Mino-Bimaadiziwin: Culturally Responsive Health Messaging in Ojibwe Communities
by
Nii Mahliaire
A dissertation accepted and approved in partial fulfillment of the 
requirements for the degree of
Doctor of Philosophy
in Communication and Media Studies
Dissertation Committee:
Dr. Dean Mundy, Chair
Dr. Autumn Shafer, Core Member
Dr. Chris Chávez, Core Member
Dr. Tiffany Brown, Core Member
Dr. Jason Younker, Cultural Advisor
Dr. Jeff Todahl, Institutional Representative
University of Oregon
Spring 2024
© 2024 Nii Mahliaire
This work is openly licensed via CC BY 4.0. 
2
DISSERTATION ABSTRACT
Nii Mahliaire
Doctor of Philosophy in Communication and Media Studies
Title: Mino-Bimaadiziwin: Culturally Responsive Health Messaging in Ojibwe Communities
In response to the opioid crisis disproportionately affecting Native American populations,
this dissertation examines the communication preferences of the Ojibwe community in Northern
Minnesota for addiction recovery program materials. It seeks to answer the question: What
preferences do Ojibwe community members have for messaging within addiction recovery
program materials, and in what ways can their preferences inform the creation of effective
communication tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources?
Employing grounded theory and Indigenous Standpoint Theory, the study unfolds in
phases, each contributing to a comprehensive understanding of effective communication
strategies within Ojibwe communities. Initial pretesting at Northern Minnesota Addiction
Wellness Center informed the development of culturally sensitive research tools, laying the
groundwork for future phases and ensuring the study's approach resonated with the cultural
context and recovery practices of the Ojibwe community.
The first phase gathers insights through interviews with a diverse group of participants:
healthcare professionals who treat opioid use disorder, community Elders, and Ojibwe
individuals who have experienced addiction recovery. These interviews aim to identify the
specific barriers and facilitators to effective communication, revealing the complexities of
addressing substance use disorder within this cultural context.
3
The second phase shifts toward active community involvement through Collaborative
Creation Circles. This approach engages Ojibwe members who are currently clients at Northern
Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center in the process of designing culturally resonant recovery
materials. This participatory co-design method ensures the materials reflect genuine recovery
narratives and empower participants to share authentically.
The final result of this research was the creation of a comprehensive website named
Mino-Bimaadiziwin, a digital resource platform inspired by the insights from the community. It
features several key components: Personal Stories, offering narratives of recovery; a Decolonial
Perspective, which challenges conventional narratives around addiction; Cultural Practices,
highlighting traditional healing and recovery methods; Artistic Representations, showcasing
community art; and an interactive map of Resources. Each element is crafted to address the
distinct needs of the Ojibwe community, aiming to provide a holistic and accessible repository of
recovery resources.
This dissertation contributes to the broader field of communication and public health by
illustrating the importance of incorporating Indigenous knowledge and perspectives into health
messaging. Through a detailed exploration of the Ojibwe community's communication
preferences, the study highlights the potential for culturally tailored messaging to enhance
engagement with recovery programs. Ultimately, it seeks to offer pathways for improving health
outcomes and well-being in Ojibwe communities, advocating for a respectful integration of
cultural values and practices in public health initiatives. This work not only addresses a critical
health issue but also reinforces the value of culturally informed research methodologies in
creating meaningful and effective health communication strategies.
4
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I owe profound gratitude to my dissertation committee for their guidance and support
throughout my academic journey. Dr. Dean Mundy, my chair, has been an unwavering pillar of
support. Despite the challenges I presented as a graduate student, his kindness, generosity with
time, and exceptional guidance have been crucial. Dr. Mundy’s ability to support even my most
outlandish decisions and sustain me during setbacks has been nothing short of remarkable.
Dr. Autumn Shafer, my first connection at the University of Oregon, ignited my passion
for analysis and introduced me to Dr. Mundy. Her insights into health communication influenced
my topic choice and approach, enriching my project immensely.
Dr. Chris Chavez briefly advised me during an important time before my comprehensive
exams, ensuring that Indigenous knowledge was integrated throughout my work and shaping my
interview methodology.
Dr. Tiffany Brown graciously allowed me access to her closed classes, providing an
unmatched learning opportunity about the clinical side of recovery during a personal time of
healing after my mother’s passing.
Dr. Jason Younker offered invaluable cultural perspectives that ensured my project was
beneficial and respectful to my community.
Dr. Jeff Todahl, as the Institutional Representative, not only joined my project but also
believed in its significance from the start.
Special thanks to Dr. Julie Newton, the Director of the Graduate Program, who supported
me through some of the darkest moments of my life and for providing me a chance to prove
myself instead of giving up.
5
Dr. Michelle Jacob’s Auntie Way Writing Retreats offered a nurturing space that
grounded me and created a community throughout the challenging phases of my dissertation.
I am grateful to all the mentors and peers in my SIGI fellowship who challenged me to
rethink my methodologies and embrace my idea of collaborative creation circles.
My gratitude also goes to my professors who helped me navigate through confusion, and
to Debra Sea, my undergraduate mentor, whose endless support and love encouraged me to
pursue graduate studies.
Thank you to my McNair Scholar family, including Kristina Cirks, who supported me
from the beginning and helped me discover my love for research.
And a thank you to my therapists, Cori and Chris, who taught me to understand the
complexities of depression and the intricate nature of emotions especially in grief.
A heartfelt thanks to the Malterud and Jennings families, whose constant encouragement
and support were crucial to my success. Without their reminders to stay focused, I would not
have reached this milestone. Thank you for supporting me through my youth to now.
My deepest appreciation extends to my family, Marcus and Legend, whose personal,
emotional, and physical sacrifices made my work possible, and to my found family who
provided laughter and light during the toughest times.
Lastly, to everyone who believed in me when I doubted myself and supported me through
moments of despair—your belief was my strength. Thank you all for being part of my journey.
6
DEDICATION
This work is dedicated to the seven generations of relatives who came before me and
those who will follow. (Especially my mother, Rosanna Sue Gordon). It is my hope that this
work not only reflects our community and its values but also brings about real and positive
changes in the lives of those who need it—both directly and indirectly. Without your guidance
and the lessons of reciprocity you have imparted, this work would not exist. Without your
influence, we would not understand the interconnectedness of life.
I could not be more grateful to have spent the last five years dedicated to understanding,
listening, and being more present in our community. This project has been a journey of healing,
both for myself and for others. It has been an opportunity to move away from mainstream
narratives and to focus deeply on the culture and community that define us. To create a body of
work that is a tribute to you and to my manidoog—this has been my honor and privilege.
In embracing this project, I have adopted the practice of living and learning as an act of
gratitude. Each interaction and every story shared has deepened my appreciation of our cultural
heritage and the enduring spirit of our people.
I express my heartfelt appreciation to the Elders and knowledge keepers who have shared
their wisdom with me. Your guidance has shed light on the complexities of our traditions and the
paths to healing. You have taught me the importance of listening intently, not only to the spoken
words but also to the quiet moments in between, where much of our truth lies. Through your
teachings, I have come to understand that healing involves not just recovery but the reclamation
and revitalization of our connections to each other and to the land.
7
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION......................................................................................................................... 12
LITERATURE REVIEW...............................................................................................................29
Tracing Opioid Use Disorder from National Concern to Community Focus.......................... 30
Stigma Reduction and Cultural Sensitivity in Recovery......................................................... 35
Prevention, Treatment, and Recovery Options........................................................................ 40
Recovery Campaigns............................................................................................................... 43
Tradition and Treatment: Tribal and Community-Based Participation....................................45
Operational Dynamics and Communication within Recovery Centers................................... 51
Communication Approaches in Recovery Messaging.............................................................53
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK.................................................................................................59
Grounded Theory..................................................................................................................... 60
Indigenous Standpoint Theory.................................................................................................61
METHODS.................................................................................................................................... 64
Pretesting at the Treatment Facility......................................................................................... 65
Phase One: Interviews..............................................................................................................68
Phase Two: Collaborative Creation Circles............................................................................. 69
Integration of Findings.............................................................................................................71
Ethical Considerations............................................................................................................. 73
FINDINGS.....................................................................................................................................76
Insights from Interview Data................................................................................................... 77
A message of sincere hopefulness..................................................................................... 80
Our language that tells our empowering stories................................................................ 92
Access to information and recovery tools........................................................................100
Interview Conclusion....................................................................................................... 116
Insights from Collaborative Creation Circles........................................................................ 117
Collaborative Creation Circles Conclusion..................................................................... 165
DISCUSSION..............................................................................................................................170
Summary of Primary Findings...............................................................................................170
Implications for Theory and Practice.....................................................................................183
Limitations and Future Research........................................................................................... 191
A Need for Future Research.................................................................................................. 194
Conclusion............................................................................................................................. 196
APPENDICES............................................................................................................................. 202
Informed Consent...................................................................................................................202
Semi-Structured Interview Questions.................................................................................... 204
Addiction Treatment Center: Creation Circles...................................................................... 205
Codebook............................................................................................................................... 206
8
Co-design Materials............................................................................................................... 211
REFERENCES............................................................................................................................ 238
9
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1a……………………………………………………………………………….. 118 & 211
Figure 1b……………………………………………………………………………….. 122 & 212
Figure 2a……………………………………………………………………………….. 124 & 213
Figure 2b……………………………………………………………………………….. 126 & 214
Figure 3………………………………………………………………………………… 128 & 215
Figure 4………………………………………………………………………………… 130 & 216
Figure 5a……………………………………………………………………………….. 132 & 217
Figure 5b……………………………………………………………………………….. 134 & 218
Figure 6………………………………………………………………………………… 135 & 219
Figure 7a……………………………………………………………………………….. 137 & 220
Figure 7b……………………………………………………………………………….. 138 & 221
Figure 8a………………………………………………………………….…………… 140 & 222
Figure 8b…………………………………………………………………..…………… 141 & 223
Figure 9………………………………………………………………………………… 143 & 224
Figure 10a……………………………………………………………………………… 144 & 225
Figure 10b……………………………………………………………………………… 145 & 226
Figure 11………………………………………………………………………..……… 147 & 227
Figure 12…………………………………………………………………………..…… 149 & 228
Figure 13…………………………………………………………………………..…… 151 & 229
Figure 14…………………………………………………………………………..…… 153 & 230
Figure 15……………………………………………………………………………..… 155 & 231
Figure 16………………………………………………………………………..……… 157 & 232
Figure 17a……………………………………………………………………………… 158 & 233
Figure 17b……………………………………………………………………………… 159 & 234
Figure 18…………………………………………………………………………..…… 160 & 235
Figure 19……………………………………………………………………………..… 162 & 236
Figure 20……………………………………………………………………………..… 163 & 237
10
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1…………………………………………………………………………………………... 31
Table 2…………………………………………………………………………………......... 31-32
Table 3…………………………………………………………………………………………... 32
11
INTRODUCTION
It is with great consideration that this dissertation begins with my positionality statement.
I have written and rewritten this more times than I can remember. It is a window into myself, my
work, my healing journey, and ultimately why this project exists. Its tone and style are
independent of my research—this is intentional. I am an artist at heart. I am a writer of poetry
and non-fiction work, even more. I share this with you as a way to frame the project and its
entirety. I share this with you in hopes that you can place yourself in my shoes—even for a brief
moment.
My positionality statement is not just my own. It is also my family’s. My mother’s.
In an effort to answer—Why this topic? Why my method? Why my perspective?
It starts with the phrase, “To exist is to resist.”
I am a two-spirit, Ojibwe, feminine-presenting person. In many aspects of my life, I was
told and shown that I didn't belong. That my ideas didn’t hold value. That my culture and my
heritage were faults and not strengths. This is a statement of this truth. This section stands by
itself and within this work.
Our voices persevere. Through the noise, through the resistance. I am not the only one
with the experiences you will read—but I am one of the few who has the privilege to write and
share these experiences.
---
I am lucky.
I am loved.
I am safe.
Now.
12
That wasn’t always the case. Much of my experience has been
crawling out of an endless hole
intended to keep me buried
beneath dualities and injustice.
It is nothing short of a miracle you are reading this.
I shouldn’t be here.
But I am
now.
People living with addiction deserve more.
People living with addiction deserve to be heard.
to be loved.
to be seen.
People living with addiction deserve your attention.
People living with addiction deserve to be healthy.
Recovery is not
Linear.
I didn’t always believe this.
I didn't always have space.
13
I couldn’t
I was also just trying to
survive.
Like everyone around me.
Like all of the stereotypes.
She was not just an addict.
She was a mother.
She was a healthcare worker.
She was a caregiver.
She loved more than anyone.
She lost even more.
She never held her head low.
She was proud.
She thrived in her community.
She made the best fry bread.
She changed peoples lives.
She was the reason why
I survived.
When my mother died - parts of me died too.
My resentment of lost time.
My guilt of never calling - enough.
14
My shame of telling this story.
I remember my mother as her whole.
The good, the rugged, the clumsy, the high, the stable, the sorrowful, the violent, the caring, the
trying, the clarity, the relapse, the hiding, the open, all of her.
I hold a lot of blame for her shame.
Though, she always respected me.
Can you hold a space for broken pieces to mend?
She could.
We sat in circles talking about the ugly.
The things people couldn’t hold - like she could.
When she died. I had a pouring of messages from people she helped.
“I know your mom had problems but she is the reason I am sober today.”
“You have no idea how your mom changed my life.”
“She had the biggest heart of anyone I’ve met.”
I am lucky.
I reconciled with my mom six years before she passed
I got to see the clarity, the life she wanted
I got the “good” years with her before she met the Creator.
15
Which makes it hard to move forward.
Because if she was in the thick of her addiction it would be “easy” to just write her off
Like everyone else did - who aren’t in the community.
“She took a pill,” my grandma on my dads side.
“She dosen’t look the same - my God what happened?” my grandma on my moms side.
“Smile!” my uncle - when I stood next to my mothers ashes at the celebration of her life.
There was no obituary.
There was a police report.
Fentanyl and a broken heart.
There was no follow-up.
No cards.
No sympathy.
I lost my friends - my family.
next after the next
people kept
falling..
my cousins
my aunts
16
my uncles
my Papa.
This isn't the end.
Of their life - or mine.
It has to be just the beginning.
So I recreated the talking circles with my mom.
To talk about the hard shit without sensor
the mud, the thick, the real
to be vulnerable in a safe space without repercussion.
Addicts helping addicts.
Or.. helpers helping heal.
There’s something of surprise
opening up vulnerabilities - re-wounding
in a space for people with wounds
Heals.
What spaces like this exist?
With a new emergence of spirituality and reconciliation
There is more access - but do people know?
17
What do these messages look like?
Not the people I love.
This needs to be recreated.
For vulnerability, for truth.
I decided to go on my own healing journey
to walk the Red Road.
Not for data, not for research.
For myself.
For my community.
For my Mom.
So we sat in talking circles
We made art
We healed together.
In all of the messy ways.
I was vulnerable
I was disconnected
I was lost
18
too.
Who I talked to was intentional.
I wanted to talk to people in their healing
following that Red Road.
People who deserve it.
People who are often cast aside.
There is empowerment there.
Who do we talk to when finding “help?”
What do these messages look like?
National messaging is just that - national
not personal.
What works here?
Vulnerability.
So this is me-
I am white passing.
My skin a duality.
My heritage too.
My mother Ojibwe
19
My father - French and German
People made me believe
I didn’t belong
in either world.
This journey was about reconnecting
To myself
To the Creator
and to my Manidoog.
I am loved.
By the spirits that never left me
just waiting for me to find myself again.
I wanted it to mean something more.
More than deadlines and a degree.
More than status and position.
So..
I listened, I wrote, I cried, I re-wounded, I screamed in the woods, I layed in the dirt, I went
inside myself - the deepest parts, and I showed it to others.
But some Elders didn't want to talk to me
20
because I sold my soul to the institution
because I do the “white-mans” work.
I still didn't belong.
I nearly didn't finish.
I nearly gave up.
I nearly left Mother Earth.
But the Creator has a funny way of showing you
purpose.
I sat alone
in my sorrow
in my grief
crying at a picnic table at the park
a small yippie dog came up to me
licked my legs
I didn't know how to respond but laugh
with tears down my face
the dog stayed
21
the owner followed
he was Paiute
and asked about my day
knowing I was in a bad place
the words overcame me
poured out like a broken dam
flooding the air
I was holding onto everything
by myself
I didn't truly let go
We sat there
I re-wounded
the dog licked me
he patched me up
He said
“it's always about the bigger picture, little sister”
to find community and share my bad medicine
because its too much for one person to hold
22
He said
I can lean on my people and my community
that Elders are there for people like me
But I was so distant
I didn't feel like I was allowed
to heal or to be healthy
He said
Creator gave you purpose
to heal with others in this pain
find those people on the Red Road
Often I have felt unseen
I can only imagine how my mother felt
In this moment my new brother saw me
saw my light and my purpose
I believe the Creator sends us messages
when we want to listen
we really hear them
This work was always meant to be
23
it’s why I am here
I have finally accepted that
and whatever hills I have
along my way
I am safe, now.
This work is meant to be real
to have tangible meaning in my community
to be accessible
to be reciprocal
to help light the eight fire
I won’t deny the amount of myself that exists in this work because it is me. I won't try and
convince you this is the best route - because I am still learning. But I do think that there is value
here.
Rich, cultural, and personal value.
There are parts of my mom, my participants-my community, and myself.
Through this work, I don't intend to change you.
I only hope you can hear us.
---
24
The opioid epidemic has had a profound impact on families and communities in the
United States; nearly 645,000 people died from overdoses involving any opioid, including
prescription and illicit opioids, from 1999-2021 (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,
2022). Certain groups, notably those released from incarceration or experiencing homelessness,
were identified as particularly vulnerable to this crisis (Humphreys et al., 2022). Additionally,
the stigma associated with opioid use disorder (OUD) and substance use disorder (SUD) posed
barriers for individuals affected by opioid use disorder, complicating their efforts to seek
treatment and support (Kennedy-Hendricks et al., 2017).
Despite perceptions that opioid use disorder affects all demographics equally, Native
American populations have been disproportionately burdened by the opioid epidemic
(Kennedy-Hendricks et al., 2016; Humphreys et al., 2022). The standard treatment for opioid use
disorder, which typically follows a secular, Western model, often conflicts with Indigenous
healing practices that prioritize spirituality and holistic wellness. In Ojibwe communities for
example, the medicine wheel and prayer circles are often incorporated in the healing process
(Venner et al., 2018). In this research, I note the same reflection occurs in communication
materials for these services. This mismatch highlighted the necessity for exploring effective
communication modes that could convey information about opioid use disorder recovery
resources and resonate to Ojibwe communities.
Rosanna Sue Gordon, a 44-year-old Ojibwe woman, achieved three years of sobriety
before a tragic relapse and untimely death in 2020. Having battled opioid use disorder for a
decade, Rosanna cycled through various treatment centers with no lasting success until she
engaged with Four Winds Healing and Recovery Center in Brainerd, Minnesota. This center's
holistic approach, which integrated input from Elders, personalized treatment plans, and
25
addressed physical, mental, spiritual, and cultural health, laid the groundwork for Rosanna's
recovery. As research indicates, the path to recovery from this disorder is not linear, with high
relapse rates persisting even after successful detoxification. Relapse rates range from 72 -88%
within 12–36 months following opioid detoxification (Chalana, H. et al., 2015). This emphasizes
the critical need for effective treatment options and continued research on culturally relevant and
holistic support methods for Indigenous communities.
The Midwest Initiative emerged as a collaborative effort to tackle the opioid crisis in
rural and tribal communities, including Indigenous groups (Pew Charitable Trusts, 2021).
Partnering with various stakeholders, such as schools, tribal leadership, and public health
agencies, the campaign developed localized, culturally tailored solutions for opioid use disorder
treatment (Pew Charitable Trusts, 2021). By integrating traditional healing practices, advocating
for harm reduction training, and organizing community forums to combat stigma, the Midwest
Initiative showcased the potential of culturally sensitive communication strategies in effectively
disseminating information on opioid use disorder recovery systems to Indigenous communities
(Pew Charitable Trusts, 2021). This initiative's achievements show the importance of cultural
relevance and collaboration in devising strategies to address the opioid epidemic in Indigenous
settings.
This dissertation explores the question of what preferences Ojibwe community members
in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within addiction recovery program materials, and
how these preferences could guide the creation of effective communication tools to encourage
engagement with available recovery resources. Utilizing a grounded theory approach (Charmaz,
2014; Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019; Ellingson & Borofka, 2014; Martin et al., 2018) in
combination with Indigenous standpoint theory (Foley, 2007; Moreton-Robinson, 2013; Nakata,
26
2007), this research prioritizes Indigenous knowledge and perspectives in exploring
communication strategies.
Phase one centers on community and tribal-based participatory resources for recovery,
creating trust and collaborative opportunities to guarantee cultural relevance (Venner et al.,
2018). By conducting 24 interviews with clinical staff who treat opioid use disorder, community
Elders participating in program implementation, and Ojibwe community members who have
personal experiences with opioid use disorder, this phase provides an in-depth understanding of
the communication barriers, facilitators, and cultural nuances in substance use disorder treatment
and recovery in Ojibwe communities.
Phase two introduced Collaborative Creation Circles, engaging 18 Ojibwe community
members in in-patient treatment to partake in a creative process aimed at developing brochure or
flyer materials. This activity promoted a supportive community atmosphere, inviting participants
to create materials that resonated with them personally, reflecting meaningful aspects of their
healing journey. The activity aimed to produce flyers or brochures that were not only
eye-catching but also authentically represented the participants' experiences and insights during
recovery.
Building on the insights gathered in earlier phases, the project entered its final phase:
implementation of findings. This stage was about turning the information gathered from the
community and the collaborative creations into practical solutions. The result was the creation
of a comprehensive website named Mino-Bimaadiziwin. This website is structured around
several key themes: Personal Stories, featuring real-life experiences; a Decolonial Perspective,
offering educational insights on addiction; Cultural Practices, spotlighting traditional ceremonies
and the Red Road; Artistic Representation, showcasing community-inspired art; and
27
Accessibility to Resources, which includes an interactive map and a list of health resources.
Together, these themes inform a platform designed to support the community's specific needs.
This study uses grounded theory and Indigenous standpoint theory to enhance our
understanding of how to effectively communicate about recovery resources with Ojibwe
communities. It focuses on developing outreach and messaging strategies that are specifically
designed for the unique cultural and contextual needs of Ojibwe peoples. The goal is to empower
Ojibwe individuals on their paths to recovery, aiming to improve their overall health and
well-being.
28
LITERATURE REVIEW
This literature review critically examines the prevailing challenges and considerations in
addressing opioid use disorder, with a specific focus on Indigenous communities. By exploring
the nature of opioid use disorder, its societal impacts, and existing strategies for treatment and
recovery, this review sets the groundwork for investigating how communication and messaging
strategies can be specifically tailored to meet the unique needs and preferences of the Ojibwe
community.
The review begins with a definition of opioid use disorder, emphasizing both the medical
and societal frameworks that influence our understanding and responses to this condition. This
foundational discussion is vital for anchoring our exploration in the realities of opioid use
disorder and the broader context of addiction.
I shift the attention to demographic considerations, particularly the impact of opioid use
disorder on Indigenous populations. Understanding the unique challenges and barriers faced in
accessing recovery resources is crucial for developing culturally sensitive and effective
communication tools.
Then, I examine the variety of treatment and recovery options that are currently available,
looking into how effective and accessible they are. This part of the review pays special attention
to the methods used at these services and how the community perceives these efforts. It aims to
uncover the disconnect between the resources offered and the communication of these services to
the Ojibwe community.
At the center of this review is the critical role of communication in enhancing
engagement with addiction recovery programs. I look into the significance of culturally
competent messaging, how community-specific preferences might impact the effectiveness of
29
recovery programs, and the existing shortcomings in the way these programs are communicated
to the Ojibwe community.
This literature review aims to provide a thorough understanding of the complex factors
that influence addiction recovery within Indigenous communities. It lays the essential foundation
for my research question: What preferences do Ojibwe community members in Northern
Minnesota have for messaging within addiction recovery program materials? In what ways can
their preferences inform the creation of effective communication tools that encourage
engagement with available recovery resources? Addressing this question seeks to bridge the
existing gap between the needs of the Ojibwe community and the design of recovery program
communication materials, aiming for a more inclusive and effective approach to addressing
opioid use disorder.
Tracing Opioid Use Disorder from National Concern to Community Focus
This section traces the understanding of opioid use disorder, moving from its general
impact across the United States to its specific repercussions within Indigenous communities.
According to the American Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition
(DSM-5, 2013), opioid use disorder encompasses a spectrum of symptoms, including an inability
to control opioid usage, persistent use despite attempts to stop, social impairment, cravings,
development of tolerance, and withdrawal symptoms. Societal interpretations often mislabel
opioid use disorder as merely a matter of personal choice, ignoring the medical perspective that
identifies it as a disease impacting the brain's decision-making capabilities (Bagley & Beckham,
2020; Bahorik et al., 2017).
30
Opioid use disorder represents a public health crisis in the United States, affecting
individuals across all age groups. Data from 2021 reveal that about 2.0 percent of the population
aged 12 or older, equating to roughly 5.6 million people, were diagnosed with opioid use
disorder (SAMHSA, 2021). This prevalence varies across different age and racial groups,
indicating the need for customized approaches to prevention and treatment. Notably, Asian
communities exhibit a lower prevalence of opioid use disorder compared to other racial and
ethnic groups, with disparities evident across demographics (SAMHSA, 2021). Prevalence rates
of these disorders varied, with Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander groups reporting a rate
of 1.5 percent, and American Indian or Alaska Native populations experiencing a higher rate of
4.4 percent (SAMHSA, 2021).
Table 1
Disorder 12 or Older 12 to 17 18 to 25 26 or Older
Opioid Use 2.0 percent (.10) 1.0 percent (.14) 1.3 percent (.16) 2.2 percent (.13)
Disorder (OUD) or 5.6 million or 259,000 or 438,000 or 4.9 million
people people people people
Information from (SAMHSA, 2021).
*Estimates shown are percentages with standard errors included in parentheses.
NOTE: Additional estimates may be found in Results from the 2021 National Survey on Drug
Use and Health: Detailed Tables here. Measures and terms are defined in Appendix A of the
2021 Detailed Tables.
Table 2
Race Opioid Use Disorder (OUD)
White 2.0 (0.13)
Black or African American 2.4 (0.32)
American Indian or Alaska Native 4.4 (1.51)
Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander 1.5 (0.90)
31
Asian 0.7 (0.17)
Multicultural 2.6 (0.62)
Hispanic or Latino 1.9 (0.26)
Not Hispanic or Latino 2.0 (0.11)
*Estimates shown are percentages with standard errors included in parentheses.
Information from (SAMHSA, 2021).
The role of media in public education on opioid use disorder is crucial yet often limited.
Investigations into "solutions journalism" reveal a tendency to mention treatment, harm
reduction, and prevention, but there's a notable lack of coverage on evidence-based public health
solutions like medication-assisted treatment and harm reduction strategies such as syringe
services programs and safe consumption sites (McGinty et al., 2019). This gap suggests a
potential shortfall in public knowledge regarding the risks and available treatments for opioid use
disorder (Kilgo & Midberry, 2020).
From 1999 to 2009, the opioid crisis severely affected Indigenous communities in the
United States, leading to the highest death rates from opioid pain relievers, especially in
Minnesota, Washington, Alaska, and Oklahoma (Soto et al., 2019). Alarmingly, 47% of
Indigenous young adults aged 18 to 25 have used opioids, exceeding the 5% national average
(SAMHSA, 2022). Despite the severity, detailed data on specific tribes is lacking.
Table 3
State Opioid-Related Deaths
Minnesota 26/100,000
Washington 21/100,000
Alaska and Oklahoma 13/100,000
Information from (Venner et al., 2018)
32
The path to recovery from substance use is uniquely personal, with its definition varying
widely among individuals. Hser and colleagues' 2015 meta-analysis looks into the nuances of
recovery, examining the opioid crisis's long-term effects, including key moments of change and
supportive factors. Their findings cover a range of outcomes such as relapse, abstinence, mental
health status, support networks, recovery statistics, mortality rates, and the exploration of new
treatments. They stress the importance of accurately conveying these findings to the public to
transform the narrative around substance use from one of personal failure to a call for
compassionate support (Hser et al., 2015).
In treating substance use disorders, the prevailing methods often reflect a Western-centric
approach, focusing primarily on medical and psychological interventions. This stands in contrast
to Indigenous healing practices, which place a greater emphasis on spirituality and holistic
wellness. Indigenous traditions, such as those practiced by communities in the Great Lakes area,
integrate teachings like the medicine wheel and prayer circles into recovery, offering a
comprehensive view of health that encompasses mental, physical, emotional, and spiritual
well-being (Momper et al., 2017; Venner et al., 2018). This holistic perspective is often
overlooked in mainstream treatment models, which typically prioritize biological factors.
The current healthcare and treatment infrastructure largely overlooks the specific needs of
Indigenous populations. There's a knowledge gap concerning the effectiveness of substance use
disorder treatment among Indigenous communities in the United States, partly due to the
exclusion of these groups from broader research efforts (Rieckmann, 2016). This issue is
compounded by systemic funding shortfalls and a critical shortage of mental health professionals
in areas predominantly inhabited by Indigenous people (Rieckmann, 2016).
33
Historical mistrust toward healthcare providers, rooted in past exploitation and negative
experiences, further complicates the provision of effective care in Indigenous communities
(Rieckmann, 2016). Despite attempts to enhance the quality of both tribal and urban treatment
services, a lack of data on what constitutes successful, culturally sensitive care remains a barrier.
There's a pressing need for collaboration with Indigenous communities to develop and
implement comprehensive, long-term treatment and prevention strategies that honor cultural
practices (Rieckmann, 2016).
Addressing health disparities stemming from opioid use requires a united effort that
merges Western and Indigenous approaches. Venner and colleagues emphasize the importance of
a mutual relationship in the creation of interventions, advocating for a collaboration where
researchers from academic and community backgrounds work together on an equal footing. This
partnership aims to develop strategies that honor cultural significance while being rooted in
scientific evidence (Venner et al., 2018). Such cooperation is crucial in enhancing care and
assistance for individuals with opioid use disorder, ensuring that the approach is respectful and
inclusive of diverse community values and practices. Central to this collaborative process is the
goal of changing perceptions, moving away from labeling individuals with substance use as
simply "addicts with a choice" and toward acknowledging them as "individuals in need of
support" (Hser et al., 2015, p. 80).
This section explored how understanding of opioid use disorder has evolved from a
national concern to its impact on Indigenous communities. It defines the disorder as complex,
challenging the misconception that it's simply a matter of choice, and notes the high prevalence
in the U.S., especially among Indigenous populations, where effects are disproportionately
severe. The lack of media attention to effective treatments and detailed data on Indigenous
34
impacts is highlighted, alongside the contrast between Western and Indigenous recovery
approaches. The healthcare system's shortcomings in addressing Indigenous needs are
emphasized, pointing to a need for a unified approach that blends medical practices with
traditional healing. Overall, advocating for partnerships that respect cultural practices and aim to
change the narrative around substance use to one of support and inclusivity.
Stigma Reduction and Cultural Sensitivity in Recovery
Understanding the nuances of opioid use disorder means recognizing the roles stigma and
cultural sensitivity play in recovery. This section looks at these themes, highlighting why
compassionate, culturally-aware approaches support individuals toward healing.
Opioid use disorder presents a complex challenge that affects individuals and
communities across various dimensions, including health, social integration, and access to care.
Stigma related to opioid use disorder can be categorized into public, self, and provider stigma,
each stemming from and contributing to negative beliefs and attitudes. These stigmas often arise
from stereotypes that paint individuals with opioid use disorder as immoral, irresponsible, or
lacking willpower. The sources of such stigma are varied, including media portrayals, healthcare
professionals' attitudes, and general public opinion, all of which can reinforce negative
stereotypes and contribute to the challenges faced by those seeking recovery (Volkow, 2018;
Kasmin, 2019; Taylor et al., 2021; Barry et al., 2014).
The choice of language when discussing opioid use disorder influences perceptions and
attitudes toward the condition and those affected by it. Derogatory terms and labels can
exacerbate stigma, while respectful, non-judgmental language can help reduce it. Adopting
person-first language in a healthcare setting is crucial for stigma reduction, as labels like
35
"substance abuser" or "addict" can worsen stigma (McGinty & Barry, 2020). Likewise, using
neutral terms such as "substance use disorder" instead of "addiction" helps diminish negative
associations with opioid use disorder (Kelly et al., 2010). This approach not only alters
perception but also encourages individuals to seek and adhere to treatment by creating a more
supportive environment (McGinty & Barry, 2020; Kelly et al., 2010; Kelly, 2016).
Addressing opioid use disorder in Indigenous communities highlights the critical role of
cultural sensitivity in recovery messaging. The research by Boyd et al. (2021) investigates the
treatment of opioid use disorder within an American Indian community in Minnesota,
emphasizing the importance of cultural sensitivity. It suggests that incorporating elements like
the Ojibwe language into recovery programs could improve their effectiveness by making them
more relatable and credible to the community members, thereby enhancing their engagement and
overall understanding of the recovery process (Boyd et al., 2021). This principle aligns with
broader initiatives, such as the HEALing Communities study and Native Center for Behavioral
Health programs, which have demonstrated that culturally sensitive methods can reduce stigma
and create the adoption of evidence-based practices for recovery, promoting more effective
engagement and outcomes in Indigenous populations (Lefebvre et al., 2020; Skinstad, 2021).
The intersection of stigma reduction and cultural sensitivity reveals how addressing one
can inform and strengthen the other. By recognizing the compounded barriers faced by
Indigenous populations due to both stigma and cultural insensitivity, we can develop more
inclusive and effective strategies. Integrating culturally relevant language and practices into
stigma reduction efforts not only addresses the specific needs of diverse populations but also
enriches the overall approach navigating the opioid epidemic.
36
It is essential to incorporate evidence-based practices that recognize the importance of
both language and cultural sensitivity. Healthcare providers, media, and policymakers should
adopt person-first and neutral language, while also integrating culturally relevant messaging in
their communication strategies toward Indigenous populations. Tailoring communication efforts
to each community is vital because the meanings and subtleties of language vary across different
groups. Engaging directly with communities to discover what resonates with them ensures that
messaging is relevant and impactful. Understanding a community's specific cultural and
linguistic preferences is key to creating effective communication materials that genuinely
connect and address community needs. Such practices contribute to a more supportive
environment for Indigenous individuals with opioid use disorder, facilitating better engagement
with treatment and recovery services.
This section explored how reducing stigma and being culturally sensitive are key in
helping people recover from opioid use disorder. It talks about how negative views and
stereotypes can make it harder for people to seek help and highlights the importance of using
respectful language to change these perceptions. The text also points out the special role of
culture in recovery, especially in Indigenous communities, suggesting that including cultural
elements in treatment could make it more effective. By combining efforts to reduce stigma with a
deep understanding of cultural values, the discussion suggests a more welcoming and effective
approach to recovery. It encourages everyone involved—from healthcare providers to
policymakers—to adopt language and practices that respect cultural differences, aiming to make
recovery support more inclusive and helpful.
37
The Role of Social Support and Communal Kinship in Recovery
This section explores the critical role of social support and communal kinship in the
recovery process from opioid use disorder. It looks into how interconnectedness, support
networks, and the broad definition of family within communities, particularly among Indigenous
populations like the Ojibwe, contribute to successful recovery outcomes.
“Most [people with opioid use disorder] acknowledged that it is extremely difficult to
overcome opioid addiction alone. It is necessary for those dealing with addiction to seek out
social support, and it is the responsibility of everybody else to offer social support to those we
know are experiencing addiction” (Bagley & Beckham, 2020, p. 6). Studies highlight the crucial
role of social connections in improving health and well-being, especially when dealing with
stress, mental health problems, chronic diseases, and opioid addiction (Cohen, Underwood, &
Gottlieb, 2000; Sarason & Sarason, 2009). Social support includes a range of assistance within
relationships, from emotional encouragement to hands-on help, and is essential for recovery
(House, 1981). This kind of support can come from professionals like doctors and counselors, or
from unpaid individuals such as mentors, volunteers, and notably, family and friends (McCrady
et al., 2012; McCamish-Svensson et al., 1999).
In the context of opioid use disorder, the concept of "family" or found-family plays is
deeply influential. These support networks offer more than just encouragement; they affect
decision-making and are key in understanding how recovery works in the context of substance
use (McCrady et al., 2012). Although social support can lead to both good and bad
outcomes—improving well-being or potentially encouraging unhealthy habits—the focus is on
creating supportive, positive relationships (Antonucci, 1985; Wilcox & Vernberg, 1985).
38
Transitioning from a broader context to a more focused examination of recovery support,
it becomes evident how deeply ingrained these communal values are in creating environments
supporting to overcoming addiction. Elders in Indigenous communities, including Ojibwe, play a
core role that extends the concept of family beyond biological ties, embracing a broader
definition of kinship and connection. This perspective on family relationships highlights the idea
that family encompasses not only those to whom we are related by blood but also those with
whom we share deep communal ties, cultural values, traditions, and experiences.
Drawing on my personal experience as a member of the Ojibwe community, this view of
family includes individuals who may not be blood relatives but are considered family members
due to shared upbringing, cultural practices, and collective identity. For example, individuals
raised in the same area, participating in the same tribal rituals, and taught the same values and
beliefs are often regarded as cousins or even siblings, despite the absence of direct biological
connections. This inclusive understanding of family reflects the communal ethos of Ojibwe
culture, where relationships are built and valued based on shared experiences, mutual support,
and collective well-being, rather than solely on genetic ties.
Elders are the keepers of traditional knowledge, values, and practices, often guiding
health-related decisions and contributing to the development of community policies and
programs (Bartlett et al., 2007; Strickland, 2006; LaVeaux & Christopher, 2009). Their deep
understanding of the interconnectedness of physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual well-being
offers a unique and invaluable form of support, highlighting the cultural dimension of recovery
support networks.
Moving from the cultural foundations to the application of these values in recovery, it is
essential to recognize the role of direct community involvement. Family and community
39
involvement stands as a cornerstone in overcoming opioid use disorder, offering indispensable
encouragement and resources. This support extends to facilitating access to recovery services
like Medication-Assisted Treatment (MAT) or residential treatment, which are crucial for
recovery (Laudet et al., 2015). Such involvement is particularly impactful for youths with opioid
use disorder, showing support, connectedness, and backing that's essential for successful
recovery (Leshner, 2003; Ling et al., 2019; Nash et al., 2019).
Building upon the crucial role of community in recovery, we see firsthand accounts that
vividly bring to life the impact of peer-to-peer relationships. One individual recounts "I had a
couple overdoses and reached out for help. I’ve got 6 ½ months clean. The only reason is from
help from other alcoholics and drug addicts" (Bagley & Beckham, 2020, p. 6).
In summary, social support and a sense of community are important for people recovering
from opioid use disorder, especially in Indigenous communities. It highlights that recovery isn't
something people can often do on their own—they need a strong support system. This includes
help from professionals like doctors and counselors, as well as from friends, family, and even the
wider community. The idea of "family" here goes beyond just blood relatives. It includes anyone
who shares a close bond through culture, traditions, or shared experiences. Elders play a special
role, offering wisdom and guidance that's crucial for recovery. The section also points out that
being part of a community, where people understand and support each other, can make a big
difference in overcoming addiction. This kind of support can come in many forms, like helping
someone get into treatment programs or just being there for them.
40
Prevention, Treatment, and Recovery Options
This section discusses the comprehensive approach required in addressing substance use
disorder, highlighting the integration of prevention, treatment, and recovery strategies. It
emphasizes the importance of tackling root causes, offering personalized care, and ensuring
sustained support for recovery.
Prevention is a cornerstone in the framework of recovery systems, placing a strong
emphasis on confronting the foundational issues such as poverty, trauma, and mental health
concerns. Initiatives centered on education, launching awareness campaigns, engaging with
communities directly, and advocating for policy reforms are all crucial actions in this initial stage
(Doyle & McGaffey, 2022). Beyond these efforts, it's equally critical to provide support that
addresses the social and economic challenges people face, which might be a factor in a person's
choice to engage with substances amid stress and pressure. This includes facilitating access to
housing and offering assistance to secure employment (Ling et al., 2019).
Moreover, an important part of creating a supportive environment for those who have
opioid use disorder is the active reduction of stigma. Through public education campaigns,
strategic media storytelling, and advocating for changes in policies, it becomes possible to
encourage individuals to seek the help they need while also working toward minimizing
instances of discrimination and judgment they may face (Nash, Hennessy, & Collier, 2019).
Prevention not only aims at directly addressing the immediate challenges but also at creating an
understanding, supportive, and inclusive community for individuals navigating their journey to
recovery.
Personalized treatment plans may include a blend of pharmacological interventions,
psychotherapeutic approaches, and supportive services such as participation in peer support
41
groups, guidance from recovery coaches, and involvement in family therapy sessions (Pfefferle,
Karon, & Wyant, 2019; Volkow, 2018). These treatment modalities can be augmented with
evidence-based methodologies like medication-assisted treatment (MAT) and
cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), proven to mitigate cravings and withdrawal symptoms
while tackling underlying psychosocial issues such as trauma and mental health concerns
(SAMHSA, 2022; Leshner & Dzau, 2019). The inclusion of supportive services and strategies to
overcome social and economic challenges is critical for maintaining long-term recovery
(Pfefferle, Karon, & Wyant, 2019; Volkow, 2018; Ling et al., 2019).
Harm reduction approaches acknowledge the reality that abstinence may not be feasible
for everyone, offering interventions such as supervised consumption sites and naloxone to reduce
the harm associated with drug use (Wakeman, 2019). Innovations like the Peer Alerting Lifeline
application provide tailored health support and emergency responses via a text-based system,
supplementing traditional emergency medical services while minimizing stigma and housing
security threats. Exemplifying technology's potential to provide tailored health support and
emergency responses (Tofighi et al., 2015).
Recovery support services offer a range of resources aimed at sustaining recovery,
including support for housing and employment, alongside peer support networks. These services
facilitate access to treatment and additional supports such as mental health care and substance
use disorder therapies (Doyle & McGaffey, 2022). For people with opioid use disorder,
alternative treatments might involve techniques like auricular acupuncture, mindfulness practices
tailored to recovery, and the integration of spiritual elements into healing processes (Venner et
al., 2018).
42
In summary, recovery systems for opioid use disorder encompass prevention strategies,
personalized treatment, recovery support services, strategies addressing social and economic
factors, and efforts to reduce opioid use disorder associated with stigma.
Recovery Campaigns
This section explores various campaigns aimed at addressing the opioid epidemic,
highlighting efforts to increase awareness about treatment and prevention strategies for opioid
use disorder. From community-focused initiatives to digital platforms supporting healthcare
professionals, each campaign brings forward unique outreach and solutions.
A variety of communication campaigns have been launched to reduce harm of the opioid
epidemic and spread awareness about treatments and preventive measures for opioid use
disorder. The Opioid Response Network (ORN), backed by the Substance Abuse and Mental
Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), stands out as a holistic effort providing training and
technical support to communities healing from the opioid crisis. This initiative aims to equip
communities with the educational tools and support needed to address opioid use disorder and
prevent overdoses (Opioid Response Network, 2022).
The Truth About Opioids campaign, started by the Truth Initiative along with the Office
of National Drug Control Policy (ONDCP) and the Ad Council, uses moving, emotional stories
to teach young adults about the dangers of opioid misuse (Truth Initiative et al., 2018).
OpiSafe represents a digital solution offering a suite of tools and resources designed to
assist healthcare professionals in the management of patients dealing with chronic pain and
opioid use disorder. It serves up a compilation of educational content, guidelines, and best
43
practices aimed at enhancing the handling of opioid-related challenges within healthcare settings
(OpiSafe, 2023).
The Rx Awareness campaign, introduced by the Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC), focuses on elevating public understanding of the hazards tied to prescription
opioid use. Featuring personal accounts from individuals impacted by opioid use disorder, this
campaign delivers a wealth of educational materials and resources aimed at curtailing opioid
abuse (CDC, 2021).
Highlighted within
this effort is the
campaign's outreach
to Indigenous
communities in the
United States, the
image presented
showcases the Rx Awareness Campaign's effort to connect with the community.
The image appeared on the homepage of their website (CDC, 2021). Clicking the image
leads to a story featuring Stevi Rae, an Alaska Native who has been on the path to recovery for
over two years. Her journey toward healing is closely tied to undergoing treatment among her
Alaska Native peers. The onset of Stevi Rae's struggle with opioid use disorder followed a car
accident, prompting her to pursue treatment in Dillingham, Alaska. Surrounded by a community
of Alaska Natives, the act of sharing her experiences with trauma and childhood sexual abuse has
been important to her recovery process. Currently, she is dedicated to developing recovery
resources in her home community of Naknek.
44
While the described campaigns make strides in the opioid crisis, it's critical to recognize
their limited focus on Indigenous populations and the lack of inclusion of tribal and
community-based involvement. The broad messaging and approaches of these initiatives might
not align well with the distinct cultural, historical, and social backgrounds of Indigenous
communities across the United States, potentially affecting the relevance and effectiveness of
these efforts. This situation highlights the necessity for more focused and culturally sensitive
communication strategies. Tailoring information dissemination about substance use disorder
recovery to Indigenous communities and ensuring active participation from the community the
messages are for are crucial steps toward creating and executing messaging that is culturally
resonant and impactful.
Exploring various campaigns aimed at the opioid epidemic reveals diverse efforts to raise
awareness about treatment and prevention, from community initiatives to digital tools for
healthcare providers. Among them, the Opioid Response Network, the Truth About Opioids,
OpiSafe, and the CDC's Rx Awareness campaign stand out for their unique approaches to
outreach and education. Despite their contributions, there's a noticeable gap in addressing the
specific needs of Indigenous populations, with limited focus on tribal and community-based
involvement. This lack of culturally sensitive communication strategies highlights the
importance of tailoring recovery messaging to Indigenous communities, ensuring their active
participation for truly impactful and resonant messaging. Developing strategies that align with
the cultural, historical, and social contexts of Indigenous populations is crucial for enhancing the
relevance and effectiveness of opioid epidemic efforts.
45
Tradition and Treatment: Tribal and Community-Based Participation
In the context of addressing substance use disorders within Indigenous communities, the
role of tribal and community-based participation cannot be overstated. Such participatory
approaches, including tribal and community-based participatory research (CBPR), are
indispensable in providing recovery strategies that are culturally congruent and impactful for
Indigenous populations. By creating a collaborative research environment that prioritizes the
culture, values, and priorities of the community, these spaces provide a nuanced understanding of
the specific needs and perspectives of Indigenous communities facing the substance use disorder.
Here I explore how these foundational strategies translate into practical, community-tailored
recovery services and initiatives, demonstrating their effectiveness in bridging traditional
knowledge with contemporary healthcare practices.
Tribal and community-based participatory research (CBPR) is essential for creating
communication strategies that are both culturally relevant and effective for Indigenous
communities. This method emphasizes working closely with community members,
organizations, and stakeholders throughout the research process, ensuring that initiatives are
aligned with the community's culture, values, and priorities (Boyd et al., 2021; Skinstad, 2021).
CBPR is particularly valuable in addressing the opioid crisis within Indigenous communities,
offering a detailed insight into their specific needs and views (Soto et al., 2019). Various studies
have successfully employed this approach to craft communication campaigns that not only
reduce stigma but also advocate for proven treatment methods and support for opioid use
disorder (Lefebvre et al., 2020). By actively involving Indigenous communities in the research
process, tribal and CBPR methods pave the way for the creation of culturally attuned, relevant,
and impactful strategies that enhance opioid use disorder recovery efforts.
46
Furthermore, tribal and CBPR methods present an opportunity to tackle the opioid crisis
within Indigenous populations effectively. By creating a cooperative, community-led research
environment, these methods help close the gap between Indigenous peoples and health
professionals (Boyd et al., 2021). This collaborative approach allows Indigenous communities to
directly contribute to developing communication strategies that mirror their unique cultural
values, beliefs, and priorities, leading to interventions that are not only more culturally fitting but
also more impactful. Additionally, such collaborative efforts foster trust and strong relationships
between Indigenous communities and researchers, essential elements for successful engagement
and outreach. In essence, leveraging tribal and CBPR methods can enhance health outcomes for
Indigenous communities affected by opioid use disorder, creating communication strategies that
accurately meet their distinct needs and perspectives.
As such approaches lay the groundwork for bridging cultural understandings and
healthcare practices, let's examine how these methodologies manifest in tangible recovery
services within Indigenous communities.
In rural areas that cater to Indigenous populations, Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) open
meetings, Recovery Support Services, and Wellbriety stand out as primary recovery services
(Roubideaux, 2011; New Spirit, 2016). While AA meetings are widespread, the range of
treatment services such as individual and group therapy, along with psychiatric education, is
notably less diverse than in urban settings (Roubideaux, 2011). Moreover, traditional practices
like Talking Circles and cultural activities—beading, dancing, drumming, and hide-tanning—are
available but limited (Rieckmann, 2016; Allen, 2018; Momper, 2017).
Garrett and Carroll (2000) highlight the importance of the Sacred Circle and Good
Medicine, illustrating how cultural perspectives on wellness are crucial for Indigenous healing.
47
They argue that substance use disorder stems from generational trauma and sociodemographic
factors. Recovery centers focusing on cultural, spiritual, and physical wellness have seen positive
outcomes by incorporating tribal-specific spiritual practices and employing positive psychology
to build gradual and sustained recovery (Lowery, 1998). The Wellbriety movement and White
Bison, Inc., spearhead holistic wellness and sobriety in Indigenous communities, focusing on
healing from alcohol and substance use disorder through culturally relevant programs (Coyhis &
Simonelli, 2006). White Bison, established by Don Coyhis in 1988, combines traditional
teachings with evidence-based practices to tackle the root causes of substance use disorders and
facilitate healing (White Bison, 2023).
Other programs White Bison has developed, include Mending Broken Hearts, designed to
help participants heal from grief, loss, and unresolved trauma experienced by Indigenous
communities, and The Red Road to Wellbriety, a book that provides guidance on embracing the
Wellbriety lifestyle, integrating Indigenous wisdom and teachings with recovery principles
(Coyhis & Simonelli, 2006). The Wellbriety Training Institute offers training and certification for
individuals aspiring to become facilitators of White Bison's programs within their communities
(White Bison, 2023).
Different Indigenous tribes and bands are developing innovative strategies to support
their youth. In Alaska, the Qungasvik (Toolbox) program targets 12 to 18-year-olds with
interventions rooted in traditional teachings to strengthen community bonds and cultural identity
(Allen, 2018). Similarly, in the Great Lakes region, Talking Circles led by Elders offer a space
for cross-generational dialogue on substance use and recovery, highlighting the power of
community support and traditional healing methods (Momper, 2017).
48
Another approach in Beltrami County offers medical-focused treatment plans supported
by the Indian Health System (IHS) and the Indian Health Service National Tribal Advisory
Committee on Behavior Health (NTAC), although culturally relevant behavioral health activities
are rare (Roubideaux, 2011). The Bemidji Area Office, catering to federally recognized tribes,
emphasizes balance and harmony in their healthcare approach, striving to rebalance patients'
perspectives toward health and wellness (Roubideaux, 2011). The Bemidji Area Office provides
funding and healthcare support for about 102,782 active substance users residing in Minnesota,
Wisconsin, Michigan, Indiana, and Illinois. They serve 34 federally recognized tribes within the
Great Lakes region and operate two short-stay medical hospitals, three ambulatory health
centers, and five health stations. Their main values are balance and harmony, which they strive to
achieve by rebalancing patients' thinking and improving their health and well-being
(Roubideaux, 2011).
To address the scarcity of culturally sensitive behavioral health services in Beltrami
County, Fond du Lac Behavioral Health has launched an innovative treatment initiative known as
the Miikanaake Program. "Miikanaake," meaning "to create a new path" in the Ojibwe language,
blends modern scientific methods with traditional holistic approaches to address a range of
behavioral health challenges, including long-term abuse of methamphetamines, stimulants,
prescription drugs, depression, and anxiety (Roubideaux, 2011, p. 36). The program employs
"brainwave optimization sessions" that use advanced EEG technology to personalize treatment
based on the patient's unique brain activity, complemented by traditional practices like
meditation, prayer, and the use of natural sounds to encourage healing, balance, and harmony
(Roubideaux, 2011, p. 36). Patients engage in visualizations during daily sessions for a week,
with progress meticulously tracked, transitioning to weekly sessions thereafter (Roubideaux,
49
2011). In addition, the program integrates traditional counseling, focusing on positive
psychology and trauma-informed care, to enhance understanding and adoption of healthy living
practices. Creative activities such as beading, blanket making, sugaring, and ricing further enrich
the healing experience. As part of their ongoing care, patients are invited to partake in
community-centric activities, including longhouse and sweat lodge ceremonies, and Talking
Circles with community Elders, creating a sense of belonging and support. Remarkably, about
50% of patients with long-term substance use disorders have shown improvement six months
post-treatment, alongside notable progress in individuals dealing with depression, anxiety, and
insomnia (Roubideaux, 2011).
Another example is The Oshki Manidoo, or "New Spirit" Center, located in Bemidji,
Minnesota, offers a space for both Indigenous and non-Indigenous individuals seeking healing
through traditional practices. It aims to inspire a transformation in people, their families, and
broader communities by creating connections with heritage, community, and personal identity.
Offering a variety of activities, including cultural crafts such as beading, basket weaving, and
dream-catcher making, alongside community gatherings like powwows and talking circles, the
center facilitates meaningful conversations about substance use and cultural reconnection for
both young people and Elders. Staffed with therapists and psychiatrists specializing in trauma
and family-based care, the center applies concepts from the four circles and the medicine wheel
to promote overall wellness. With its community-oriented approach, Oshki Manidoo strives to
address the overrepresentation of Indigenous youth and women in the legal system, aiming for a
holistic path to recovery and empowerment (New Spirit, 2016).
By emphasizing collaboration, respect for traditional knowledge, and community-driven
research, these approaches have laid the foundation for a range of recovery services and
50
programs that address the unique needs of Indigenous communities. From rural recovery services
like AA meetings and Wellbriety to innovative treatment programs like the Miikanaake Program,
these initiatives highlight the importance of blending scientific approaches with traditional
practices. Moreover, they demonstrate the potential for improvements in health outcomes when
Indigenous values, beliefs, and priorities are central to the design and implementation of
recovery strategies.
Operational Dynamics and Communication within Recovery Centers
This section looks into the intricacies of operational dynamics and communication
strategies within treatment and recovery centers for substance use disorders, highlighting their
role in the effective delivery of care and the promotion of recovery paths for individuals with
substance use.
The organizational structure and communication strategies within treatment and recovery
centers for substance use disorders are essential to their operation and effectiveness (McLellan et
al., 2003). These centers, which can vary in size, location, and whether they are publicly or
privately operated, often adopt a hierarchical structure. At the top, executive directors or
administrators oversee the entire operation, while clinical directors manage the treatment
services. Direct care to patients is provided by a dedicated team of therapists, counselors, and
support staff. Governance and strategic oversight might be the responsibility of a board of
directors, emphasizing the importance of leadership at all levels in ensuring the delivery of
comprehensive care (McLellan et al., 2003).
In terms of treatment services, these centers adhere to evidence-based practices across a
continuum of care that includes prevention, intervention, treatment, and recovery support. The
51
array of services offered might include detoxification, inpatient and outpatient care, individual
and group therapy, medication-assisted treatment, and peer support programs, all aimed at
facilitating effective recovery paths for patients (Best & Laudet, 2010; White & Kelly, 2011).
When it comes to developing messaging and communication materials, a collaborative
approach is favored, involving administrators, clinical staff, marketing experts, and sometimes
patients or community members. The goal is to craft messages that effectively promote the
center's services, combat stigma, and encourage individuals to seek help (Noar, 2006).
Decision-making around these materials takes into account the target audience, cultural
sensitivities, and evidence-based communication tactics to ensure relevance and engagement.
Acknowledging the concept of recovery capital is also crucial, as it involves understanding the
resources individuals have access to during their recovery process (Best & Laudet, 2010). This
understanding allows centers to tailor messaging strategies effectively (Noar, 2006; Snyder et al.,
2004).
Exploring the creation of impactful communication and messaging strategies in treatment
and recovery centers, it's essential to recognize their importance extends beyond just the
individual level. These strategies are part of a broader effort to address the challenges faced by
the national substance use disorder treatment infrastructure, which strives to meet the growing
demand for high-quality care. This shift from individual messaging to systemic improvement
highlights the importance of seamlessly integrating strategic communication with overall
treatment efforts to enhance the support provided to individuals on their path to recovery.
Moreover, the national substance use disorder treatment infrastructure faces the challenge
of meeting the public demand for high-quality care, necessitating efficient and effective
communication methods. By integrating these comprehensive strategies, treatment, and recovery
52
centers can enhance their ability to support individuals on their journey to recovery, making an
impact on public health outcomes (McLellan et al., 2003; Best & Laudet, 2010).
Understanding the organizational structures and communication strategies within
substance use disorder treatment and recovery centers is crucial, as these elements play a key
role in delivering effective care and promoting recovery paths. It's evident that successful
recovery support goes beyond the clinical setting, requiring strategic messaging to combat
stigma and motivate individuals to seek help. This prepares the ground for an examination of
communication preferences within particular communities. The focus is on developing
communication that culturally resonates with the community, with the goal of increasing
participation in available recovery resources.
Communication Approaches in Recovery Messaging
This section looks into how we communicate about health, especially concerning opioid
use disorder. It begins with a look at risk perception and emotions, showing why understanding
both is crucial when trying to change health behaviors. From there, it moves to the Extended
Parallel Process Model (EPPM), explaining how fear can motivate people to act differently but
only if they feel capable of dealing with the threat. Next, the focus shifts to storytelling,
highlighting its power to change attitudes and behaviors by making health issues more relatable.
Finally, the section wraps up with the Lived-Experience Framework, emphasizing the
importance of real-life stories in making health messages hit home.
To begin, risk perception is an important part of health behavior change theories like the
Health Belief Model, Extended Parallel Process Model, and Protection Motivation Theory. These
theories emphasize looking at how likely someone is to get sick or take risks, and then making
53
choices based on what might happen (Qin et al., 2020; Ferrer et al., 2016). When people make
decisions about risks, they think about the facts but also how they feel. The idea that feelings
play a big role in decision-making is supported by the affect-as-information theory (Clore et al.,
1994). Peters and Slovic (2007) shows that paying attention to specific feelings can help predict
outcomes well, with Peters et al. (2004) noting that seeing risk is often tied to feeling negative
emotions.
Studies by Qin et al. (2020) demonstrate that detailed descriptions of the consequences of
opioid use disorder, particularly through visual means, can enhance risk awareness and negative
emotions, potentially reducing opioid use. This approach addresses the underestimation of
personal risk, highlighting the efficacy of messages that evoke negative emotional responses in
mitigating opioid usage.
Furthermore, through qualitative analysis of anonymous reports, Bagley and Beckham
(2020) investigated the perceived threats and effectiveness of responses to the opioid crisis. Their
findings indicate that the perceived dangers encompass issues like opioid use disorder, family
conflicts, the risk of overdose and death, stigma, financial, and legal consequences. Perceived
effective responses were identified as social support, proactive information seeking and sharing,
access to intervention programs and resources, and focused care for children.
Research in communication indicates a widespread optimistic bias in risk perception,
particularly regarding negative outcomes, leading to a "it won't happen to me" mentality (Bagley,
2019; Turner, Skubisz, & Rimal, 2011; Arnett, 2000). In the context of opioid use disorder, this
bias may cause people to underestimate the risks to themselves or loved ones, reducing the
perceived importance of taking preventive actions despite evidence to the contrary.
54
Following the exploration of risk perception and its influence on health behavior,
particularly in the context of opioid use disorder, the discussion transitions to a more focused
examination of how fear-based messages impact behavior through the lens of the Extended
Parallel Process Model (EPPM). Introduced by Kim Witte in 1992 and expanded upon by Lewis,
Watson, and White in 2013, EPPM is a theoretical framework designed to explain how
individuals respond to messages that aim to incite fear in order to motivate behavior change. This
model is grounded in the premise that for a fear-based message to be effective, the individual
receiving the message must both perceive the threat as likely and believe they have the means to
effectively counteract this threat. Witte & Allen (2000), outlined the EPPM's four foundational
elements: perceived severity of the threat, the individual's susceptibility to the threat, their belief
in their ability to take effective action (self-efficacy), and the belief that the proposed actions will
effectively mitigate the threat (response efficacy).
For a fear appeal to lead to the desired behavior change, it's essential that the recipient of
the message perceives the threat as both severe and relevant to them personally. This means they
must see themselves as vulnerable to the consequences outlined in the message. Beyond
recognizing the severity and relevance of the threat, the message must also convincingly
communicate that taking the recommended action will reduce the risk or impact of the threat
(response efficacy), and that they, the message recipient, are capable of performing these
recommended actions (self-efficacy).
The concept of system efficacy, which highlights the trust in societal and communal
support systems to manage the threat, complements these individual-level perceptions. This
aspect underlines the importance of confidence in the broader social and institutional
55
mechanisms for effective threat mitigation (Venette, 2008; Anthony et al., 2018; Macpherson et
al., 2014).
Witte and Allen (2000) identify three potential reactions to fear-inducing messages: no
response, fear-control response, and danger-control response. The most favorable reaction, the
danger-control response, occurs when the individual not only understands the risk but also feels
motivated to adopt the suggested protective behaviors. Conversely, a message might fail to
provoke any reaction if it does not successfully instill a sense of fear, rendering it ineffective. On
the other hand, a message that successfully incites fear but fails to boost the individual's
confidence in their ability to counter the threat can lead to a fear-control response. In this
situation, the individual may downplay the severity of the threat, ignore the advice given, or
doubt the effectiveness of the recommended preventive measures. Achieving a danger-control
response requires a delicate balance: the message must simultaneously trigger a sense of fear and
convince the audience of the efficacy of the suggested action. The interplay between perceived
threat and the belief in one's ability to mitigate that threat is crucial for prompting individuals to
take the recommended course of action.
Moving from the detailed look at how fear influences behavior with the Extended Parallel
Process Model, the next topic is about the impact of storytelling in health messages. Narrative
messaging can really grab people's attention and help them understand and act on health advice.
Using narrative messaging in public health materials can be a powerful way to change
behaviors. Hinyard (2007) points out that storytelling can grab people's attention and make them
more likely to understand and act on the message. Zoller and Dutta (2008) argue that stories can
help build a sense of community and shared identity, influencing how individuals react to health
information. Stories have also been shown to lessen negative attitudes toward mental health
56
issues (Pescosolido et al., 2010), addiction (Kelly, 2016; Kelly et al., 2010; Taylor et al., 2021),
and boost support for policies like naloxone distribution (Bachhuber et al., 2015). They can
change views on the need for treatment (Kasmin, 2019; Qin et al., 2020) and portray women who
use opioids in a more understanding light (Kasmin, 2019). Essentially, storytelling in health
messaging can effectively influence public attitudes and behaviors toward health issues.
After exploring the effectiveness of storytelling in health communication, the
conversation turns to the Lived-Experience Framework. This approach emphasizes the power of
real-life stories and experiences in enhancing the impact of health communication campaigns. It
considers how personal experiences, cultural backgrounds, and the broader social and
environmental context can shape people's responses to health messages.
Using real-life stories and experiences can deepen our understanding of how people react
to health communication campaigns by looking at the influence of personal stories, cultural
beliefs, and social and environmental contexts (Kim & Dearing, 2021). For example, Pescosolido
et al. (2010) noted a shift in public attitudes toward conditions like schizophrenia, depression,
and alcohol dependence over the years, likely due to changes in cultural norms and
conversations. Similarly, Witte and Allen (2020) discovered that messages that evoke fear can
work in health campaigns, but their success largely depends on the audience's own experiences.
This highlights how crucial it is to use a real-life experience approach to create impactful health
messages and to understand how they're received (Hornik, 2002; Hinyard, 2007; Jordan, 2009;
Zoller & Dutta, 2008). This strategy also helps explore the role of media in shaping public
opinions and health behaviors (Briggs & Hallin, 2016; DuPré, 2017; Friedman, 2004;
McDonnell, 2016; Parker & Thorson, 2009) and shows the importance of using storytelling to
encourage people to change their health behaviors (Hinyard, 2007; Miller-Day & Hecht, 2013).
57
Moreover, storytelling can challenge how the media portrays women who use opioids, offering
more nuanced perspectives (Kasmin, 2019).
Concluding the section on communication approaches in recovery messaging highlights
the importance of understanding risk perception, emotions, and their roles in health behavior
change, especially concerning opioid use disorder. This exploration begins with how individuals
assess risks and the emotions that influence their decisions. It is crucial for effective health
communication to grasp both concepts. The discussion then moves to the Extended Parallel
Process Model (EPPM), illustrating that fear can motivate action if individuals feel capable of
addressing the threat. The narrative shifts to the impact of storytelling, demonstrating its ability
to make health issues more relatable and change attitudes and behaviors. The section concludes
with the Lived-Experience Framework, underlining the importance of incorporating real-life
stories into health messages to enhance their resonance and impact.
This analysis sets the stage for addressing the research question, which seeks to
understand the communication preferences of Ojibwe community members in Northern
Minnesota concerning addiction recovery program materials. This inquiry stems from the
premise that cultural sensitivity and relevance are crucial for creating messages that resonate
with the community's values, experiences, and needs. Investigating the Ojibwe community's
communication preferences aims to identify how these insights can guide the development of
effective communication tools. These tools should not only align with cultural norms but also
motivate engagement with recovery resources.
This work is grounded in the belief that understanding the unique cultural and
communicational landscape of the Ojibwe community is crucial for the creation of health
communication strategies that are both respectful and effective. It acknowledges the diversity
58
within Native American communities and the need for tailored approaches that honor each
communities traditions, narratives, and visions of health.
59
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
In transitioning from the literature review to the theoretical underpinnings of this study,
it's crucial to contextualize the choice of theoretical frameworks within the broader research
objectives. The review of existing literature has revealed the complex nature of recovery from
opioid use disorder, particularly highlighting the unique challenges faced by Indigenous
communities. It shows the importance of approaches that are both culturally sensitive and
grounded in solid research. With this context in mind, this dissertation employs Grounded
Theory and Indigenous Standpoint Theory as its foundational theoretical frameworks. These
choices are not arbitrary but are informed by the literature's emphasis on the complex interplay
of cultural, social, and individual factors influencing recovery in Ojibwe communities.
Grounded Theory and Indigenous Standpoint Theory offer deep insights into
communication strategies for opioid use disorder recovery, especially within Indigenous
communities. Grounded Theory enables the development of theories that are directly informed
by data, ensuring these theories are relevant and applicable to the context they’re studied in. On
the other hand, Indigenous Standpoint Theory emphasizes prioritizing the experiences and needs
of Indigenous peoples in the research process, facilitating a collaborative creation of knowledge
that reflects community perspectives and priorities. Using these two frameworks together can
achieve a more thorough understanding of how to approach opioid use disorder recovery
messaging in Indigenous contexts. This method ensures that messaging is culturally attentive and
meets the specific needs of Indigenous communities. Additionally, grounding messaging in the
experiences and values of Indigenous peoples can enhance engagement and the effectiveness of
these communication strategies. In summary, combining Grounded Theory with Indigenous
60
Standpoint Theory provides a strong and comprehensive approach to studying opioid use
disorder recovery messaging in Indigenous communities.
Grounded Theory
Grounded theory is a research approach that combines different methods to collect and
analyze data systematically, aiming to build theories or models from the ground up. This method
is particularly useful for exploring how to communicate about recovery from opioid use disorder,
allowing for a process that adjusts based on what the data shows, reflecting real-life experiences
and perspectives of people dealing with opioid use disorder (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019).
The main goal of grounded theory is to develop a theory or model based directly on collected
data, avoiding the use of pre-set ideas or biases (Ellingson & Borofka, 2014).
Li (2022) demonstrated how grounded theory was used to develop a model looking at
how digital communication affects the preservation of cultural heritage. Similarly, Martin et al.
(2018) pointed out its value for beginners in research, especially in the area of communication
studies. By applying grounded theory, a deeper understanding of the experiences, attitudes, and
beliefs of individuals affected by opioid use disorder can be achieved. This understanding helps
in designing communication strategies that truly connect with people affected by opioid use
disorder (Chun Tie et al., 2019).
When it comes to creating messages for recovery from opioid use disorder, grounded
theory helps identify which communication strategies work best, like the Extended Parallel
Process Model, sympathetic storytelling, and sharing real-life experiences, and also helps
understand why they are effective. Furthermore, grounded theory allows for the development of
theories or models that are based on the actual experiences of individuals affected by opioid use
61
disorder. This can guide the creation of specific interventions to aid recovery (Ellingson &
Borofka, 2014). In short, grounded theory is an essential tool for investigating communication
strategies in opioid use disorder recovery messaging, offering a detailed and systematic way to
gather and analyze data that's rooted in people's real experiences.
Indigenous Standpoint Theory
Indigenous Standpoint Theory explores how our social position, shaped by our social,
political, economic, and cultural relationships, influences our identity and the structure of our
lives (Foley, 2007). This theory looks into the dilemma Indigenous peoples face: the pressure to
choose between their cultural identity and one imposed by colonial powers. It stresses the critical
need to recognize and appreciate the differences between Indigenous and Western cultures as a
foundation for mutual understanding and acceptance (Foley, 2007).
Central to this theory is the concept that research should primarily benefit the Indigenous
communities it studies, rather than outsiders (Foley, 2007). This means that the knowledge
produced is valued and owned by the community, giving Indigenous researchers the opportunity
to contribute from their unique cultural perspectives, support the preservation of their culture,
and share their distinct understandings to create a more inclusive and complex body of
knowledge. Indigenous scholars argue that research in their communities must be conducted with
the community's needs and interests at the forefront, empowering them and supporting their
self-determination, thereby respecting their sovereign right to set their research agendas and
demonstrating a commitment to social justice (Moreton-Robinson, 2013).
By emphasizing the significance of Indigenous peoples' experiences, acknowledging the
distinct differences between Indigenous and Western cultures, and upholding the sovereignty of
62
Indigenous peoples in determining the focus of research, Indigenous Standpoint Theory
advocates for a creation of knowledge that is inclusive and multifaceted. This approach benefits
Indigenous peoples by centering their perspectives, addressing their specific needs, and honoring
their cultural distinctiveness (Nakata, 2007). Through this lens, research becomes a collaborative
effort that not only enriches academic discourse but also has practical implications for
Indigenous communities, ensuring that the generated knowledge is meaningful and directly
beneficial to them.
Wrapping up this section, the chosen theoretical approaches, Grounded Theory and
Indigenous Standpoint Theory, set a strong base for exploring how to effectively communicate
about opioid use disorder recovery in Indigenous communities, specifically focusing on the
Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota. Grounded Theory digs into the real stories and
experiences of people dealing with opioid use disorder to build theories that make sense in their
specific contexts (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019). This approach ensures the findings are
directly connected to what people are actually going through and what helps them in recovery.
At the same time, Indigenous Standpoint Theory puts the spotlight on the importance of
understanding recovery from the viewpoint of Indigenous people themselves (Foley, 2007). It
argues for research that benefits Indigenous communities, allowing them to guide the study
based on what they need and what matters to them (Moreton-Robinson, 2013; Nakata, 2007).
This ensures the research is respectful and reflects the unique cultural identity of the Ojibwe
community.
Merging these frameworks, this study seeks to answer the research questions: What
preferences do Ojibwe community members in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within
addiction recovery program materials? In what ways can their preferences inform the creation of
63
effective communication tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources? By
integrating Grounded Theory and Indigenous Standpoint Theory, the goal is to uncover
messaging strategies that resonate with the Ojibwe community's cultural values and experiences,
ensuring the development of communication tools that effectively engage and support the
community in their recovery journey. This dual-framework methodology offers a comprehensive
approach to crafting messages that are not only evidence-based but also culturally attuned,
aiming to enhance the efficacy and relevance of addiction recovery programs.
64
METHODS
In response to the escalating opioid crisis disproportionately impacting Native American
populations, this dissertation focuses on developing effective communication strategies for
substance use disorder recovery that align with the cultural and communicative preferences of
the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota. This research is driven by the question: What
preferences do Ojibwe community members in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within
addiction recovery program materials. In what ways can their preferences inform the creation of
effective communication tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources?
Utilizing a qualitative research methodology, this study integrates grounded theory and
Indigenous Standpoint Theory to foreground Indigenous knowledge systems and perspectives.
Grounded theory facilitates the generation of theory from systematically gathered and analyzed
data, while Indigenous Standpoint Theory prioritizes Indigenous experiences and worldviews,
critically addressing the marginalization of these perspectives in mainstream discourse. This dual
theoretical approach ensures the research is culturally attuned and aims to produce findings that
are academically informed and practically applicable in crafting communication materials for
addiction recovery programs targeting Indigenous communities.
Participants in this study were selected based on specific inclusion and exclusion criteria.
Inclusion criteria encompassed Ojibwe individuals in inpatient treatment and Elders facilitating
ceremonies at the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center, as well as healthcare workers
and facility owners, regardless of race. Exclusion criteria applied to non-Ojibwe individuals in
inpatient treatment. Additionally, to protect privacy in this small community, no further
identifiers such as gender or age were shared.
65
The initial stage of the research involved direct involvement at the Northern Minnesota
Addiction Wellness Center, where I engaged with the community both as an observer and
participant. This immersion was important for the development of research tools and was
informed by Ojibwe people's lived experiences and cultural practices, encompassing
participation in meals, ceremonies, and daily community life to gain a comprehensive
understanding of their healing practices and the challenges they face during recovery.
Following the pretesting phase, in the first phase of the study I conducted semi-structured
interviews with a select group of participants, including clinical staff, community Elders, and
individuals personally affected by substance use disorder. These interviews sought to capture the
community's narratives surrounding addiction, recovery, and the role of informational materials
in these processes, providing insights into both personal and collective experiences.
The second phase engaged community members in a co-design process to produce
communication materials. Through Collaborative Creation Circles, participants leveraged their
experiences to design brochures and flyers that mirror their personal and shared recovery
journeys. This phase not only produced culturally resonant materials but also empowered
participants by involving them directly in the creative process, ensuring the final products were
meaningful and aligned with community values and preferences.
In concluding the study, I focused on the integration of insights from earlier phases into
the development of a culturally specific website. This online platform was designed to support
recovery by featuring personal stories, educational content grounded in Ojibwe teachings, and
information on local resources. By adhering to co-design principles, the application of findings
aimed to create a digital space that reflects the community's experiences, facilitates healing, and
serves as a valuable resource for those on the path to recovery.
66
Pretesting at the Treatment Facility
In the early stages of my research at the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center,
my role evolved beyond that of an observer, but as an active participant within the community.
This approach was not chosen at random; it was a deliberate method to ensure that the
development of my research instruments would be informed by the lived experiences and
cultural practices of Ojibwe peoples, along with ensuring the facility I gathered data from
integrated Indigenous healing methods. Through recommendations from my healthcare network,
I was fortunate enough to gain access to this facility, known for its openness to research and
collaboration, particularly with scholars from Bemidji State University.
Incorporating participant observation into my dissertation research provided an in-depth
exploration into the community's space of healing and recovery. I was fortunate to gain access to
this space, especially the cultural aspects, thanks to the established community at the facility. My
own personal experiences, including my mother's overdose and her prolonged health struggles
leading to her death, created a unique layer of trust. This connection conveyed a deep
understanding, essentially saying, "You know who I am and some of what I'm going through."
This shared experience opened doors to observe everyday life, customs, and interactions that are
not immediately visible from the outside (Emerson, Fretz, & Shaw, 2011). This approach was
important for building trust and understanding the community's dynamics from an insider's
perspective (Bernard, 2011). By actively participating in daily routines and cultural practices, I
ensured my research was grounded in real-world experiences, enhancing the validity and
relevance of my findings (Fetterman, 2010). This hands-on approach offered a detailed depiction
67
of how cultural traditions, social interactions, and individual stories intertwine within the
community's recovery landscape.
My immersion over two days involved engaging with the community in a variety of
settings: sharing meals, playing lacrosse, participating in ceremonies such as smudging and
talking circles, and attending classes about grief and healing. This participatory observation
allowed me to gather an understanding of data through casual conversations, observations, and
reflective notes, all of which painted a picture of the community's health information-seeking
behaviors and their preferences for certain terminologies.
Interestingly, this engagement led to a series of revelations that would shape my research
direction. Initially, I had assumed that traditional forms of advertising like flyers and billboards
would be the most recognized sources of information for this community. Conversations
revealed a strong preference for digital platforms, with many participants discovering the facility
through case worker recommendation followed by a web search on their phones. This preference
hierarchy extended to radio, word of mouth, printed materials, and finally, social media and
online groups, reshaping my assumptions about effective communication channels within this
community.
Additionally, my initial beliefs about the role of language and stigma were challenged. I
had anticipated a resistance to the term “addict” due to its potential stigma; instead, I found a
community reclaiming the term as a part of their identity and healing journey. This insight was
particularly impactful, highlighting the importance of language and self-identification in the
recovery process.
Reflecting on my own experiences of grief during this time, I recognized the parallels
between my personal journey and those of the participants. This commonality in emotional
68
experiences not only contributed depth and empathy to the research but also revealed the
universal aspects of grieving and the assorted avenues for healing.
This participatory approach not only informed the evolution of my research instruments
but also deepened my understanding of the cultural and informational landscapes navigated by
individuals in recovery. The insights from this experience were important in shaping the
subsequent phases of my research, guiding the creation of materials that resonate with the
cultural and communicative preferences of the Ojibwe community.
Phase One: Interviews
In the initial phase of my research at the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center,
I initiated a series of interviews aimed at capturing the complex narratives surrounding the
community's relationship with addiction and recovery information. Choosing a semi-structured
interview format was a deliberate decision to create a setting where conversations could unfold
organically, rather than a rigid clinical exchange. This format ensured that while the conversation
remained open to exploration, it was also guided to cover the essential questions I needed to
address. My approach was informed by Grant McCracken’s methodology for generating
ethnographic data, utilizing an open-ended questionnaire to look into the cultural categories and
meanings shared across interviews (McCracken, 1988).
The selection of participants was a thoughtful process, facilitated by the relationships I
had nurtured during the pretesting phase. This prior engagement made the interviews not only
more meaningful but smoother, as a sense of familiarity and trust had already been established. I
employed purposive sampling to choose 24 participants, consisting of four clinical staff
experienced in substance use disorder treatment, two community Elders who facilitate ceremony
69
in recovery settings, and eighteen community members who had personal experiences with
substance use disorder. This diverse group played a crucial role in depicting a full portrait of the
community's experiences and resilience when dealing with substance use disorder.
Conducting the interviews required a return to the Wellness Center, where I held
one-on-one sessions in settings ranging from private rooms for telehealth appointments with
clients to the med room for medical staff. These interviews, recorded and later transcribed by me
using Google Docs' voice typing feature, served as the cornerstone of my data gathering process.
Followed by utilizing Dedoose for thematic analysis.
Analyzing the interview data was an extensive process that began with a thematic
analysis. This method allowed me to identify patterns and themes within the data without being
confined to a specific theoretical framework (Braun & Clarke, 2006). I started with a general
overview of the transcripts to grasp the data's overall essence before moving on to initial coding
and thematic categorization (Creswell, 1998; 2013). This method enabled the extraction of
overarching themes from detailed observations, leading to a collection of broad insights that
might be relevant to comparable groups (Yin, 2009).
Phase Two: Collaborative Creation Circles
In phase two, which I like to call Collaborative Creation Circles, the aim was to directly
involve participants from the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center in creating
communication materials. Drawing on the work of Lindquist et al. (2007), Apers et al. (2023),
Grindell et al. (2022), and Goodyear-Smith et al. (2015), this phase was grounded in co-design.
The participants, chosen from those engaged in the initial interview phase, worked individually
70
in a group setting to produce a brochure that reflected their individual and collective healing
journeys.
The process involved a group session where basics of brochure and flyer design were
discussed, and participants were encouraged to create something meaningful to their recovery.
After creation, each participant explained their piece to me privately, focusing on their choices of
art, words, and symbols. This activity aimed to generate materials that would resonate with the
broader community, making the brochure's message more impactful.
The materials produced during these circles—be they drawings or written pieces—were
collected and documented. This collection process was respectful of participants' ownership of
their creations, with many choosing to photograph or scan their work as a personal keepsake. My
analysis strategy was guided by the insights of Grindell et al. (2022) and facilitated by the use of
Dedoose software. I aimed to see what was really going on beneath the surface of each work,
from the choice of colors and symbols to the nuances of language and narrative styles.
In working with the Collaborative Creation Circles, I used thematic analysis to see what
common themes popped up from our group's work, focusing on how we communicate, our
cultural symbols, and what healing means to us. This approach is based on the work of Braun &
Clarke (2006), who suggest looking for themes in what people create or say to understand them
better. I started by taking a close look at each piece of artwork and discussion from the circles,
identifying the main ideas that kept showing up. This careful look helped make sure I really got
what each creation was about, following a method similar to what Strauss & Corbin (1998)
recommend for breaking down and understanding data.
To keep track of everything, I made a detailed list (a codebook) of all the themes I found,
explaining what each one means. This helped organize the information I collected, turning my
71
initial notes into clear, defined themes. Creswell (1998) talks about how important it is to get a
good, overall understanding of your data, and that's what I tried to do.
To make sure my findings were solid, I worked with another researcher. We both used my
list of themes to look at three of the creations together. This step was crucial for making sure we
both saw the themes in the same way, ensuring the analysis was reliable, just like Braun &
Clarke (2006) suggest.
After we agreed on the themes, I looked at the big picture to connect the dots between all
the different themes I found. This was more about letting the main messages show themselves
from the data, keeping in line with what people actually shared, similar to the approach Strauss
& Corbin (1998) describe.
Finally, I kept a journal during the whole process, writing down my first impressions and
feelings about what we discussed and created in the circles. This step, inspired by Lindlof &
Taylor (2011), was about making sure I understood the reasons behind people's actions and
creations. Looking back at these notes helped me stay true to what the participants really wanted
to say, making the analysis grounded in real experiences.
Integration of Findings
In the integration of my project, the focus shifted toward the practical application of
insights gathered from the Ojibwe community into developing a culturally tailored website to
support recovery from substance use disorder. This step was informed by a deliberate
methodological approach, emphasizing co-design principles highlighted by which advocate for
the integration of users in the creation process to ensure that the final product is both relevant
and meaningful to its intended audience (Lindquist et al., 2007; Apers et al., 2023).
72
Guided by the principle of Mino-Bimaadiziwin, or "living a good life," the core of the
website was shaped, reflecting a core Ojibwe value guiding individuals toward spiritual healing
and wellness. This decision was backed by thematic analysis allowing for the organic emergence
of key themes such as personal stories, educational insights, cultural practices, and artistic
expressions (Braun & Clarke, 2006). Each element aimed to enhance the relevance and
accessibility of recovery resources.
The inclusion of personal narratives discovered through public interviews conducted by
Minnesota Public Radio (MPR) was a choice designed to lend the site authenticity and a sense of
belonging. This approach emphasizes ethnographic data's power to convey deep, culturally
resonant stories, thereby emphasizing the concept of Mino-Bimaadiziwin in a relatable manner
(McCracken, 1988).
Furthermore, the educational content on the website drew heavily from the Seven
Grandfather Teachings, a decision informed by participant interviews and observations. This
choice was rooted in co-design, ensuring that the content not only provided a decolonial
perspective on addiction but also was grounded in traditional healing practices (Grindell et al.,
2022).
For the representation of cultural practices, such as ceremonies and the Red Road to
wellness and recovery, I leaned on insights from cultural experts and community members. This
approach stresses the importance of including stakeholders in the design process to ensure that
the traditional practices featured on the website are meaningful and representative of the
community's path to healing (Goodyear-Smith et al., 2015).
Artistic representations on the website were inspired by community collaboration circles,
reflecting a co-design approach where community input directly influenced the visual content.
73
This method, aimed to create art that serves as a cultural tie, connected users to the community's
healing process through visual storytelling (Fetterman, 2010).
An interactive map and resource section were developed to enhance accessibility to local
wellness and healing centers. This development was grounded in the methodology's focus on
making recovery resources more accessible and user-friendly (Creswell, 1998).
Reflecting on this project, the integration of findings into a cohesive website was
supported by a thoughtful blend of thematic analysis and co-design methods. These choices were
made to ensure that the website not only resonated with the Ojibwe community's needs and
values but also represented a step forward in combining traditional knowledge with modern
communication techniques to address the complexities of recovery from substance use disorder.
The process highlighted the importance of culturally sensitive communication, the power of
visual storytelling, and the importance of engaging with and reflecting upon the community's
voice in every step of the development process.
Ethical Considerations
In the data collection phases, each participant received an informed consent form
detailing the study's aims, procedures, potential risks and benefits, and their rights, including the
right to withdraw at any time without penalty. After reviewing the form and addressing any
questions, participants gave their verbal consent. To accurately capture the data, interviews were
audio recorded, providing a comprehensive record for analysis. Recognizing the importance of
consent and autonomy, participants could choose not to be recorded, in which case detailed notes
were taken, supplemented by reflective notes and observations post-interview. This method
74
respects privacy and comfort while maintaining ethical standards of informed consent and
participant control.
When addressing the choice of verbal consent over written consent in research or
interventions involving communities with a history of trauma associated with signing documents,
it's crucial to consider the ethical implications and the historical context. The use of verbal
consent over written consent in research, particularly with communities that have experienced
historical trauma, it's essential to recognize the ethical implications and historical context. This
approach acknowledges the potential mistrust and fears in communities with a history of
exploitation or abuse documented through written agreements. The frameworks of OCAP
(Ownership, Control, Access, and Possession) and IQ (Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit) provide valuable
guidance. OCAP, specific to First Nations, and IQ, deriving from Inuit traditional knowledge,
emphasize self-determination and respect for Indigenous communities' autonomy in research
(Mashford-Pringle & Pavagadhi, 2020). They advocate for a research ethic that prioritizes
collaborative relationships, ensuring that Indigenous communities can govern how research is
conducted and how the resulting data and knowledge are shared. This approach acknowledges
the mistrust and fears that may be present in communities that have experienced the removal of
rights or other forms of exploitation and abuse documented through written agreements. The
decision to use verbal consent respects the participants' comfort levels and aims to create a more
inclusive and trusting environment (Mashford-Pringle & Pavagadhi, 2020).
The method of consent (written or verbal) can be tailored to the specific needs of the
study population, particularly in situations where written agreements may evoke negative
historical or cultural associations. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) endorses verbal
consent as a viable option in certain scenarios, notably with populations that historically mistrust
75
written contracts due to previous exploitation (National Institutes of Health, 2020). Adopting
such approaches allows for trust and honors the cultural and historical backgrounds of
participants.
To maintain confidentiality, I anonymized interview transcripts by removing all personal
identifiers. Protective measures for data security included the use of password-protected digital
files and secure storage of physical documents. The Institutional Review Board (IRB) at the
University of Oregon reviewed and approved the study, affirming its adherence to ethical
standards.
76
FINDINGS
In this section of my dissertation, I explored how cultural values and communication
preferences intersect within the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota, specifically focusing
on messages about recovery from substance use disorder. This exploration was based on two
primary sources: detailed interviews with Ojibwe community members, including Elders and
clinical staff, and insights from Collaborative Creation Circles, which engaged community
members in co-designing recovery program materials. This dual-method approach allowed for a
nuanced understanding of what makes recovery messages meaningful to the community.
The purpose of this analysis was to uncover how Ojibwe community members'
preferences shaped their engagement with recovery messaging. Through examining the patterns
that emerged from both interviews and collaborative sessions, I aimed to identify key elements
that resonated with the community. These research questions guided the study: What preferences
do Ojibwe community members in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within addiction
recovery program materials? In what ways can their preferences inform the creation of effective
communication tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources?
This section aimed to craft a communication strategy framework that not only reflected
Ojibwe cultural identity but also effectively connected community members with recovery
resources. This involved looking into the community’s views on language, cultural symbols, and
narratives, highlighting their importance in developing empowering and hopeful messages. By
synthesizing insights from the research, I intended to show how cultural understanding could
guide the development of communication tools for recovery, enhancing the connection between
the Ojibwe community and available recovery resources, and supporting individuals on their
recovery journey.
77
Insights from Interview Data
This section reviews how Ojibwe community members in Northern Minnesota feel about
messages in addiction recovery materials. I aimed to find out what messages work best to
encourage them to use available resources for recovery. By analyzing interviews from the
Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center, I looked for clear themes that show what the
community prefers. My goal was to learn from these insights to make better communication
tools that are easy to understand, respectful of cultural values, and motivating for people on their
recovery journey.
Choosing the right participants was important, bringing together a group of 24
individuals that included four clinical staff members knowledgeable in substance use disorder
treatment, including the facility's owners, two community Elders who lead recovery ceremonies,
and eighteen Ojibwe community members who have personal experience with substance use
disorder. This varied collection of perspectives offered a rich and detailed understanding of the
challenges and responses associated with substance use disorder.
Semi-structured interviews were employed to collect data, offering a rich and varied
dialogue. This method enabled participants to openly share their experiences, while still
addressing the study's core subjects. Both flexible and focused, the interviews were designed to
gather data relevant to the research question (McCracken, 1988).
A coding scheme was developed for thematic analysis, utilizing Dedoose to assist in
identifying and categorizing themes across the data. Initial coding led to the identification of
major themes, which were then analyzed in relation to the broader research questions (Braun &
Clarke, 2006). Dedoose is a web-based application designed for organizing, analyzing, and
78
collaborating on research data, particularly for qualitative and mixed methods research. It
provides tools for coding, retrieving, and sharing data efficiently, making it a popular choice for
researchers across various disciplines. The analysis also considered the impact of data collected
during the pretesting phase, allowing for an understanding of the community's relationship with
substance use disorder and recovery before formulating the interview questions.
The process to sift through the interview data began with a review of the transcribed
interviews, focusing on recurrent ideas, expressions, and instances that appeared across the
conversations. Each interview was read multiple times, for a deep understanding of the content
and the emergence of preliminary codes. These initial codes were applied uniformly across all
transcripts, noting patterns that transcended individual experiences. As themes began to come
together, they were further refined, ensuring they captured the key points of the participants'
narratives. This iterative coding process, supported by Dedoose, facilitated the organization of
data into coherent themes that reflected the shared experiences and concerns of the community
members, clinical staff, and Elders (Braun & Clarke, 2006).
The analysis centered on how the identified themes related directly to the research
questions, focusing on messaging preferences within the community and the implications for
creating effective communication tools. Themes such as "Empowerment and Hope," "Stigma and
Language," and "Cultural Relevance" highlighted the importance of positive, culturally sensitive
messaging and the use of non-stigmatizing language. The interrelation of these themes pointed to
a comprehensive framework for designing recovery program materials that resonate with Ojibwe
community values and experiences. By examining the connections between messaging
preferences and the broader context of addiction recovery, it became clear how important the
79
alignment of communication strategies with community expectations is for encouraging
engagement with recovery resources.
The thematic analysis provided critical insights into the preferences of Ojibwe
community members regarding messaging in addiction recovery program materials. It revealed a
clear preference for messaging that is empowering, culturally tailored, and free from stigmatizing
language. These preferences highlight the necessity of developing communication tools that not
only provide accurate and helpful information but also reflect the community's cultural heritage,
values, and language. The findings suggest that effective communication tools should
incorporate elements that create hope, highlight success stories, and utilize culturally relevant
symbols and narratives. Such tools are likely to facilitate a stronger connection with the intended
audience, thereby enhancing engagement with available recovery resources. This analysis aligns
with the research question by illustrating how understanding specific messaging preferences can
lead to the development of more effective communication strategies in addiction recovery
programs for the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota.
The research questions guiding this investigation seek to understand - What preferences
do Ojibwe community members in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within addiction
recovery program materials? In what ways can their preferences inform the creation of effective
communication tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources? The insights
gained here are important in guiding the development of recovery program materials that are not
only culturally sensitive but also aligned with the community's values and communication
preferences.
80
A message of sincere hopefulness
The section explores a messaging approach to engaging with individuals seeking help for
substance use disorders. This analysis draws upon firsthand accounts from the Northern
Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center's community, highlighting a clear preference for messages
that are positive, informative, and realistically framed. Through an examination of messaging
preferences, communication channels, and visual and design preferences, this section aims to
uncover the types of messaging and outreach that resonate most effectively with the community.
The insights gathered here are important in guiding the development of communication tools that
not only convey the necessary information about addiction recovery but also do so in a manner
that is empowering and hopeful. By addressing the community's preferences for how recovery
programs communicate their messages, this analysis contributes to a deeper understanding of
how to create engagement and support Ojibwe individuals on their journey toward wellness.
Several participants expressed a clear preference for positive messaging and
informational content over fear-based approaches. A healthcare worker highlighted the value of
including mission statements and service offerings in program materials, suggesting a preference
for clear and informative messaging, "It's good that they have their mission statement on there.
And then the services they offer." This indicates a desire for transparency and straightforward
communication about the services available to them, which can foster trust and clarity in the
recovery process.
Conversely, negative framing, particularly fear-based messaging, was criticized for its
ineffectiveness and potential harm. For instance, the owner of the facility criticized the D.A.R.E.
program for being fear-based and misleading "D.A.R.E. is actually I think has ruined more
children than it's ever helped. Yeah because it scares you and it doesn't teach you the truth." This
81
sentiment was echoed by another participant, who argued for the importance of providing
accurate information to enable informed decisions rather than using fear tactics "Give them the
right information you know so that they can make an educated informed decision for themselves.
You know don't try and use fear tactics." These perspectives underline the community's
preference for recovery messaging that is empowering and educative, steering clear of tactics
that invoke fear.
The critique of simplistic messaging approaches, such as the "Just Say No" campaign,
further illustrates the community's preference for nuanced and realistic messaging about
recovery. The dismissal of such campaigns as unrealistic by participants suggests a desire for
messaging that acknowledges the complexities of addiction and recovery "Recovery is
possible...It's just a redo of the Nancy Reagan just say no... That's not realistic." This aligns with
the broader theme within the interviews of seeking messaging that respects the intelligence and
autonomy of the community members, providing them with the information and inspiration
needed to pursue recovery.
Finally, participants also discussed the importance of changing the current messaging
strategies to better reflect truths about addiction and recovery. This includes moving away from
fear-based narratives to more positive, informative, and supportive messaging that can genuinely
assist individuals in their recovery journey "Fear-based for sure... it scares you and it doesn't
teach you the truth…How do we change that messaging as well?" This reflects a broader desire
for a shift in how addiction recovery is communicated, emphasizing hope, support, and accurate
information.
In conclusion, the analysis of Messaging Preferences within the Northern Minnesota
Addiction Wellness Center's community highlights a clear preference for positive, informative,
82
and realistically framed messaging over negative, fear-based approaches. The community
members express a desire for messaging that empowers and educates, offering hope and support
while acknowledging the complexities of addiction and recovery. These preferences are
important for developing effective addiction recovery programs that resonate with the Ojibwe
community and support their journey toward wellness.
A health care worker shared insights on how the facility's information is spread through
university hiring fairs, suggesting an active approach to outreach that goes beyond traditional
advertising, "So [the owners] will go to [the university] and will have…a hiring fair. So [they]
will set up a stand and just kind of like spread it that way." This strategy indicates a personalized
and direct engagement with potential community members, showing the value of face-to-face
interactions in raising awareness about recovery programs.
A health care worker mentioned using personal social media accounts for promotion,
indicating a contemporary and reachable communication strategy. They said, "[The owner] has
Facebook. It seems like it was her personal account originally, but now she uses it solely for this
place." This method shows how combining personal and professional networks can be used
effectively to promote programs. Additionally, it highlights how the outreach, being personal and
led by someone in long-term recovery, enhances the connection and impact within communities.
This approach shows the value of peer-led efforts in making recovery messaging more relatable
and effective.
The program has a strong online presence and also utilizes radio, a more traditional
communication method, to reach a wider audience. A health care worker's statement shows this
approach, "[The owner of the facility] has done radio interviews too. I don't necessarily drive and
hear ads for this place, but I know [she] has talked on the radio"
83
Bridging traditional and community-specific outreach, the facility owners mentioned
distributing brochures in tribal locations as a customized strategy to connect with their audience.
They said "our brochures are located in any tribal facilities like colleges or jails…I know there
are, I just don't know where. They do have [them out]." This method demonstrates an
understanding of the community's locales and the strategic placement of informational materials
where they are most likely to be seen by those in need of services. This focused approach makes
sure important information is easy to find in places where the community often goes, increasing
the chances of reaching people who need these services. By doing this, it helps build a more
connected and knowledgeable community.
The use of printed materials like brochures and business cards plays a role in their
communication strategy. The owners of the facility highlight the use of these materials as a
means to ensure constant engagement and accessibility, "I have brochures constantly. I'm going
through business cards. Yeah. Here you go. Here you go. So I think I've ordered 4000 business
cards since we started." This quote illustrates a proactive approach to distributing tangible
resources that people can easily share and refer to. The physical distribution of brochures and
business cards not only helps in spreading awareness about the recovery services but also
facilitates personal connections between the community members and the recovery program. By
investing in such a high volume of printed materials, the facility demonstrates its commitment to
making sure that information about their services reaches as many individuals as possible,
thereby enhancing the network of support within the community.
Word-of-mouth is highlighted as a powerful tool for information dissemination within the
community, as one owner vividly describes, "The cool thing is now with word of mouth I think
word of mouth even like I said the people who are getting kicked out are in jail and telling,
84
giving, people my phone number." This quote emphasizes the organic spread of information
within tight-knit communities and the importance of personal recommendations in building trust
and credibility. This focus on word-of-mouth illustrates how personal connections and trust are
important for spreading information, showing that straightforward, people-focused
communication is key to effectively connect with and support community members.
The journey to discovering addiction recovery programs can vary among individuals, as
highlighted by a participant's experience, "Haha I didn’t hear about this place. I was sent here.
Court ordered. So, yeah. Then I Googled it." This statement shows the diverse ways people come
into contact with recovery services, including through legal mandates. This also points to the role
of the internet in providing additional information and context about these programs. Once
court-ordered to attend, the participant turned to Google to learn more about the facility,
illustrating how digital resources serve as a critical tool for individuals seeking to understand
more about their path to recovery. This blend of initial external influence followed by personal
research highlights the importance of maintaining a strong online presence for recovery centers.
It ensures that individuals, regardless of how they are referred to a program, can access detailed
and supportive information to help them engage with their recovery process more effectively.
Together these quotes illustrate the diverse strategies employed to communicate with the
Ojibwe community about addiction recovery programs. From direct outreach at local universities
to the strategic placement of brochures, the use of personal social media accounts, or websites,
these methods highlight a comprehensive approach that seeks to maximize engagement through
varied communication channels. Furthermore, the emphasis on word-of-mouth highlights the
importance of personal connections and community trust in disseminating information
85
effectively. This multifaceted communication strategy is indicative of the program's awareness of
and adaptability to the community's preferences and needs.
The visual and design preferences within addiction recovery programs for Ojibwe
community members in Northern Minnesota are central to the effectiveness of their messaging.
The detailed attention to visual aesthetics—ranging from the selection of imagery to the layout
simplicity—plays a role in ensuring that the information is not only accessible but also resonates
deeply with the community.
One of the facility owners discussed the collaborative effort in designing brochures,
emphasizing a desire to reflect the natural and tranquil setting of the recovery environment:
“Me and the person from AOM&E Graphics...wanted to make sure people knew it's out
in the woods...Really in the woods, nice and clean open spaces...this is a double rainbow
picture that [a peer] got... And we just wanted to make it nice and easy [to read]."
This quote highlights the importance of using visuals that convey the serene and healing
atmosphere of the facility, suggesting that such imagery can create a sense of hope and peace for
individuals considering the recovery journey.
Participants' feedback further informs the visual and design strategies of the recovery
programs. The desire for more art and stories reflective of the community's experiences—"There
needs to be more art"; "I think more stories about people like us, you know?"—points to a need
for materials that not only inform but also engage and represent the community's diversity and
stories. This feedback shows the importance of culturally relevant and personalized content in
creating materials that connect on a deeper level.
There's also a critical perspective on the approach to marketing within these materials, as
one participant expresses discomfort with the marketing-like appearance of some materials: "I
don’t like it. It’s like marketing." This viewpoint highlights the delicate balance between creating
86
visually appealing materials and ensuring they authentically represent the recovery process
without seeming overly commercialized.
Lastly, the curiosity about the people within the recovery program—"Tell me about the
people. What are they like?"—indicates a desire for human connection and understanding, which
can be facilitated through stories and testimonials within program materials. Incorporating
narratives of recovery and support can demystify the recovery process and foster a sense of
community and shared experience.
The Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center places a strong emphasis on
blending traditional cultural methods with its addiction recovery programs, making the care they
offer closely aligned with cultural needs. By integrating cultural identity into the recovery
process through established traditions and the leadership of community figures, the center
ensures the care it provides is respectful and culturally aware. Ojibwe participants, in particular,
benefit from peer recovery sessions led by Elders, which incorporate cultural teachings and
healing practices tailored to their spiritual and cultural requirements. The center's dedication to
honoring traditional ceremonies, like pipe and smudge ceremonies, shows its deep respect for
these practices and helps participants in reconnecting with their cultural roots. Additionally,
encouraging spiritual communication, with your manidoog, highlights the critical role of spiritual
ties and acknowledgment in the recovery process. This approach underlines the center's belief in
recovery as a shared journey, rooted in cultural and ancestral bonds.
One facility owner shared, "Yeah so we offer we have peer recovery that are specifically
for this area Native American. And we have other peer recovery that we work with... So [one of
the Elders].. he does more cultural stuff. So Wednesday night is two hours of cultural [healing]" .
This quote highlights the importance of incorporating cultural practices, such as peer recovery
87
sessions led by community Elders, which are tailored to meet the cultural and spiritual needs of
their participants. The focus on cultural healing highlights the facility's commitment to providing
culturally sensitive and relevant care.
Emphasizing the importance of traditional practices in healing, an Elder shared plans for
regular spiritual ceremonies, saying, "We're going to do a pipe ceremony every week. We're also
going to do a smudge ceremony." This shows the ongoing commitment to time-honored
ceremonies and the deep respect for these spiritual practices. Such activities are crucial for
helping participants feel connected to their cultural and spiritual roots, which is a key part of
their recovery.
Continuing on this theme of cultural connection, an Elder shared a story highlighting the
support nature offers to humanity:
“In this version, when the creator made everything and before he lowered down the
human being, Anishinaabe, he asked all the plants and the animals and medicines, you
know, everyone that was here that he put down before Anishinaabe, if they would help
Anishinaabe when he got here. And they said, yeah, I will do that. So anyways they
lowered Anishinaabe to the earth and just like you know all the plants and animals they
all took care of it was like their little brother took care of Anishinaabe, gave what he
needed. But then after a while, everything was going good then after a while, there was a
lot of accidents that started happening. There was a lot of sickness and a lot of things
going on. And there was a lot of Anishinaabe that were dying. And so the creator asked
them all he said, I thought I asked you if you would take care of them. And so they said
that, they said, wow, you know, we've been trying to talk to them, we've been trying to
tell them what they need to do to take care of themselves, but they're not listening…
they're not understanding. There's like a miscommunication. And so the creator asked, he
said, who is going to be the one that will step up and help them with that? And it was the
tobacco plant, asemaa, that stepped up and said that I'll be the go-between, to
communicate. You know, to communicate to the creator, to the plants, to the animals.
And so that's why when you put out your tobacco you know why it's so important.
Because the story goes all the way back. The animals remember that."
Connecting to your manidoog is introduced through an Elder's advice, "Spend 20 to 30
minutes each morning communicating with [your spirits] as you offer each of them your
tobacco…The spirits, they're waiting for you to do that. And uh... [They] want to be
88
acknowledged, you know? They want to be acknowledged by you." This teaching emphasizes
the importance of spiritual communication and recognition in the healing journey, illustrating
how traditional beliefs and practices are integrated in recovery spaces.
The importance of connecting with one's ancestors for guidance and strength during
recovery is captured in another Elder's words, "They took care of the family. And you know, as
we begin that healing process, you know, for us men, you know, we start looking back to our
ancestors for a little guidance." This quote highlights the impact of ancestral connection and the
role of family and community in the healing process.
The Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center's incorporation of traditional cultural
practices into its recovery programs demonstrates a strong dedication to culturally relevant care.
By blending recovery methods with traditional practices led by community Elders, the center
provides culturally sensitive care. Peer recovery sessions, led by Elders and focused on cultural
teachings, meet the spiritual and cultural needs of participants. Regular traditional ceremonies
like pipe and smudge ceremonies show the center's respect for spirituality, helping participants in
connecting with their cultural and spiritual roots—an aspect to their recovery. The emphasis on
spiritual communication through manidoog highlights the importance of acknowledging spiritual
beliefs in the healing process. This approach reflects the belief that recovery extends beyond the
individual, forming a collective journey rooted in cultural and ancestral connections, laying the
groundwork for a recovery that honors cultural heritage.
In exploring the theme of Cultural Restoration Identity, the focus is on efforts to
rejuvenate Indigenous identity through traditional practices, ceremonies, and language learning.
This thematic analysis unfolds through an investigation into how these cultural elements
contribute to a sense of belonging and identity, which are fundamental to recovery.
89
The importance of traditional practices in reinforcing Indigenous identity is highlighted
through various narratives. An Elder comments on the historical attempts to diminish Indigenous
cultures, stating, "Remember it was a plot by this country to have us abandon our teachings and
ways in the name of civilizing us as Anishinaabe. So many of our people have fallen for that."
This statement brings to light the systemic challenges faced by Indigenous communities in
preserving their cultural practices, emphasizing the resilience and resistance in maintaining these
traditions as a core aspect of identity and recovery.
The incorporation of crafts and traditional activities within recovery programs is further
illustrated by a healthcare worker,
"I think a lot of it is like the craft side. Where they can bead. And smudging. Yeah, they
smudge... They sage often. I think [the owner] has sweet grass too. And then they have
the bags of tobacco that they have... Beading, dream catchers... They listen to powwow
music in the evenings too, when they get free time."
This quote demonstrates the holistic approach to cultural restoration, integrating physical,
spiritual, and communal practices that collectively support the journey to recovery. Participants
choose to spend their free time connecting with their culture and community.
One respondent, an Elder, emphasizes the holistic approach to well-being, stating,
"You know, we hear about it, you know, like we're supposed to take care of our body. You
know, we only got one of them…There ain't no do-overs…That's why they encourage
you to eat well, to sleep, you know, to exercise, you know, what we're creating for
movement."
This quote illustrates the Elder's belief in the importance of physical health as part of a
broader wellness approach in addiction recovery. It suggests that messages within recovery
programs should stress the value of physical care as integral to overall health and recovery
success.
90
In another reflection on the nature of physical existence and the enduring nature of the
spirit, an Elder articulates, "Our goal in life is to bring peace within us and our Anishinaabe spirit
that is within. We only occupy this physical body temporarily." This insight highlights the
importance of nurturing inner peace and spiritual well-being alongside physical health. The
quote suggests that recovery messages should acknowledge the spiritual aspects of healing,
encouraging individuals to cultivate peace within themselves as part of the recovery process.
The value of cultural narratives and teachings is expressed through an Elder's recounting
of the Anishinaabe creation story:
"So, like, in our creation story, the creator said that he gave us everything that we need in
life to do what is asked of the creator. And so, what he's talking about there is that in our
creation story, how we were created is that we came from the spirit world..."
This narrative emphasizes the belief in inherent strength and resources for healing,
bestowed by the creator. It indicates that recovery messaging should include cultural stories and
teachings to resonate with Indigenous individuals, reinforcing their capacity for recovery and
growth.
The significance of cultural identity in the journey to recovery is further discussed by an
Elder who speaks on the importance of receiving an Indian name,
"I think that's why it's important to get our Indian names so the creator and the spirits can
recognize who we are as Anishinaabe…When you get your Indian name, it's like
stepping into your Anishinaabe identity, you know? And it's like, you know, it helps us to
be who we really are."
This perspective shows the connection between cultural identity and the healing process,
indicating that accepting one's Ojibwe identity, symbolized by the act of receiving an Indian
name, is a meaningful step toward self-discovery and advancing in recovery.
In the community Elders often tell people who are not connected with their language the
role language and ceremonies hold,
91
"Learn our language and ceremonies. In our future, there will be a need to have people
who can do our ceremonies. If you want to keep busy, this is a line of work to pursue.
Think of the people that you can help and the satisfaction that comes from that."
This statement not only highlights the role of preserving language and ceremonial
practices but also positions them as essential for the community's future health and continuity.
The role of cultural identity in personal transformation is shown through the
encouragement of an Elder to fully embrace one's identity, "Embrace your Anishinaabe identity.
Our teaching ceremonies and language." This directive emphasizes the intrinsic link between
cultural identity and the recovery process, suggesting that a connection to one's roots is
fundamental to healing and growth.
These quotes collectively highlight how cultural restoration and identity play an
indispensable role in recovery. By engaging in traditional practices, learning the language, and
participating in ceremonies, individuals not only reclaim their identity but also pave a path
toward healing. This analysis reveals the impact of cultural restoration on recovery, emphasizing
the need to integrate these practices into recovery programs to create a sense of belonging,
identity, and well-being among Ojibwe peoples.
Exploring the community and social dimensions of recovery, this analysis looks into the
role of communal relationships and social networks in aiding recovery from addiction. At the
heart of this discussion is the acknowledgment that recovery-oriented communities, built on peer
support and mentorship by Elders and former clients, provide essential structures that enhance
the recovery journey. These communities emphasize the value of shared experiences and
communal resilience, highlighting the critical nature of community in the recovery process.
The insights from participants show that the effectiveness of addiction recovery materials
relies heavily on their design and visual appeal. These insights suggest that materials should not
92
only be accessible but also deeply resonate with the community by reflecting the tranquil
environment of recovery settings and including art and stories that are culturally relevant.
Participants express a strong desire for content that mirrors their own experiences and values,
indicating the necessity for materials to be engaging and representative. Criticism toward
materials that appear overly commercialized shows the need for genuine representation in how
information is presented. The incorporation of visual elements that evoke a sense of hope and
peace, along with stories that create human connection, emerges as a crucial strategy for
enhancing the impact of these materials on individuals contemplating or undergoing the recovery
process.
Our language that tells our empowering stories
In this section, the roles of cultural relevance, community narratives, empowerment,
hope, and the impacts of stigma and language in the addiction recovery process are explored,
with a particular focus on the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota. Cultural elements,
including traditions, practices, and languages, can enhance the effectiveness of recovery
programs and messaging. Feedback highlights a collective wish for the inclusion of these cultural
aspects, which not only honor the community's heritage but also render the recovery journey
more engaging and meaningful. The importance of community stories and personal experiences
is important, creating connections and understanding essential for recovery, helping to diminish
stigma and generate hope. Stories of empowerment and hope reflect the resilience and
transformative journey individuals undergo during recovery, emphasizing the critical role of
supportive communication and belief in the possibility of change. Additionally, discussions
about the impact of stigma and language reveal the influence societal attitudes and word choice
93
have on individuals with substance use disorder, pointing to the need for a more compassionate
and understanding recovery approach. By examining these elements, the section aims to offer
insights into the complex interplay between cultural and community factors in shaping recovery
messaging, advocating for approaches that respect cultural identities and are grounded in
community support and straightforward communication.
The importance of cultural relevance in the messaging of addiction recovery programs for
the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota is illuminated through direct feedback and
suggestions from both healthcare workers and participants. This feedback shows a collective
desire for the incorporation of cultural elements that reflect and honor Ojibwe traditions,
languages, and symbols.
A healthcare worker emphasizes the importance of activities that are not only
therapeutically beneficial but also culturally resonant, stating, "Maybe more like cultural -- how
any activities they do here are more culturally relevant. Like how they have beading and dream
catcher [making], that kind of stuff." This reflects an understanding of the need to intertwine
recovery processes with cultural practices that are meaningful to the community.
Another healthcare worker suggests enhancing the visual appeal of materials with
culturally specific designs: “If they wanted to focus more on like the Ojibwe, I think they should
incorporate more of like, you know, like the floral pattern on the borders or something."
Similarly, participants express a desire for more culturally indicative visuals, "I think some
flowers would be nice…on the sides," indicating a preference for designs that visually echo their
cultural heritage.
Language plays a role in cultural relevance, with a participant noting, “Some of our
language, you know, to show its got the talk.” This highlights the community's desire for the
94
inclusion of the Ojibwe language in recovery messaging, underscoring the importance of
language as a carrier of culture and identity.
Another participant's suggestion is to depict traditional ceremonies through artwork,
"Maybe show the ceremonies we do, like, through drawings," alongside the inclusion of cultural
references such as, “Say something about the seven fires prophecy or the grandfather teachings,"
points to a deeper layer of cultural integration. These elements not only serve to inform but also
to spiritually and culturally engage individuals in their recovery journey, connecting them with
their roots and providing a source of strength and inspiration.
Incorporating these cultural elements into recovery messaging acknowledges the
profound connection between cultural identity and healing. By weaving traditional practices,
languages, and symbols into the fabric of their communications, the recovery programs
demonstrate a deep respect for and understanding of the cultural heritage of the Ojibwe
community. This approach not only enriches the recovery experience but also reinforces the
community's connection to their cultural roots, enhancing the overall effectiveness of the
programs.
In addiction recovery, the importance of community stories and personal experiences is
central to crafting messages that resonate with individuals and the broader community. These
narratives serve an important function, enabling a sense of connection and understanding
important for recovery. The discussion on the importance of sharing in the recovery process
highlights how openness about one's journey can dismantle stigma and inspire others.
The impact of shared experiences is significant. For instance, the observation from a
facility staff member who has successfully navigated their own recovery journey speaks
volumes:
95
"We're here... And having people work here that went through this program is the most
powerful thing because they can say, 'I went here. I can do this, so can you.'" This
approach highlights the strength found in shared experiences and the belief in recovery
out loud to combat silent suffering, "we recover loudly so others don't have to die
quietly."
The question of why the sharing of these stories isn't more common is raised. "But
beyond that, we encourage people to tell their stories. A lot of people and places don't. I don't
understand that," a facility owner comments. This emphasizes the importance of sharing personal
narratives to reduce feelings of isolation.
The evolution of recovery methods is also examined. A reflective comment on traditional
programs highlights a shift in perspective: "AA is wonderful but it was started in the 30s before
this was classified as a disease. And so the anonymity was important then, but it hurts us now
sometimes..." This observation indicates a movement toward more open discussions in today’s
recovery context, moving away from the stigma once associated with addiction.
Personal stories shed light on the intricate challenges linked with addiction. One person
shares, "My friends died in front of me. I just couldn’t let that shit go. So, I got high." This
highlights how trauma and grief can lead someone to seek escape through substance use. It
shows the need for recovery programs to understand and address these challenges, tailoring
support to meet individuals where they are. This also involves recognizing personal limits and
finding supportive communities beyond the recovery center. A participant shares their
perspective on setting boundaries, "I just can't be around them anymore, because it makes me
wanna [use] too, and like, I’m trying to be healthy." This account sheds light on the impact
trauma can have on addiction and the critical need for recovery programs to be customized to fit
the specific needs of individuals, honoring their distinct paths and hurdles.
96
Recovery isn't a one-size-fits-all process. Personal stories add depth to this narrative. An
Elder shares a touching story of forgiveness following a family tragedy, highlighting the
emotional complexities families face,
"So I had a little brother. He died when he was 17. He was killed by a drunk driver... But
my dad, on the other hand, when we were going through court, because he absconded,
and they didn't find him for a few years... My dad didn't want that person that did that to
even get any jail time. I couldn't understand that at the time. But he processed things a
little differently than I did. You know, he already forgave that man.”
This story not only emphasizes the personal and non-linear nature of forgiveness but also
the diverse emotional landscapes that families navigate in the aftermath of addiction-related
incidents.
The motivation for recovery can stem from a desire to be there for family. "I gotta get
sober for my kids," shares a participant. This concise yet profound statement mirrors a common
sentiment among many seeking recovery, emphasizing the role of family in the healing journey.
The importance of community in healing is clear from what one facility owner shares:
"And connection and community is what helps heal all of us, and almost all physical and social
ills." This view supports the idea that a supportive community can help overcome not just
addiction but also other challenges. Being active in community events and being visible in the
recovery process helps fight stigma and proves that getting better is possible. The owner adds,
"You're truly building a community and that's what keeps support, and allows for the openness,
too, for the conversations that need to be had." This highlights the benefit of a community where
sharing openly and supporting each other creates a space for healing, showing that working
together and sharing experiences are key to healing as a group.
These narratives show how community support and knowledge sharing are essential.
Combining personal stories with community involvement enhances recovery messaging and
97
builds identity and resilience. Community Narratives are important in explaining the complex
path of addiction recovery, showing how individual and shared experiences provide hope and
drive change in a community-focused healing approach. This approach not only values shared
experiences and challenges but also shows the community's strength and commitment to support
each other’s recovery journeys.
In the context of recovery, personal stories bring to life the themes of Empowerment and
Hope, showing us the real challenges and victories individuals face. Their experiences show the
importance of clear and meaningful communication in supporting one’s journey to healing.
An owner of the recovery facility shares a powerful message, "Your life is worth it. It is.
It's not worth it to live in hell. No, absolutely not. And there's a way out. It's just, here, follow
me," highlighting the value of each person’s life and the possibility for change. This statement
directly addresses individuals in struggle, offering a guiding hand toward a path out of their
current predicaments, emphasizing recovery is within reach.
A participant reflects on their inner strength saying, “I know things don’t change out
there, so you gotta get strong in here and show them, out there, it’s possible.” This quote reveals
the inner work necessary for recovery, suggesting that resilience and a positive outlook are key to
overcoming external challenges. It suggests recovery involves personal growth that influences
and inspires others.
A broader perspective, an Elder who conducts ceremonies related to recovery in the
region shares, “our belief is that everyone is placed on this earth with a purpose. We all have a
mission to fulfill during our time here.” This adds a layer of meaning to the recovery journey,
suggesting that everyone has a unique purpose and contribution to make, which recovery can
help facilitate.
98
Following this, another Elder highlights the significance of our engagement with the
world, stating, "The energy we emit through our actions and the way we treat others and our
surroundings circles back to us." This shows the influence of our behavior and mindset on both
our personal well-being and the broader community, promoting a life led with care and positive
intent.
The stories shared by people on their journey to recovery emphasize the importance of
feeling empowered and hopeful. These accounts point out how important it is to have clear and
understanding communication to support recovery. Together, they reveal that recovery is more
than just stopping substance use—it's about finding one’s self-worth, growing stronger within,
finding one's purpose, and making a positive difference in the world. These personal stories
provide a wider and more inspiring view on recovery, showing it as a path of healing.
The narrative surrounding recovery messaging stresses the importance of hope and
empowerment. It underlines the role of clear, supportive communication in assisting those on
their journey. Central to this discourse is the belief in the intrinsic value of every person and their
potential for change. The narratives highlight the importance of resilience and the power one has
to inspire change in others. Contributions from those with deep experience reinforce the
message, pointing out the greater purpose of our lives and the impact our actions and attitudes
have on not just our own path to recovery but also on the broader community. This collection of
stories paints a picture where recovery messaging is about more than abstinence; it’s about
acknowledging personal value, nurturing inner strength, finding one's purpose, and making a
positive difference. These insights collectively offer a more complete and optimistic view of
recovery messaging as a journey of self-discovery and renewal, emphasizing its capacity to
transform not only individuals but also communities at large.
99
The intersection of stigma, language, and recovery is a complex and nuanced topic, as
revealed through the perspectives of various participants. Their experiences and views shed light
on how societal attitudes and the words we use can affect individuals with substance use
disorder.
One facility owner highlights the deliberate choice of language in the context of recovery,
stating, "We do choose to use verbiage now... I'm in recovery." This statement shows the
importance of self-identification and the positive impact of language on personal recovery
journeys. The choice of words like "recovery" over labels like "addict" reflects an understanding
of the power of language to shape identity and influence public perception.
Further emphasizing the complexity of language in medical contexts, another facility
owner criticizes medical jargon for its alienating effect, suggesting it's used "to make you feel
stupid so you don't ask questions." This perspective is important, as it points to the barriers
created by technical language, which can obstruct people's comprehension of their health
challenges and, consequently, the variety of routes available for healing and recovery.
The discussion around the term "addiction" versus "substance use disorder" reveals a
deep divide. While some advocate for clinical terminology to destigmatize the condition, others
believe it dilutes the severity and struggle inherent in the recovery process. One participant's
statement, "Substance use disorder.. addiction is the disease...We own up to it, you know…My
drug of choice is, but now I choose recovery," illustrates the embrace of clinical terms while also
acknowledging personal responsibility and the path to recovery.
An Elder's reflection on societal stigma extends the conversation beyond substance use,
"there are a lot of negative messages out there about us as Anishinaabe. In this country, anyone
who is different is considered inferior" highlighting broader issues of discrimination and
100
self-perception among Ojibwe peoples. This illustrates how stigma can permeate various aspects
of identity, influencing not just individuals with substance use disorders but also entire
communities.
Finally, the disparity in how society reacts to various health challenges, highlighted by a
facility owner's observation of the different responses to cancer compared to addiction, vividly
demonstrates stigma's effects. The statement, "when I had cancer, everybody showed up with a
casserole. And when I told everybody I was dealing with addiction, half the people I knew lost
my phone number," conveys the loneliness and exclusion faced by people with addiction due to
societal attitudes.
The exploration of stigma, language, and recovery through the voices of participants
reveals a deeply intertwined relationship affecting individuals with substance use disorder and
broader communities. The narratives presented illustrate the transformative power of language in
recovery, the challenges posed by medical jargon, and the societal shift required to embrace more
inclusive and compassionate approaches. As we navigate the complexities of these issues, it
becomes clear that a collective effort is needed to dismantle stigma and create an environment
where recovery is supported through understanding, acceptance, and empowering dialogue.
Access to information and recovery tools
The Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center actively addressed the challenges of
addiction recovery education, particularly the impact of misinformation and the importance of
accurate, evidence-based communication. Misinformation presented substantial obstacles,
making it crucial to provide clear, accessible, and medically accurate information to support
individuals on their recovery journey. Facility owners emphasized the importance of presenting
101
information clearly to prevent misunderstandings about the physiological effects of addiction.
Healthcare workers and participants pointed out the shortcomings in existing drug education and
recovery messages, highlighting the need for messages that were not only hopeful but also
actionable and rooted in scientific evidence. Through these conversations, the essential role of
trustworthy, evidence-based messaging in enhancing community engagement, building trust, and
supporting informed decisions about recovery became evident. This comprehensive view
underlined the collective call for improved recovery program messaging, focusing on clarity,
scientific validity, and actionability to effectively address the needs of those seeking recovery.
The exploration of Recovery Support and Future Directions examined the Northern
Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center's distinctive strategy of incorporating traditional cultural
practices within its addiction recovery programs. This section also highlighted the criticality of
tailoring care to meet the cultural needs of its participants, showing the center's commitment to a
recovery path that respects and responds to the diverse backgrounds of those it serves. The center
incorporated cultural identity through traditions and the leadership of community figures,
ensuring the care provided was both respectful and culturally aware. Special attention was given
to Ojibwe participants who benefited from peer recovery sessions led by Elders, incorporating
cultural teachings and healing practices tailored to their spiritual and cultural requirements. The
discussion extended to the center's future directions and expansion plans, highlighting a
proactive stance toward enhancing recovery services and filling existing gaps in care. This
strategic outlook included the development of a detox center and transitional housing, reflecting
the center's holistic approach to offering comprehensive support for those on their recovery
journey. By emphasizing the importance of an inclusive, comprehensive framework that aligns
with the complexities of addiction, the center aimed to facilitate more effective and empathetic
102
recovery outcomes, reinforcing the necessity of a compassionate, community-oriented
framework for recovery that honors each individual’s journey within a collective path to
wellness.
In the analysis of accurate and clear information's role in addiction recovery education,
interviewees brought to light the adverse effects of misinformation and the essential need for
evidence-based messaging. Facility owners emphasized the critical need for medical accuracy,
stating, "So then we have medical misinterpretation... This is how we medically have to do this.
This is what actually happens physiologically. And so we need to make sure in our
communication that it's clear..." This quote highlighted the necessity of clarity and accuracy in
presenting medical information, suggesting a foundational requirement for recovery education.
They further stressed the importance of accessible information, noting, "And so we need to make
sure in our communication that it's clear and that if people have questions, there's a clear line of
this is where you get more information," indicating that clear channels for further information
could empower individuals in their recovery journey.
A healthcare worker criticized the lack of comprehensive messaging in recovery
resources and stated, "No resources, no help, no messaging about how to get help, no additional,
nothing. Literally says recovery is possible. And I know this because I've seen them and paid
attention to it." This reflected a shortfall in providing actionable information, highlighting the
need for messages that extended beyond hopeful statements in recovery materials. Participants
also shared their experiences with drug education programs, with one remarking, "I remember
D.A.R.E. what a shit show,” and another sharing, “This is the only place I really cared about
learning about drugs. Unless it was from my friends." These comments suggested dissatisfaction
103
with traditional drug education efforts and a preference for environments that offered accurate,
relatable information.
These quotes collectively highlight the critical demand for accurate, clear, and
evidence-based information within addiction recovery education. They uncover a widespread
concern over misinformation and showcased how clear, accurate communication could support
individuals in making informed decisions about their recovery. Addressing these concerns
enhanced community engagement and trust, contributing to more effective addiction recovery
education.
The conversation on misinformation versus accurate information within addiction
recovery education highlighted a critical demand for transparency, accuracy, and reliance on
evidence-based messaging. Insights from facility owners, healthcare workers, and program
participants spotlighted the negative impact of misinformation on individuals seeking recovery,
advocating for a shift toward communication that was clear, scientifically verified, and
actionable. Critiques of traditional drug education programs, such as D.A.R.E., by participants,
showed a mismatch between these programs' objectives and the actual needs of their intended
audience. These narratives collectively expressed a desire for recovery education that
empowered individuals with knowledge, promoted informed decision-making, and enhanced
trust through credibility and relevance. The conclusion drawn from this discussion suggested a
pathway forward that involved a dedicated effort to improve the quality of recovery program
messaging by focusing on accuracy and evidence, which was essential for supporting individuals
on their journey toward informed recovery and sustained well-being.
104
Education and Awareness within addiction recovery initiatives at Northern Minnesota
Addiction Wellness Center focus on various outreach and engagement strategies to provide
access to services and deepen the understanding of substance use. By employing diverse
methods, such as explaining moderation practices to delineate safe alcohol consumption,
engaging with young people through school programs, and offering personalized recovery
materials, recovery centers can strive to inform and empower individuals on their path to healing.
Moreover, the value of direct community interaction and personal stories is highlighted, with
efforts to stay informed on evolving substance use trends and harnessing the power of
recommendations. These comprehensive approaches collectively aim to create a supportive and
well-informed community that motivates individuals toward recovery, showcasing the intricate
nature of educational and awareness efforts in these programs.
One facility owner emphasized the educational aspect of their outreach, stating,
"Teaching moderation, talking about, hey, this is a normal amount of alcohol to have in a week."
This quote highlighted the facility’s commitment to providing practical, health-oriented
information as a cornerstone of its outreach efforts, aiming to inform individuals about safe
alcohol consumption limits. Another strategy involved direct engagement with schools, "we went
to the high schools, the middle school, both of the charter schools," demonstrating the center’s
proactive approach in connecting with younger demographics to spread awareness about
substance use and recovery options.
Another aspect of outreach was illustrated by the facility’s interaction with the
community, “It's because they had, I could see what the new synthetics were on the street
because it's a head shot... The clear glass, that's for, I don't know. And so there was a lot, I
wanted to know what was new on the street while I went there”. This quote reflected the center's
105
efforts to stay informed about current substance use trends, demonstrating their proactive stance
in adapting their awareness strategies to address emerging challenges. Such engagement not only
helped the center in tailoring their educational content but also established their credibility and
trustworthiness among the target audience.
The role of personal recommendations and familial influence in raising awareness was
further highlighted by a participant's reflection, “My baby mama went here. She OD’d. So I had
to get right for our kids." This quote illustrates the powerful impact of personal experiences and
word-of-mouth in motivating individuals to seek help, highlighting the social dimension of
awareness and the importance of community in the recovery journey.
Personal stories from participants also offer valuable insights into the outreach efforts'
effectiveness. For instance, one participant mentioned, "My grandma told me about this place,
she said it's good healing there," showcasing word-of-mouth and family referrals as crucial
channels for raising awareness about recovery services. Additionally, a participant noted, "I
heard a ad on the radio. With a native voice said we deserve to heal too. It’s not just a white
man's space," pointing to the importance of culturally sensitive messaging and the role of media
in reaching broader and more diverse audiences.
A health care worker reflected, “So when they come in, they're actually given a three-ring
binder, sketchbook, journals, and they can create their own how-to-recover manual” ,
emphasizing the center's approach to education. This method not only provides information but
also engages participants actively in their recovery process, offering a personalized tool for
reflection and growth. Such strategies highlight the center's commitment to empowering
individuals through education, catering to diverse learning preferences and enhancing the
personal relevance of recovery information.
106
These quotes collectively indicate that education and awareness initiatives are
fundamental to enhancing access to recovery services. Through direct education on substance
use, engagement with educational institutions, personal recommendations, and culturally
inclusive media outreach, the treatment center effectively engages with a wide audience. These
strategies inform potential participants about available services and play a role in destigmatizing
recovery, thereby making it more accessible to various communities. The variety of outreach
methods discussed in these narratives show the necessity for a comprehensive approach to
education and awareness in addiction recovery programs.
Moving from the general concept of community support to the specific approach of the
facility, as highlighted by its owners, the importance of lived experience and peer support in
recovery was brought to light. The owners shared, "Both [of our Elders are] enrolled in Red
Lake. And they both spent prison time, and they both have long-term recovery" and "90% of us
are in recovery... We've been there." These statements reveal the facility's commitment to
employing staff who can empathize with the recovery journey, creating an environment of
understanding and mutual respect. Including Elders who share cultural heritage and recovery
experiences offers a layer of support that is both unique and enriching for those in the recovery
program.
Further exploring the role of culture in recovery, the analysis highlighted how integrating
cultural practices into the recovery process was crucial. Statements from healthcare workers such
as "We offered peer recovery that was specifically for this area Native American. And we had
other peer recovery that we worked with" and "It was like, we were able to provide a lot of that
peer recovery specifically for Native Americans... We did have, like, a cultural night," illustrated
the facility’s commitment to cultural relevance. This approach acknowledged the healing power
107
of connecting with one's cultural roots and traditions, showing an understanding that recovery
involved reconnecting with one's identity as much as overcoming addiction.
Building on the theme of cultural integration in a community, the concept of a
recovery-oriented community was further explored. Efforts to create a specific and inclusive
recovery community were mentioned in "It was a community thing but only people who
graduated from here could come not just anybody. Right, so it was very specific to the
community they were building." This strategic approach not only created a sense of belonging
but also strengthened the support network among individuals who shared similar recovery
journeys, reinforcing the foundational idea that recovery thrives in a community setting.
An observation by a health care worker shows the importance of this community
building, “They learn more from their peers than they do from us," reinforces the idea that peer
relationships are instrumental in recovery. Peer support provides a unique avenue for shared
learning and growth, rooted in the common experiences of those involved. This mutual exchange
not only empowers individuals on their recovery path but also strengthens a sense of community
solidarity.
Compared, the facility owner critiqued conventional therapy approaches, stating, "Most
therapists are the 'oh yes that's so good.' And you can't do that in addiction medicine... And I
think that's probably why so many of us that have been in it first person or our family members
because they can't bullshit us." This highlighted the value of lived experience in fostering
genuine connections. This insight underscored the notion that individuals who had personally
navigated the recovery journey, or had closely observed a loved one's journey, brought an
irreplaceable level of empathy and comprehension to the recovery process.
108
Emphasizing the transformative impact of engaging in meaningful work and activities,
the owners of the facility shared, "And it's given him a new sense of purpose, too, because he
gets to help kids, and he gets to show people he loves wood in the outdoors, and making things."
This quote illustrated how recovery involved discovering joy and purpose in life's activities and
passions, which, in turn, could inspire others within the recovery community.
Echoing the importance of personal connection and understanding, another facility owner
mentioned, "Meeting people where they were at and listening to them. Just making them feel
heard was most of my job." This approach recognized the individual nature of the recovery
journey, emphasizing the need to customize support to each person's specific situation and needs.
By actively listening and affirming the experiences of those in recovery, a supportive atmosphere
was cultivated, creating a sense of belonging and acceptance.
In conclusion, the exploration of community and social dimensions in recovery
emphasizes the integral role of communal relationships, cultural integration, and peer support as
foundational elements that facilitate the recovery journey. Through the lens of a facility deeply
committed to embodying these principles, we see a model where lived experiences, mutual
respect, and cultural relevance converge to create a supportive and understanding environment.
This approach not only acknowledges the healing power of belonging and shared experiences but
also celebrates the transformative impact of engaging in meaningful activities and personal
connections. By prioritizing a recovery process that is as much about rebuilding lives and
identities as it is about overcoming addiction, this analysis reaffirms the necessity of a
compassionate, community-oriented framework for recovery that honors the unique journey of
each individual within a collective path to wellness.
109
Exploring the challenges and barriers to recovery, this section illuminates the diverse and
multifaceted obstacles individuals face on their journey toward healing from addiction.
Recognizing the external and internal hurdles—including personal challenges, systematic
barriers, and the diversity of recovery experiences—is crucial for developing supportive and
effective recovery pathways. This understanding is essential for addressing the complexities of
the recovery journey and facilitating more effective outcomes.
Personal struggles presented barriers to recovery, confronting individuals with the reality
that their journey toward healing might be one of the most challenging experiences of their lives.
As one participant candidly shared, recovery was "the hardest thing you've ever done in your life,
but you're worth it." This sentiment was echoed in the raw expression of another participant who
detailed their physical and emotional hardship, saying, “I couldn’t get any sleep, I was always
shaking, I couldn’t eat anything. Everything was hard.” These personal accounts highlighted the
intense and often painful struggles faced by individuals in recovery, showing the necessity for
supportive, understanding, and patient-centered approaches to help navigate recovery challenges.
These internal battles were compounded by legal challenges, such as the criminalization
of paraphernalia, which could deter individuals from seeking help due to fear of legal
repercussions. The recent change in the law regarding paraphernalia was a step toward reducing
such barriers, "It was now legal to have paraphernalia...Thank fucking God...Everybody got
nailed on fifth-degree possession charges which was usually for paraphernalia... If you got
caught with a syringe and you were not a diabetic, you could be prosecuted. Until two weeks
ago," but the stigma and challenges persisted.
Systemic barriers, as recounted by the facility owners, included entrenched policies and
societal structures that had historically hindered access to care and support. For instance, "We're
110
talking about drug policies that were enacted in the 1980s, which had set us up to be where we're
at today... It had to happen, or we were never going to be able to get this problem under control,"
highlighted how outdated and punitive drug policies continued to affect individuals seeking
recovery.
Moreover, the limited availability of resources, exacerbated by the pandemic's impact on
treatment centers, underscored the critical need for increased support and flexibility in recovery
services. One of the facility owners articulated this concern, stating, "The pandemic closed 50%
of treatment resources that won't be opening back up again. Alcohol sales were up 39% since the
pandemic started and haven't come down." This observation illustrated the gap between the need
for recovery services and their availability, highlighting the urgency of addressing this disparity
to support individuals in their recovery journey effectively.
Systemic barriers included entrenched policies and societal structures that had historically
hindered access to care and support. For example, one owner described a local challenge, "And
then it was like, okay, I filled up every other place in town. And they were going to close their
office up here, and I'm like, no no... welcome to the good old boys club up here." This statement
not only highlighted the difficulty in securing space for recovery services due to local politics
and exclusions but also emphasized the broader issue of limited recovery resources in certain
areas. Additionally, a healthcare worker shed light on professional silos that further complicated
the delivery of care: "Because LADCs wouldn't share their tools and resources with each
other...But yeah, so you had to be an LADC to provide services." This insight revealed another
layer of complexity, where professional gatekeeping and the requirement of specific licensure
limited the availability and diversity of recovery support services.
111
Cultural and family dynamics also played a role in the recovery journey. An Elder
reflected, "And so it was our job to come back to that path that the creator gave us," speaking to
the need for culturally sensitive recovery paths that honored individual and community heritage.
The landscape is revealed as being filled with obstacles ranging from systemic and
professional to personal and cultural complexities. Through the insights shared by facility
owners, healthcare workers, and participants, a clear image of the multifaceted hurdles on the
path to recovery emerges. A poignant statement from a participant, “There are only a few places
that really care about you, you know?” highlights the essence of these challenges, underscoring
the critical need for compassionate, accessible, and adaptable recovery services. This remark not
only points to the scarcity of supportive environments but also emphasizes the importance of
creating more spaces where the well-being and recovery of individuals are genuinely prioritized.
Addressing these barriers with empathy and action is essential for forging effective and caring
pathways toward recovery, ensuring individuals on this journey find the understanding, support,
and opportunities for healing they deserve.
The journey of addiction recovery is a multifaceted process that necessitates a
comprehensive understanding of the individual's biopsychosocial needs. The Northern
Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center adopts a holistic approach to recovery, emphasizing the
importance of respecting and integrating the biological, psychological, and social dimensions of
healing. This approach is predicated on the understanding that each individual’s path into
addiction is unique; hence, their pathway out requires a tailored strategy that respects their
distinct experiences and challenges. Central to this recovery process is the empowerment of
individuals, enabling them to take charge of their journey with the support of a guiding and
encouraging environment. The act of forgiveness, coupled with the cultural teachings of the
112
Anishinaabe, further enriches this discourse, highlighting the importance of forgiveness and
cultural sensitivity in the healing journey. This section looks into the essence of such a recovery
model, exploring its implications for individuals navigating the complexities of addiction and
recovery.
The facility's approach, as described by its owners, emphasizes a comprehensive model
that respects the biopsychosocial aspects of recovery, celebrating the integration of various
treatment modes to meet individual needs. This method acknowledges that "all of us get into our
addiction through different paths. All pathways in and all pathways out…Many of us have
different ways of how we got into addiction. And so we need different ways of how we get out of
it," recognizing the importance of a tailored recovery journey that accommodates the diversity of
experiences and challenges faced by those in recovery.
Central to this process was the empowerment of individuals in their recovery journey. As
one owner put it, "I told my own clients, this is not about me driving the bus, you're driving the
bus. I'm hanging out in the passenger's side with a road map and some tools and a cheerleading
section." This perspective placed the individual at the helm of their recovery, supported by
guidance, resources, and encouragement, personal agency and self-determination in healing.
Within the journey of healing and personal transformation, the act of forgiveness emerged
as a spectrum of experiences, encompassing a range of emotions and milestones that contributed
to recovery. Participants articulated the complexity of forgiveness, from the liberating decision to
forgive for one's own peace and well-being, as one shared, "Forgiving him just so that I could not
be miserable anymore because it has no effect whatsoever on my abuser. But just so that I could
live a more better life," to the ongoing struggle and realization that forgiveness is a "daily
process." Another participant recounted a moment she found forgiveness, "I couldn't forgive my
113
teacher for abusing me and my children...It's a daily process. But...I was very miserable and I
used to drink and probably like five years ago I was blacked out and all that anger that I was
carrying had come out of a blackout." These narratives showed the deeply personal and
sometimes arduous journey toward forgiveness, highlighting its role not just in healing from past
wounds, but in fundamentally reshaping one's life and future.
The cultural teachings of the Anishinaabe further enriched this discussion, providing a
perspective on forgiveness. An Elder's guidance, "We were taught as Anishinaabe to forgive even
those who may have killed our closest relatives or friends," introduced a spiritual dimension to
forgiveness, highlighting its importance in healing and community cohesion. This wisdom,
coupled with personal accounts of participants who spoke of forgiveness as a turning point in
their recovery, illustrated the broad spectrum of forgiveness experiences. From achieving a sense
of peace and a better life to grappling with forgiveness as an ongoing process, these stories
reflected the transformative potential of forgiveness in the recovery journey. Each narrative,
whether it was about coming to terms with past abuse, finding joy in cultural reconnection, or the
desire to contribute positively to others' lives, echoed the profound impact of forgiveness on
personal identity, purpose, and the broader process of healing.
Moreover, the healing journey was marked by moments of realization and growth, such
as an Elder's reflection, "We were only here a short time...We may be young right now, but I'm
telling you, from 28 to 54, it went by quickly," which emphasized the preciousness of life and the
urgency of embracing recovery and transformation. The development of new neural pathways
through prayer and meditation, as another Elder noted,
"It was like creating these new neural pathways inside the brain, you know, for healing,
you know, for resilience, for feeling good, you know, all these good things that happen
when you pray, when you meditate, you know, good things happen,"
114
signified the profound changes that occurred within the brain and spirit in the recovery
process, creating resilience, well-being, and a renewed sense of hope.
The comprehensive model adopted by the facility, as detailed by its owners and reflected
in the narratives of its clients, shows the importance of a personalized and culturally sensitive
approach to addiction recovery. By honoring the individuality of each person’s journey into and
out of addiction, and emphasizing empowerment, forgiveness, and cultural relevance, the facility
creates an environment where recovery is not just possible but is supported by an understanding
of the biopsychosocial aspects of healing. This model highlights the importance of community,
cultural identity, and the empowerment of individuals in crafting recovery paths that are as
diverse and varied as the individuals themselves. Moving forward, the insights from this
approach can inform the development of more effective and compassionate recovery programs,
ultimately contributing to a broader understanding of addiction recovery and the diverse
pathways to healing.
The Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center is actively pursuing new pathways
and growth opportunities aimed at enhancing the scope of support for those on their recovery
journey from addiction. This strategic outlook is shaped by insights gathered from detailed
interviews with both the facility's owners and healthcare professionals working within the center.
Central to their expansion plans is the development of a detox center and the formulation of
transitional housing options. These efforts underscore the center's commitment to a holistic
approach in providing addiction recovery services.
The facility owners highlight the Community Resource Connections (CRC), representing
collaborative efforts among non-profit and service organizations to support individuals in
recovery.
115
"There's something here called Community Resource Connections. It's wonderful. The
executive director has organized community resource connections. It is like all the
non-profit and service organizations. And we can also, there's a once a month meeting we
can go to. I try to at least hit the yearly meetings, so that we can all go around and tell
each other what we do."
Further detailing the center's expansion plans, a healthcare worker and the owners discuss
the goal to establish a detox center soon, demonstrating a concrete commitment to expanding
service offerings to meet the immediate needs of those seeking freedom from substance
dependence. A health care worker reflected,
"[They are] wanting to build a detox center... eventually they want to do like a halfway
house. The halfway house will be quite a ways down the road, but hopefully the detox
will be within the next year or two, at tops. That's what their plan is."
The owner's vision encompasses a complete care continuum, from detoxification to sober
living environments, with a focus on family-centered recovery. This vision acknowledges
addiction as affecting not only the individual but also their family, emphasizing a healing process
that considers the entire family system.
"My goal before I die is to have detox all the way through sober living. With different
types of family living. Because this is a family disease. And if we take kids away and
keep snapping them back and forth, they don't learn anything but that the system is still
broken. And so if we can really start to look at the whole family, helping the family heal,
you know, what the kids' roles are, helping them understand that."
These insights reflect a proactive stance toward enhancing recovery services, revealing a
commitment to addressing the needs of those in recovery. The described initiatives not only
showcase the center's dedication to filling existing gaps but also highlight a strategic approach to
building resilient support systems that align with the diverse and changing needs of individuals
pursuing recovery. This strategy emphasizes the importance of an inclusive, comprehensive, and
flexible framework that aligns with the complexities of addiction, facilitating more effective and
empathetic recovery outcomes.
116
Interview Conclusion
This phase of work emphasizes culturally informed and community-focused methods in
developing effective messaging for addiction recovery resources targeted at the Ojibwe
community. By closely aligning these messages with the unique identity and values of the
Ojibwe people, there is a pronounced opportunity to enhance the resonance and impact of such
initiatives. This strategy goes beyond simply acknowledging the distinct identity and resilience
of the community; it lays the groundwork for crafting messages that support more engaging and
enduring recovery journeys, establishing a standard for holistic and culturally sensitive
communication.
This analysis shows a clear preference for messages within addiction recovery materials
that are empowering, tailored to cultural values, and respectful. The community's favor for
positive over fear-based messaging, the effectiveness of a variety of communication channels,
and the importance of cultural integration into recovery materials shows the need for resources
that resonate with the community's traditions and language.
Recommendations for refining recovery messaging include careful selection of language,
tone,artwork, and content that embody inclusivity, hope, and positivity, while thoughtfully
incorporating aspects of Ojibwe culture and values. Utilizing a variety of communication
channels to disseminate these messages ensures that they reach the intended audience effectively
and engagingly.
The forthcoming expansions at the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center, such
as the introduction of a detox center and transitional housing, provide a practical context for
applying and assessing the effectiveness of culturally tailored messaging. This initiative could act
117
as a template for similar efforts, highlighting the crucial role of cultural sensitivity and
community engagement in the wider field of addiction recovery.
In conclusion, this phase advocates for a strategic approach to crafting recovery
messages, grounded in cultural awareness and community involvement. Such an approach not
only aligns with the Ojibwe community's values and identity but also promises to improve the
overall impact of recovery resources. By promoting messages that uplift and integrate the
cultural identity of the community, there's potential to support more meaningful and sustainable
recovery journeys.
Insights from Collaborative Creation Circles
The Collaborative Creation Circles served a role in engaging community members from
the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center in the co-design process of communication
materials (Lindquist et al., 2007; Apers et al., 2023; Grindell et al., 2022; Goodyear-Smith et al.,
2015). This initiative was rooted in the principle that incorporating the perspectives and insights
of those directly impacted by substance use disorder into the creation of recovery materials
would yield culturally resonant and impactful messages. The subsequent analysis of these
sessions aims to uncover key insights into effective, culturally aligned recovery strategies, with a
focus on how community involvement in the design process can enhance the relevance and
acceptance of recovery support materials.
In analyzing the artifacts and discussions from the Collaborative Creation Circles,
thematic analysis was used (Braun & Clarke, 2006). This approach facilitated the identification
of common themes that reflect the community's experiences, values, and aspirations regarding
recovery. Additionally, grounded theory was important in understanding these emergent themes,
118
providing a structured framework for developing theories based on the data collected during
participatory activities (Strauss & Corbin, 1998). This analysis method made sure that the
insights gained from the creative activities were closely connected to the community's real-life
experiences and cultural background.
The integration of insights from the Collaborative Creation Circles with interview data,
as described in the dissertation's method section, was important in achieving a comprehensive
understanding of culturally resonant recovery strategies. This process involved a careful
examination of how the findings from the circles complemented or contrasted with those from
the interviews, thereby enriching the analysis and deepening the understanding of the
community's needs and preferences. By juxtaposing the creative expressions from the
Collaborative Creation Circles with the narrative data from interviews, a multi-dimensional
picture of the community's approach to recovery was constructed. This integrative technique
shows the value of leveraging diverse data sources to paint a fuller picture of the community's
perspectives on recovery, thereby facilitating the development of communication materials that
are not only culturally sensitive but also meaningful to the community members they are
intended to support. My goal is to articulate how such expressions inform future communication
strategies for similar audiences, emphasizing effective practices that engage and support
individuals in recovery.
Figure 1
Effective communication tools are essential for connecting individuals with the support
and resources they need. The creation of these tools, especially when involving co-design and
artwork, presents a unique opportunity to integrate cultural sensitivity, personal relevance, and
119
community engagement into recovery programs. This analysis
examines the collaborative creation of a brochure by participants
at the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center. It focuses
on how co-designed artwork, incorporating symbols such as the
medicine wheel, the phrase "Gaanawaanindiwug" meaning "Take
Care of Each Other," and a feather, highlights key concepts of
healing, community support, and cultural awareness.
The brochure artwork for figure 1a, which includes a
medicine wheel, the phrase "Gaanawaanindiwug" meaning "Take
Care of Each Other," and a feather, highlights important ideas of
healing, support from the community, and being mindful of
cultural backgrounds. The medicine wheel, a symbol showing
how life is a cycle and everything is connected, connects well
with the ideas of integrating cultural sensitivity and relevance. Bringing cultural symbols into the
recovery process is important because it respects cultural traditions and makes the journey to
healing more meaningful by linking it to familiar contexts.
The phrase "Take Care of Each Other" and the presence of a feather add more layers to
the story this artwork tells, resonating with themes like the Community and Social Dimensions
of Recovery and Healing and Personal Transformation. These elements highlight the importance
of supporting each other and the spiritual side of healing, showing how a community plays a key
role in building strength and empowerment during recovery. Furthermore, the message below the
medicine wheel brings together the ideas of cultural significance and community support in
healing, representing the themes of Cultural Relevance and Community Social Recovery. This
120
shows a comprehensive approach to recovery, where cultural traditions and community support
are crucial. It shows how the artwork can convey complex ideas of cultural identity, community
support, and personal change. It demonstrates the ability of co-designed communication tools to
connect strongly with communities, creating a sense of belonging, understanding, and hope in
the recovery journey,
The two pipes placed below the medicine wheel add another layer to how traditional
practices merge with the journey of recovery, showing the strong link between cultural heritage
and healing within the Ojibwe community. These pipes, usually seen in ceremonies and prayers
in Indigenous cultures, stand for talking to the spiritual world, bringing guidance, strength, and
support for those working toward recovery. This part of the artwork connects well with the
themes of Cultural Sensitivity Integration and Cultural Relevance, as well as Community and
Social Dimensions of Recovery. It shines a light on the importance of both community and
spiritual support in healing, taking a group-based approach to recovering from addiction. The
inclusion of the pipes emphasizes the need for spiritual conversations and keeping in touch with
cultural foundations as key parts of the recovery journey, adding to the story that recovery is a
shared path to wellness, uplifted by cultural traditions and unity within the community. This
visual element acts as a strong reminder of the power that lies in knowing one's cultural identity
and the strength of community ties, supporting the center's dedication to a recovery path that is
both full of culture and covers all aspects of healing.
The upper corners of the brochure showcase traditional Ojibwe Woodlands art flowers
and patterns, closely linked to the cultural and spiritual practices of Ojibwe peoples. These
designs, inspired by nature, serve as expressions of the Ojibwe's connection to the natural
environment, representing themes of growth, renewal, and the continuous cycle of life, all
121
reflective of the recovery path. The floral motifs, particularly common in Ojibwe beadwork,
highlight the critical role of plants, offering simplified yet striking depictions of the natural
world. These motifs distill the essence of flora important to Ojibwe traditions, drawing directly
from nature to produce stylized versions that carry both cultural stories and individual narratives.
Incorporating these motifs into the brochure respects Ojibwe aesthetic traditions while
also adding cultural and spiritual depth to the materials. This natural inspiration and the method
of simplification allow the designs to convey a visual story about healing, growth, and renewal,
crucial aspects of the recovery journey. This method aligns with the key ideas of Cultural
Relevance and Cultural Foundations in Recovery, highlighting the essential role of cultural
identity in recovery efforts and the impact of art in establishing a sense of belonging.
Moreover, the brochure gives attention to the medicinal and spiritual qualities of specific
plants featured in Ojibwe beadwork, like wild violets, selected not only for their visual appeal
but also for their therapeutic and spiritual properties. Wild violets, marking the onset of spring,
are used in remedies ranging from skin treatments to restorative teas, illustrating the link
between cultural practices, art, and the natural world.
The layout is straightforward yet carries deeply meaningful elements, aligning with
Visual Design Preferences which emphasize the influence of visual design on message
effectiveness. With the directive "Take care of each other" prominently displayed at the top in
Ojibwe, it serves as a powerful call to action, encouraging care, support, and solidarity among
community members. The translation of this phrase into English at the bottom ensures
inclusivity, making the message accessible to others who may not be familiar with the language,
creating a sense of belonging and understanding.
122
The inclusion of cultural symbols and the use of the Ojibwe language, coupled with the
emphasis on community, indicate the artist's dedication to a recovery methodology that is rooted
in culture and communal values. This approach aligns with the Cultural Restoration Identity
theme, focusing on the revival and strengthening of Indigenous identity through traditional
practices and symbols, deemed crucial for the healing process. This design strategy showcases a
commitment to a recovery path that respects and honors Ojibwe heritage and community bonds,
highlighting the importance of cultural and
communal support in the journey toward
healing and recovery.
In figure 1b, the brochure's inside
message is clear and direct: "Everything you
need is right here! Programs rooted in our
culture." This message highlights the theme of
Education and Awareness by stressing how
important it is to have easy access to resources
that are specifically designed for cultural
needs. It suggests that you can find everything you need for addiction recovery in one place,
which is especially designed with cultural traditions in mind.
Talking about "Programs rooted in our culture" connects directly to the Cultural
Relevance theme. It shows how including cultural elements—like traditional practices,
languages, and symbols that mean a lot to the Ojibwe community—is crucial in making recovery
messages and programs work better. These cultural touches are key in making the
communication tools more effective and engaging for those looking for recovery resources.
123
The mention of a square marked "picture" seems to hint at a space for adding images later
or might suggest including real, tangible examples of the resources or cultural programs
mentioned. This fits with the Visual and Design Preferences theme, showing how important
visual aspects are in making the message stronger, thus improving the way the communication is
received.
Overall, these parts of the brochure—straightforward messaging, the inclusion of culture,
and visual design considerations—show a thoughtful approach to what the community prefers
when it comes to messaging for recovery programs. They highlight a strategy that values clear
communication, cultural connections, and engaging design in creating tools that effectively
support addiction recovery.
The co-design process in developing communication tools for addiction recovery, reveals
the impact of incorporating cultural and community elements into recovery materials. Through
the integration of symbols like the medicine wheel, traditional phrases, and feathers, the brochure
communicates complex ideas of cultural identity, community solidarity, and personal
transformation. These elements not only make the recovery journey more meaningful for
individuals by connecting it to familiar cultural practices but also enhance the overall
effectiveness of the communication tools. By focusing on the preferences for messaging within
addiction recovery program materials, this collaborative effort illustrates how artwork can be a
powerful medium for conveying hope, support, and a sense of belonging.
Figure 2
This brochure showcases a strategic blend of communication techniques tailored for
addiction recovery, from highlighting a positive environment to integrating culturally significant
124
practices like smudging, the brochure exemplifies a thoughtful strategy in creating a supportive,
informative, and inclusive setting for individuals in recovery.
The front of the brochure, figure 2a, references to a "great positive environment"
exemplifies the importance of positive framing in recovery
program materials, resonating with the Empowerment and Hope
category. This approach aligns with the desire for messages that
inspire hope, motivation, and empowerment in the recovery
journey, emphasizing the creation of an uplifting and supportive
space for community members seeking recovery. Such messaging
is crucial in creating an environment conducive to healing and
motivating individuals to engage with recovery resources.
Likewise, the brochure’s role in increasing awareness about
the center's services—by highlighting licensed counselors, nursing
staff, and the availability of both inpatient and outpatient
services—addresses the Access Awareness category. This direct
method of informing potential clients is key to the outreach efforts,
ensuring that individuals are well-informed of the center's
capabilities and services. By listing these features, the brochure
plays a role in enhancing accessibility and awareness, thereby facilitating an essential step in the
recovery journey by making these services known to those in need.
These elements reflect a co-design approach where the preferences and insights of the
recovery community are central to the creation of communication materials. Including such
preferences not only makes the messaging more effective but also ensures that the materials are
125
culturally and contextually relevant to the audience they aim to reach. This dual focus on
positive, empowering messaging and clear, accessible information about recovery services
demonstrates a nuanced understanding of what makes communication tools effective in the
context of addiction recovery programs.
The brochure acts as a helpful guide, gently teaching the reader about the professional
support the center offers. This matches the Education and Awareness theme by focusing on the
team's qualifications, contributing to better knowledge about the center's quality of support. By
highlighting the staff's expertise, the brochure informs potential clients about the excellent care
they can expect, aligning with the goal of making people aware and confident about the center's
services. This method is key in not just sharing information about what services are available but
also in building trust in the level of care provided.
Discussing licensed professionals and a positive setting can also help tackle the issue of
stigma. When the brochure emphasizes a professional and uplifting atmosphere, it indirectly
fights against stigma by using language that supports respect and understanding, and promotes a
message of support and care.
When looking at the theme, Cultural
Relevance, the front of the brochure doesn't
specifically talk about cultural aspects, the
focus on professionalism and types of services
might hint that these offerings don't
specifically address cultural needs or customs.
It would be clearer if there were direct
mentions of cultural inclusion. Inside the
126
brochure, figure 2b, mentions "smudging" and states it is "Ojibwe culture friendly" clearly
connected with cultural relevance. Smudging is an important practice for many Ojibwe peoples,
often used for cleansing and spiritual purposes. By including such culturally significant practices,
the brochure shows a meaningful effort to respect and incorporate Indigenous cultural beliefs
into recovery messaging.
Inside the brochure, figure 2b, shows the theme of Community and Social Dimensions of
Recovery through the inclusion of communal activities such as horseshoes, cornhole, and a
live-in pet dog within the center's offerings. These amenities play a crucial role in fostering a
sense of community and peer support, serving as informal settings for social interaction and
mutual support. Such environments are essential for facilitating a sense of belonging and shared
experience, which are foundational to the social recovery process. These activities not only
provide a means for leisure and relaxation but also act as important avenues for building
relationships and support networks that are crucial for individuals on their journey to recovery.
The brochure clearly states, "We accommodate to all your addiction recovery needs," and
provides a contact number, demonstrating a strong commitment to being accessible and prepared
to meet a wide variety of needs. This message aligns perfectly with the Access and Awareness
theme, which emphasizes the importance of making sure clients know about the services
available and how they can access them. This approach makes it easier for individuals seeking
help to understand what support the center offers and how they can benefit from it.
In terms of Empowerment and Hope, the inclusion of activities such as smudging and the
acknowledgment of cultural practices play a role in empowering clients. These actions show
respect for clients' cultural identities and provide hope by incorporating familiar and meaningful
traditions into the recovery process. This approach is in line with the Empowerment and Hope
127
theme, which focuses on the power of messaging to inspire hope, empowerment, and motivation
throughout the journey to recovery.
Mentioning "36 hours of classes weekly" in the brochure communicates the center's
dedication to education, which is essential for creating an understanding of recovery processes.
This information satisfies the criteria for the Education and Awareness theme by offering a clear
picture of the educational services provided. Highlighting these opportunities shows the center's
commitment to not just recovery but to ensuring clients have the knowledge and resources
necessary for their journey.
The brochure's mention of gender-specific lounges and round-the-clock staff support
creates an environment that supports personal healing. These lounges offer secure areas for
individuals to share and grow, while the availability of staff at all hours provides crucial support
whenever it's needed, fostering an atmosphere conducive to healing and personal transformation.
The brochure's approach to talking about addiction recovery services shows a strong
understanding of what people really need when they start their journey to get better. It mixes
messages of hope with detailed
information about the help available,
respects different cultures, and
suggests ways to build a supportive
community. By addressing the
negative views about recovery, sharing
knowledge on the help out there, and
celebrating everyone's unique cultural
backgrounds in a way that brings
128
people together, the brochure demonstrates how well thought-out design can truly make a
difference. These steps not only make the process of recovery seem more approachable but also
create a base of trust and respect that is crucial for effective support. This analysis points out the
importance of using a broad and welcoming approach when creating tools for communication in
addiction recovery programs. It ensures that these tools really speak to, inspire, and create a
feeling of belonging among those they are meant to help.
Figure 3
This brochure presents a smart mix of ways to talk about and support addiction recovery.
From sharing important resources like suicide prevention to including community practices such
as drum circles, it creates a welcoming, helpful, and respectful space. This approach supports
recovery, builds community connections, and encourages personal development for those
working toward a healthier future.
Access and Awareness are identified as important elements, highlighting the need to
inform potential clients about the services available to them. By listing resources like suicide
prevention, treatment programs, and clinics, the materials directly increase awareness, ensuring
individuals know the help they can get. This aligns with the broader goal of educational
outreach, a crucial part of recovery programs. Including services like G.E.D. classes and
parenting classes underlines the empowerment through knowledge, fitting into the broader theme
of Education and Awareness. These services not only support recovery but also equip clients
with essential skills, enhancing their journey toward healing.
The theme of Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery is vividly represented
through the mention of drum groups, which embody the support structure provided by the
129
community. Cultural activities like music and drum circles create a sense of belonging and
solidarity, crucial for social recovery. Similarly, Healing and Personal Transformation are
reflected in the offerings of counseling and walk-in clinics, integral to the holistic healing
journey. These services support personal transformation and resonate with the theme's focus on
overcoming substance use disorder through transformative processes.
Visual and Design Preferences highlight the importance of aesthetic elements in the
brochures. The strategic use of 'picture' placeholders indicates an intention to include visual
elements, enhancing engagement and comprehension of the provided information. This choice
not only meets the visual inclusion criteria but also shows how aesthetics can impact the
effectiveness of communication tools in addiction recovery programs.
Exploring the co-created artwork within the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness
Center's Collaborative Creation Circles reveals a collection of insights into how communication
tools for addiction recovery could look. Access and Awareness, highlighted by the detailed
listing of resources, shows the need for potential clients to know about the services they can
access. The Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery, shown through cultural activities
like drum groups, illustrate the invaluable support and sense of belonging provided by
community networks. Healing and Personal Transformation, reflected in personalized services,
emphasize the comprehensive journey toward well-being. Lastly, Visual and Design Preferences
in the brochures highlight the importance of visual elements such as images which can make
messages more clear and engaging.
Figure 4
130
Figure 4 presents an engaging and thought-provoking
approach to discussing addiction through the use of bold imagery
and language. The phrase "Are you hooked?" not only draws
attention with its play on words but also encourages readers to
reflect on their own experiences with addiction. This direct and
impactful messaging strategy aims to resonate with community
members, inviting them to consider their relationship with
substances.
The use of the phrase "Are you hooked?" serves as a
direct, compelling call to action. This method aligns with the
Messaging Preferences theme, demonstrating a preference for
straightforward and engaging messaging that sparks reflection
and encourages a personal connection with the material. This approach is designed to resonate
with community members by speaking to their experiences in a language that is both accessible
and impactful.
The image of someone looking upset and tied up with chains powerfully shows the
Challenges and Barriers to Recovery theme. It really puts the spotlight on how hard and complex
the fight against addiction can be. This image tells us a lot about the roadblocks that make it
tough for people to find their way out of addiction. It's a clear call to recovery programs to really
tackle these issues head-on, offering the right kind of help and guidance to break free from these
chains. This part is super important for the discussion because it reminds us that messages of
hope and strength are great, but we also need to be real about the tough stuff people face. By
acknowledging these challenges, the brochure fits well with the study's look into how we can
131
talk about recovery in a way that really gets through to people, showing them that while the
journey might be hard, support and understanding are there to help them through.
The illustration of an individual metaphorically 'hooked' to substances introduces a
complex dialogue about the Stigma and Language theme. While aiming to visualize the struggle
of addiction vividly, there is a risk it could inadvertently support negative stereotypes or stigmas
around addiction. The depiction of a person in distress, bound by their addiction, could be
perceived as reinforcing harmful perceptions, despite the intent to highlight the gravity of
addiction issues. This underscores the importance of careful consideration in the choice of
language and imagery, advocating for a balance between compelling communication and the
promotion of a supportive, stigma-free environment.
The slogan "At NMAWC we practice Catch & Release!" introduces a metaphor that
could intersect with the Empowerment and Hope theme, suggesting a journey of overcoming
addiction with support and compassion. This metaphor implies a treatment philosophy centered
on understanding, support, and the ultimate release from the challenges of addiction, reflecting a
message of hope and positive transformation. Without clear context, this message risks being
misunderstood, highlighting the Misinformation and Accurate Information theme's concern for
ensuring clarity and accuracy in recovery messaging. Effective communication should aim to
eliminate confusion, providing clear guidance on the recovery process.
This visual metaphor also engages with the Communication Channels theme, utilizing an
innovative approach to catch the viewer's attention and initiate conversations about addiction and
recovery. It demonstrates a method of engagement that is both provocative and inviting, seeking
to open doors to dialogue and reflection on personal experiences with addiction.
132
In summary, figure 4 navigates the delicate balance between crafting messages that are
both compelling and respectful, aiming to inspire hope and empowerment while conscientiously
addressing the challenges and barriers individuals face in their journey toward recovery. The use
of straightforward yet sensitive language, coupled with visually striking imagery, serves to
communicate a message of hope and support, emphasizing the potential for transformation and
healing within the context of addiction recovery. Though, this messaging could be misinterpreted
and there is a risk it could inadvertently support negative stereotypes or stigmas around
addiction.
Figure 5
This figure details the deliberate use of cultural symbols and
thoughtful design in the creation of communication tools for
addiction recovery in figure 5, a brochure. Specifically, it highlights
the integration of the Medicine Wheel in Ojibwe communities and
the Serenity Prayer as core elements of the co-design process.
In the process of developing communication tools for
addiction recovery, integrating cultural symbols and design choices
reflects a thoughtful consideration of community needs and values.
A key example of this is the use of the Medicine Wheel on the front
of figure 5a. Its inclusion in recovery communication materials
shows respect for the spiritual, medicinal, and educational components that the communities hold
dear. It aligns with the broader goal of providing care that is relevant to the culture.
133
The visual presentation of the Medicine Wheel acts as a strong channel for messages,
embodying the community's preference for designs that are both meaningful and familiar. This
strategic decision improves the impact of communication by ensuring the imagery resonates with
community members. This approach demonstrates an insightful understanding of how visuals
and symbolism can bridge information sharing and meaningful interaction.
Moreover, the Medicine Wheel symbolizes more than just cultural relevance; it
represents balance, hope, and empowerment. The Wheel's quadrants, which stand for the
physical, emotional, mental, and spiritual aspects of life, provide a comprehensive framework for
understanding the recovery process. This not only empowers individuals on their healing path
but also instills a sense of hope for a balanced and healthy life. Furthermore, the inclusion of the
Medicine Wheel strengthens the community and social aspects of recovery. It highlights the
interconnectedness of life and the support structures essential for healing. This symbol reminds
individuals of the collective wisdom and support within the community, showcasing the shared
experiences and resilience necessary for recovery.
Accurately integrating cultural symbols is not without its challenges. Misinterpretations
of the Medicine Wheel's meanings can lead to misinformation, undermining its importance and
potentially affecting the effectiveness of the recovery messaging. Similarly, written inside of the
brochure is the serenity prayer, shown in figure 5b, often used in recovery programs. This also
needs careful presentation to fully convey its implications for personal growth and recovery.
Correct representation and understanding of these elements are important for maintaining the
messaging's integrity and ensuring it genuinely supports the community.
The theme of Empowerment and Hope is clearly represented by the Serenity Prayer in the
brochure. This prayer is a source of motivation and positivity. It encourages people to accept the
134
things they cannot change and find
the courage to change what they
can. This idea is crucial for
recovery, offering hope and
motivation to face the challenges of
addiction and look forward to the
future.
Healing and Personal
Transformation is another important
theme, highlighted by the Serenity Prayer. The prayer's call for wisdom to know the difference
between what can and cannot be changed speaks to the journey of personal growth and spiritual
development that is central to recovery. It shows that recovery involves not just external changes,
but also internal growth and understanding.
The Cultural Sensitivity and Integration theme is subtly present in the universal appeal of
the Serenity Prayer. This indicates the importance of recovery messages being inclusive and
respectful of spiritual beliefs and practices.
Messaging Preferences are seen in the prayer's straightforward and reflective language,
which aligns with what the community finds impactful. The prayer's popularity in recovery
settings demonstrates its effectiveness, suggesting that inspiring and thoughtful messages can
potentially motivate individuals to engage with recovery resources.
The thoughtful inclusion of the Medicine Wheel and the Serenity Prayer in addiction
recovery communication materials is a clear example of how co-designed artwork can enhance
engagement and support within recovery programs. By closely aligning with themes of Cultural
135
Relevance, Empowerment and Hope, and Healing and Personal Transformation, these design
choices effectively address the community's needs and preferences. This strategy not only
respects and honors the cultural heritage of the community but also serves as a powerful tool for
facilitating personal growth and communal connection. The analysis demonstrates that such
culturally informed and emotionally resonant elements are crucial for the success of
communication tools in addiction recovery settings. Ultimately, this approach underlines the
importance of integrating meaningful symbols and messages into recovery materials.
Figure 6
Figure 6 illustrates a piece incorporating a medicine wheel
and feathers, symbolizing the role of cultural symbols in recovery
messaging, reflecting themes of empowerment, hope, healing, and
the value of community in the journey toward recovery.
In examining the co-designed artwork presented in Figure 6,
which features a medicine wheel with feathers and the acronym
"NMAWC," standing for Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness
Center, shows how important cultural symbols are in the healing
journey alongside short and clear message indicators. The medicine
wheel, as mentioned above, represents completeness and the
ongoing cycle of life and healing. Feathers, often linked to prayers
and spiritual connections, enhance this imagery, forming visual metaphor for protection and
healing. This combination of cultural symbols aligns with the community's preferences for visual
design and also connects with beliefs and traditions, making the messages more impactful. The
136
inclusion of the acronym "NMAWC" in the artwork suggests a preference for concise yet
meaningful communication, hinting at an effective strategy to engage the audience's interest in
recovery materials without explicitly mentioning addiction or recovery. This choice shows the
power of subtle cues to spark curiosity and encourage deeper exploration of the content.
The brochures' artwork themes of Empowerment and Hope, and Healing and Personal
Transformation, are important along an individual's path to recovery. By including symbols that
suggest protection and the encouragement of healing, the artwork sends a message of optimism
and spiritual well-being. It emphasizes the potential for personal growth and the holistic nature
of the healing journey, in line with the community's values and creating a supportive
environment for recovery.
Additionally, the portrayal of the Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery in the
artwork highlights the concept that healing is a communal journey with the broader community
and the natural world. This perspective is particularly meaningful in Ojibwe culture, which sees
recovery as a collective effort.
Figure 6 shows that such artworks not only communicate the importance of cultural and
social dimensions in recovery but also align with preferred messaging themes like
empowerment, hope, and the significance of community and cultural identity. These are
important in developing effective communication tools for addiction recovery, highlighting the
connection between individual and collective healing processes and the cultural foundations
supporting them.
Figure 7
137
In the brochure, figure 7, the participant incorporates individuals from diverse
backgrounds through the inclusion of multiple languages. The directive "GET HELP," paired
with the calming imagery of nature, invites individuals to take the first step toward healing,
invoking a sense of possibility and a peaceful life ahead.
In focusing on recovery messaging figure 7a shows
cultural sensitivity is a key factor. By greeting members in their
own languages, like using "Aaniin" from the Ojibwe language, the
participant shows a strong respect for everyone’s cultural
background, linking closely to the themes of Cultural Relevance
and Cultural Foundations in Recovery. Placing this on the front of
the brochure, this method shows recognition and celebrates the
varied backgrounds of community members, making the recovery
environment more inclusive and welcoming.
Motivation and empowerment are also central themes.
Presenting the word "Sobriety" alongside greetings in different languages acts as a powerful
motivation, reflecting the themes of Empowerment and Hope, and Healing and Personal
Transformation. It sends a strong message that recovery is achievable, backed by a community
that values and understands everyone's unique stories.
Effective communication plays a crucial role in connecting the program with its audience,
highlighting the importance of the Communication Channels theme. By using multiple
languages, the program greatly increases accessibility, ensuring that messages about recovery are
understood by everyone, regardless of their cultural background. This strategy might work for
spreading recovery messages effectively, reaching people wherever they are on their journey.
138
The use of visual design, featuring bright colors and welcome messages in multiple
languages, aligns with the Visual and Design Preferences theme. This approach aims to create a
space that feels open and inviting to all, making a positive and inclusive first impression of the
recovery program.
Lastly for figure 7a, the importance of community and social support in recovery is
clearly shown in the materials, reflecting the Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery
theme. It affirms the idea that recovery is a community effort, supported by connections with
others who have faced similar experiences and challenges. This part of the recovery program
emphasizes the importance of having a supportive and understanding community to help through
the healing process.
The inside of the brochure,
figure 7b, shows the directive "GET
HELP" alongside serene natural visuals,
extending an invitation for individuals to
begin their journey of healing, offering a
vision of hope and tranquility. This
method demonstrates an understanding
of the community's messaging
preferences, which favor clear, compelling calls to action that simultaneously recognize the
challenges of the recovery journey.
Images of a tranquil river and a solitary tree appeal to a universal desire for calm,
mirroring the community's liking for visuals that comfort and motivate. These choices align with
broader healing and personal transformation themes, suggesting a move from hardship toward a
139
serene and balanced state. The phrase "Calm your destructive nature" adds depth to this
narrative, encouraging self-reflection and the potential for a more peaceful life.
The use of phrases such as "destructive nature" shifts attention to the theme of stigma and
language, presenting a critical area for consideration in the messaging process. It brings to light
the importance of language in shaping perceptions and emphasizes the need for careful language
use to avoid perpetuating negative stereotypes or stigma associated with addiction. This aspect of
the brochure indicates the ongoing effort required to craft messages that are straightforward yet
mindful of the intricacies of individual experiences, highlighting an awareness of the importance
of sensitive communication within the recovery conversation.
In conclusion, the brochure stands as a comprehensive effort to communicate recovery
messages, skillfully integrating elements of cultural sensitivity, empowerment, effective
communication, visual appeal, and community support. Through the inclusion of multiple
languages and recognition of diverse cultural backgrounds, it not only respects but also
celebrates the variety of identities within the community, directly engaging with the themes of
Cultural Relevance and Cultural Foundations in Recovery. The design of the brochure, with its
inviting colors and greetings in multiple languages, aims to create a welcoming atmosphere for
all, making a positive initial impression that aligns with Visual and Design Preferences.
Moreover, the emphasis on community and social support, as depicted through the materials,
underlines recovery as a collective journey, reinforcing the Community and Social Dimensions
of Recovery theme. The interior of the brochure, with its serene natural imagery and
thought-provoking messaging, though effective in inspiring peace and possibility, brings to
attention the careful consideration needed in language use to prevent reinforcing negative
140
stereotypes associated with addiction, indicating an ongoing effort to craft messages that are
clear yet considerate of individual experiences.
Figure 8
The brochure’s front, figure 8a, integrates visual design
and messaging, aiming to connect with its intended audience.
This piece creates a conversation between despair and hope,
addressing the intense feelings of hopelessness often
accompanying addiction. By asking "Feel hopeless? Like life
will never change?" it confronts the viewer with their current
lifestyle, offering a message of hope and empowerment through
the statement "We could help fix that." This shift from
recognition to offering a solution embodies a key theme in
recovery messaging — the belief in the possibility of change
and empowering individuals to seek support and engage with
recovery resources.
The choices made in design and messaging reflect a deliberate awareness of the target
audience's preferences, using direct and empathetic communication. This approach recognizes
the struggles faced by those dealing with addiction and immediately presents an opportunity of
hope. It aligns with the identified themes of effective recovery program messaging, which stress
positive framing and the potential for a brighter, more positive future.
The inclusion of the Medicine Wheel adds a layer of meaning to the brochure's visual and
thematic composition. It highlights the cultural relevance of the content and acts as a visual
141
affirmation of the center's dedication to incorporating cultural and spiritual elements into their
recovery approach. This decision reflects a broader preference for imagery that conveys cultural
themes and values, highlighting the importance of cultural elements in making the message
resonate more effectively with the Ojibwe community. The use of the Medicine Wheel, beyond
its cultural significance, subtly introduces the theme of community and social recovery. It
implies that the path to wellness includes community support and holistic well-being. This aspect
of the design hints at the participants perspective on healing, acknowledging the crucial role of
community and the social dimensions of recovery.
Analyzing the interior content of Figure
8b, empowerment and hope are conveyed
through the promotion of a positive
environment and the support of trustworthy
peers. This approach empowers individuals,
providing a solid foundation of encouragement
that nurtures the belief in a feasible path to
recovery. The brochure communicates this by
detailing the supportive atmosphere and peer
relationships available at the center, which
create a sense of belonging and motivation
among participants.
Cultural relevance is addressed by highlighting Native American cultural practices,
affirming the center's dedication to integrating these essential cultural elements into its recovery
programming. This emphasis honors the significance of cultural identity in the healing process
142
and aligns with a broader understanding of how cultural practices can support recovery,
particularly within Ojibwe communities. By mentioning these practices, the brochure signals the
center's respect for and commitment to culturally informed care.
Though the inside of the brochure lacks visual elements, the textual mention of "good
vibes" suggests an atmosphere that is emotionally supportive and visually appealing, aligning
with preferences for aesthetics and atmosphere in effective messaging. This subtle nod to a
positive environment speaks to the broader impact of a welcoming and supportive setting on an
individual's recovery journey.
Although the inside of the brochure lacks visual elements, the text mentioning "good
vibes" suggests an environment that is emotionally supportive and visually appealing, aligning
with preferences for an inviting and supportive atmosphere. This indirect reference to a positive
setting reflects the impact of a welcoming environment on an individual's journey to recovery.
Education and awareness are expanded upon through details of services such as
one-on-one counseling and focus groups. This educates potential clients about support options
and shows the center's comprehensive approach to recovery, highlighting personalized and group
learning opportunities tailored to meet diverse needs.
The brochure places emphasis on community and social recovery through mentions of
group sessions and the role of trustworthy peers. This approach highlights the importance of
social support networks and community in the healing process, suggesting a comprehensive
strategy that recognizes the therapeutic element of collective support and shared experiences.
Finally, the brochure touches on the theme of healing and personal transformation
through listings of services like medication management and one-on-one counseling. These
143
services indicate a customized approach to recovery, focusing on the individual needs of clients
and supporting them through their unique journeys of healing and transformation.
In summary, the brochure from Figure 8 is a carefully designed communication piece that
embodies the core principles of healing and personal transformation at the heart of the recovery
process. It directly speaks to those navigating recovery, offering messages of hope and the
promise of a transformative journey. Through its strategic use of language, cultural symbols, and
visual design, it demonstrates an understanding of the audience's needs and the power of
thoughtfully crafted messaging to motivate action and inspire hope
Figure 9
The brochure artwork in figure 9 shows a bear and
a peace pipe against a background of warm colors, carries
cultural and spiritual meaning for Ojibwe peoples. The
participants’ work embodies themes of healing,
empowerment, and cultural identity.
The bear symbolizes strength, courage, and
leadership, while the peace pipe is used in spiritual
ceremonies, indicating a sacred connection. These symbols
reflect the community's cultural values and the integration
of traditional practices in recovery, aligning with themes of
Cultural Relevance and Cultural Sensitivity Integration.
Their presence in the artwork indicates the participants perspective on the center's commitment
144
to a culturally respectful recovery environment, essential for individuals’ healing and
transformation.
The design's visual and aesthetic choices—using familiar imagery, vibrant colors, and
natural scenes—appeal directly to community preferences. This approach enhances the
message's impact, creating a sense of belonging and identity. The inclusion of a "Welcome" sign
conveys a positive, inclusive atmosphere, resonating with themes of Messaging Preferences and
advocating for inclusive and empowering messages in the recovery process.
Furthermore, the peace pipe symbolizes hope and the potential for healing, representing
the theme of Empowerment and Hope. This element, signifying peace and renewal,
communicates the center's supportive approach to individuals' recovery journeys. Used as a
visual in communication materials, it brings warmth, invitation, and the importance of
community support as highlighted in the Community and Social Recovery theme.
This piece's narrative, with its cultural and community-centric themes, outlines a
comprehensive approach to recovery messaging, acknowledging the complexity of addiction
recovery where cultural identity, empowerment, and community support play crucial roles. The
co-designed material delivers a strong message of hope, unity, and strength, important to
members' healing and personal growth.
Figure 10
This flyer demonstrates the impact of visual and verbal storytelling in tackling essential
themes in recovery, such as addressing stigma through language, promoting healing, and
encouraging personal change.
145
The front of the flyer, figure 10a, shows
individually styled letters of "Ombe Oma" which
means “we rise here” symbolize both the diversity
within the recovery community and the shared
journey toward wellness. The use of simple,
nature-inspired symbols like flowers and hearts
ties back to healing, suggesting a universal
language of love and connection to the
environment, making the messages relatable and
emotionally resonant for others on similar paths.
Integrating Woodlands art, with its
traditional floral patterns, speaks to the importance of cultural identity in healing and personal
growth. This choice honors the Ojibwe community's heritage, pointing to the role of cultural
connections and spirituality in recovery. By including these symbols, the participant asserts their
identities and shows the importance of the support provided by cultural ties during the recovery
process.
The phrase "To Our Healing Community" directly addresses the stigma surrounding
addiction, highlighting the role of supportive language and collective experiences in the healing
process. Together with the contact details, it positions recovery as a group effort, nurtured by
empathy and community connections. This focus on community shows the importance of social
support in recovery, illustrating how outreach and the development of supportive networks are
important to the healing process.
146
Moving to the back of the flyer, figure 10b, emphasizes messaging that is both
empowering and supportive. The language chosen resonates with an uplifting and
forward-looking perspective, focusing on long-lasting wellness with phrases like "Get Well FOR
LIFE" and advocating for personal progress with "Move Up in life and Stop Running." This
alignment with a positive and motivating communication style speaks directly to preferences for
messages that inspire and uplift.
The phrases "Move Up in life and Stop
Running" and "CHEERING YOU ON FOR A
BETTER YOU!" embody the theme of
Empowerment and Hope, offering encouragement
and highlighting the potential for positive
transformation. Such statements are designed to
motivate, stressing the belief in each individual's
capacity for change and growth.
In addressing the theme of Community
Narratives, the phrase "Belong to a strong
Community" shows the critical role of communal
bonds in the healing journey. This message reinforces the idea that being part of a supportive
group is not only beneficial but essential for recovery, emphasizing the strength and support
derived from shared experiences.
The emphasis on Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery is further enhanced by
the benefit of belonging to a supportive community. This underscores the importance of social
147
networks and communal involvement in the recovery process, suggesting that healing is deeply
interconnected with being part of a collective that offers support and understanding.
The challenge of moving beyond past behaviors and confronting personal issues is
captured in the phrase "Move Up in life and Stop Running." This reflects the Challenges and
Barriers to Recovery theme focused on overcoming the obstacles that hinder recovery,
acknowledging the need to face and address these challenges directly as part of the healing
process.
Lastly, the call to "Save Yourself with us CHEERING YOU ON FOR A BETTER
YOU!" speaks to Healing and Personal Transformation, inviting participants to engage actively
in their recovery. Supported by a community that cheers them on, this message highlights the
journey of personal growth and the transformative power of taking responsibility for one's
healing. It affirms the belief in the possibility of a better future, facilitated by both personal
commitment and communal support.
By integrating themes of stigma, healing, empowerment, community support, and
personal change, these materials show the importance of specialized visual and narrative
communication on individuals in recovery. This analysis highlights the need for positive and
supportive messaging to aid healing and growth and shows the creative expression's
transformative messaging of hope and resilience.
Figure 11
This flyer, figure 11, is a reflection of personal and communal paths toward healing, and
is a lens through which to examine broader themes of recovery communication, including
stigma, language, healing, and personal change.
148
The language within the flyer,
utilizing motivational phrases like "beat
statistics" and "lead by example," directly
communicates a sense of resilience and
determination. This linguistic choice aligns
with a strategic preference for uplifting
messages, emphasizing the achievability of
recovery and the importance of setting
positive examples.
The theme of community emerges, with references to collective hopes for "our children"
and "future generations." This shows the importance of shared experiences and the communal
aspect of healing, suggesting that recovery is deeply connected with community life and our
shared hopes for the future.
The use of the Ojibwe term "Mino Bimaadiziwin," which means "the good life," aligns
with the theme of cultural relevance, and how important cultural values are. It connects the idea
of getting better to respecting cultural traditions and identity. The flyer is about giving people
hope and the belief that they can make positive changes together. It says, "The time is NOW!" to
encourage action and support from everyone.
Moreover, the flyer acknowledges how hard the fight against addiction can be through
the use of the phrase, "the horrors of addiction" but emphasizes that recovery is achievable,
especially with the support of the community “Let’s lift one another up so future generations
don't get wiped out - choose recovery.” This balance shows an understanding that while
acknowledging the problem is important, focusing on solutions and support.
149
In summarizing the flyer from Figure 11, it shows the journey of recovery, combining
themes of motivation, community, and cultural identity. This flyer balances recognizing the
challenges of addiction with a hopeful message of collective support. It presents recovery as a
personal endeavor and a shared objective. As an example of recovery communication, this flyer
demonstrates how combining personal stories with a broader message of healing and mutual
support can resonate strongly with individuals and communities engaged in the process of
recovery.
Figure 12
The flyer, figure 12, makes strategic
use of words such as "Honesty," "Hope," and
"Wisdom," highlighting a preference for
messages that are optimistic and grounded in
core values. This choice resonates with the
broader goal of framing recovery in a
positive light, ensuring the communication
emphasizes forward-looking and
value-driven narratives.
The display of the word "Hope" on the flyer shows an emphasis on looking toward a
brighter future, a key motivator and source of strength for those in the recovery process. This
messaging is vital as it creates a sense of possibility and empowerment among individuals,
suggesting that change for the better is within reach.
150
Moreover, the inclusion of "Wisdom" hints at the integration of culturally significant
teachings and practices into the recovery program, signifying the importance of cultural
sensitivity and relevance in the messaging. This aspect suggests a recognition of the cultural
practices that can support individuals through their recovery.
Descriptions of activities like "NA/AA, Spiritual groups, Walks, Fun, Laughter" play a
role in illustrating the community and shared experiences central to the recovery journey. These
elements point to a collective narrative of recovery, emphasizing the importance of building a
supportive community environment.
The flyer also mentions "Amazing staff" and engaging activities, highlighting the role of
a supportive community and social network in the recovery process. This aspect shows an
understanding that recovery is influenced by positive social interactions and a nurturing
environment.
Visually, the flyer centers the name "NMAWC" in large, bold letters, surrounded by
supportive words in a handwritten style, creating a welcoming and inclusive atmosphere. The
design choices reflect a preference for simplicity and a personal touch, making the message
accessible and engaging.
The phrase "Future - it gets better every day" captures the essence of healing and personal
transformation, conveying a message of gradual improvement and growth. This statement is a
reminder of the ongoing nature of the recovery journey, emphasizing progress and personal
development.
The flyer educates potential clients about the values and support available at the center, as
indicated by the words around the acronym NMAWC. This approach helps in creating a more
151
informed understanding of the services and support system offered, contributing to broader
education and awareness efforts.
The flyer shown in Figure 12 is an example of how careful choice of words, a focus on
community, and appealing design can make a difference in recovery messaging. It shows that
using positive words, considering cultural values, and having an attractive design can offer a
supportive way to communicate about recovery. This review points out how important it is to
create materials that give information and connect with people’s feelings. It shows an
understanding of the recovery journey and how important it is to maintain community ties.
Figure 13
This flyer highlights the wellness centers
services and community-focused approach to
addiction recovery. It uses key themes of hope,
support, and healing to engage and inspire individuals
on their journey to recovery.
Figure 13 starts with a bold statement,
identifying itself as "MN's #1 Treatment Center,"
accompanied by attributes like "GOOD FOOD" and
"FRIENDSHIP." These positive statements reflect
pride in the services offered and are intended to
resonate with the community. The participant emphasizes the center's dedication to quality and
creates a welcoming narrative that encourages community engagement.
152
Words such as "HOPE" and "OVERCOME" prominently feature in the flyer, conveying
messages of resilience and the possibility of overcoming addiction. These terms are important in
inspiring individuals who are considering starting or are in the midst of their recovery journey,
acting as reminders of the achievable nature of recovery.
References to "FRIENDSHIP," "GROUPS," and "AWESOME PEOPLE" highlight the
importance of social support and peer networks, illustrating that recovery is a journey shared
with others. This focus on communal experiences and mutual support showcases the importance
of connections in the healing process.
By detailing features and services like "GOOD FOOD," "SPIRITUALITY," and
"SOBRIETY," the flyer educates potential clients about what to expect, enhancing awareness of
the center's offerings and setting clear expectations for the recovery experience.
The design of the flyer, with its straightforward layout and use of purple for emphasis,
along with casual mentions like "NETFLIX," tries to engage its audience in a relatable manner.
These design choices reflect a careful consideration of how to connect with viewers, creating an
atmosphere of warmth and familiarity.
Although the flyer doesn't directly mention specific cultural elements, the inclusion of
"SPIRITUALITY" suggests a recovery approach that values a variety of spiritual and cultural
practices. This indicates an appreciation for the comprehensive nature of healing, recognizing the
role of spiritual health.
Mentions of "NA/AA" and "GROUPS" underline the role of community and social
networks in the recovery process. This part of the flyer points to the belief in the power of group
efforts and the importance of support groups in aiding recovery, reinforcing the idea that healing
is supported by community involvement.
153
By using the term "OVERCOME ADDICTION," the flyer acknowledges the challenges
within the recovery process, portraying the center as a supportive environment where these
challenges can be faced. This presentation is both realistic and optimistic, offering
encouragement to those on the recovery path. The flyer concludes with the goal of
"SOBRIETY," symbolizing personal evolution and healing. This focus on sobriety highlights the
essence of the recovery journey, marking an important step toward personal betterment.
Through strategic design and carefully chosen wording, this flyer sets a tone of optimism
and support, stressing the importance of community, spirituality, and comprehensive care in the
recovery process. It ends by emphasizing the goal of becoming sober, showing the healing and
supportive journey the center offers. Figure 13 embodies the community narratives,
empowerment, and hope themes, illustrating how positively framed messaging can motivate
engagement with recovery resources.
Figure 14
This flyer, figure 14, stands as a
reflection of the participants' journeys,
communicating themes of overcoming stigma,
healing, and personal transformation through
visual and textual storytelling.
Focusing on education and awareness,
the flyer thoughtfully details the available
treatment options, differentiating between short-term (45-60 days) and long-term (60-90 days)
programs. This distinction not only provides clear information but also highlights the structured
154
support offered by the center, catering to various needs in the recovery journey. By introducing
the concept of dual diagnostic treatment, the flyer acknowledges the multifaceted nature of
addiction, suggesting a comprehensive approach that addresses both substance use and
co-occurring mental health disorders. This choice reflects an understanding of the complexities
involved in recovery, indicating a commitment to holistic care.
The flyer also touches on the challenges and barriers to recovery, subtly addressing the
issue of dual diagnosis. This inclusion signals an awareness of the intricate hurdles many face on
their path to recovery, emphasizing the center's readiness to tackle these multifaceted challenges.
By doing so, it reassures individuals that their journey is supported by an informed and
compassionate approach.
Community and social dimensions of recovery are highlighted through the emphasis on
learning skills to manage codependency and navigate peer pressure. This focus points to the
importance of building healthy relationships and fostering resilience, underscoring the role of
community in the recovery process. The mention of "recovering addicts/alcoholic counselors"
within the program staff suggests a powerful model of peer support, reinforcing the message that
recovery is a shared journey, enriched by mutual understanding and shared experiences.
Visually, the flyer’s design preferences suggest an appreciation for clarity and
accessibility. Even though this is inferred from text, the structured presentation implies a
thoughtful consideration of how information is received, prioritizing ease of understanding to
ensure that the message is effectively communicated to its intended audience.
The cultural relevance hinted at by the flyer's nod to serving the surrounding areas
reflects an intent to connect with the community on a deeper level, potentially incorporating
155
elements that resonate with local values and experiences. Although more explicit details would
clarify this point, the mention suggests a forward-thinking approach to culturally informed care.
The inclusion of misinformation and accurate information, indicated by the facility's
description as "MA approved," assures the audience of the center's credibility and the
evidence-based nature of its treatments. This reassurance is crucial in a field where trust and
factual accuracy form the cornerstone of effective communication and therapy.
In conclusion, this flyer reflects a broad spectrum of recovery narratives, offering insights
into the center's approach to treatment, community involvement, and the importance of
empowerment and hope to participants. Through its design and content, it presents a view into
the healing journey, advocating for a recovery path marked by understanding, support, and
personal growth. This examination highlights the key themes in the participants' creation but also
points to the potential of such materials to shape future communication strategies within
recovery programs.
Figure 15
In the analysis of Figure 15, presented in the
context of addiction recovery, the artwork integrates
symbols rooted in cultural significance with elements that
visually articulate themes of healing, empowerment, and
community interconnectedness.
The medicine wheel, representing life's circle and
the balance between physical, mental, emotional, and
spiritual health, holds particular resonance within the
156
context of addiction recovery. Its relevance is heightened for the Ojibwe community, connecting
to the broader theme of cultural identity and the healing journey. This symbol's inclusion in the
flyer shows an appreciation for cultural heritage and its role in the recovery process. The phrase
"WALK THE RED ROAD" serves as a call to live a balanced, correct life, mirroring the journey
of recovery in Ojibwe communities. It embodies hope and encouragement for individuals to
pursue a life aligned with positive spiritual values.
The artwork features a hand reaching toward the medicine wheel, symbolizing a journey
toward balance, wellness, and a comprehensive approach to recovery. The drawing's simplicity,
combined with the impactful use of red and black, suggests a preference for meaningful,
symbolic imagery that communicates cultural themes without overwhelming complexity. This
gesture of reaching upward introduces an element of hope and aspiration, illustrating an
empowered path toward recovery. It resonates with themes of empowerment and hope,
portraying recovery as an attainable goal marked by personal growth and transformation.
The red handprint is also a symbol associated with the MMIW movement, and adds a
layer of social commentary to the artwork, addressing the silenced voices of Indigenous women
affected by violence. This inclusion connects deeply with community narratives and the
challenges faced in recovery, linking personal healing journeys to broader societal struggles and
the fight for justice within Indigenous communities.
The color scheme, particularly the use of red, not only signifies strength and vitality but
also calls attention to the MMIW issue, representing the blood of those lost. This choice
confronts the stigma surrounding violence against Indigenous women, urging a communal effort
toward awareness and change.
157
Incorporating the acronym MMIW directly addresses the social and systemic issues
affecting the Ojibwe and other Indigenous communities, emphasizing the external challenges
that can influence the recovery process. The mention of NMAWC (Northern Minnesota
Addiction Wellness Center) situates the artwork within a specific context, highlighting the
center's role as a space for recovery and awareness.
The term "Skoden" is a slang way of saying "let's go then," showing readiness and a push
to move forward together. It's like a rallying cry that brings people together, encouraging them to
join in a shared journey of getting better and finding hope. Skoden is motivating and inspiring
others to take action and believe in a better future.
The artwork in Figure 15 offers a compelling visual narrative that elevates the
conversation around addiction recovery. Through the strategic use of culturally significant
symbols like the medicine wheel and the red handprint, along with impactful phrases, it
highlights the journey of healing and empowerment. The design's simplicity and symbolic depth
create a direct connection with viewers, promoting a collective pursuit of healing, awareness, and
justice. This artwork strongly supports the idea of working together on personal healing and
strengthening the community. It invites people to take action and shows how pictures and
symbols can help us tackle tough problems.
Figure 16
This flyer frames the recovery journey positively, incorporating a design that symbolizes
renewal and emotional transformation while subtly nodding to the cultural significance of water
in Ojibwe tradition.
158
Figure 16, which features the phrase "GETTING
WELL" alongside "TREATMENT" and the wellness center's
name, "NMAWC," we see a clear intention to frame the
recovery journey positively. Messaging preferences show the
emphasis on a forward-moving path to wellness, avoiding
the pitfalls of focusing solely on the struggle. Such a positive
framing is important to a supportive atmosphere for
individuals in recovery.
The design choices in this flyer are notably
straightforward, favoring a clean and uncluttered visual approach. The use of raindrops might
symbolize renewal, cleansing, or the emotional spectrum associated with recovery—ranging
from tears of sorrow to those of joy.
Although the flyer does not explicitly feature Ojibwe language or symbols, the implicit
reference to water through rain imagery taps into water as a source of life and healing within
Ojibwe culture. This subtle nod to cultural relevance may reflect the artist's intent to integrate
culturally meaningful symbols into the narrative of recovery.
Furthermore, the depiction of rain originating from the word "WELL" visually conveys
hope and empowerment, integral themes in the journey toward recovery. This metaphorical
representation emphasizes the nourishment and motivation derived from the concept of wellness,
mirroring the empowerment and hope identified as crucial in the codebook for engaging and
supporting individuals in their recovery process.
By focusing on positive messaging and the concept of moving forward toward wellness,
figure 16 creates a supportive atmosphere that is supportive for individuals in recovery. This
159
artistic choice, along with the visualization of hope and empowerment stemming from the
concept of wellness, aligns with key themes of renewal and support.
Figure 17
This flyer represents simple design and
recovery messaging, focusing on how its direct,
clear communication style and visual elements like
contrasting colors and bold text are designed to
engage and empower individuals on their recovery
journey.
Figure 17a depicts the front of the flyer, the text is characterized by its
straightforwardness and bold presentation, indicating a preference for clear, direct
communication. This approach ensures the message is accessible and impactful, aligning with
recovery program goals of straightforward and effective communication. The choice to present
the message in such a manner simplifies complex ideas into understandable and relatable
content for the audience, making it more likely to resonate with individuals on their recovery
journey. The directness of the text, reflects a preference for clear, unambiguous messaging,
essential for effective communication within recovery programs
Visually, the flyer utilizes contrasting colors, possibly red and black, to create a visual
impact that draws attention. This design choice makes the message more noticeable and
symbolizes resilience and the recovery process's intensity. The dual-layered color scheme
suggests a complex nature of recovery.
160
The bold, capitalized lettering conveys strength and assertiveness, aligning with themes
of empowerment and hope. This design choice communicates a strong foundation of support
provided by the center to individuals in recovery, portraying an image of reliability and strength.
On the back, figure 17b, the term "clean" is
used to talk about not using drugs or alcohol and
highlights how important words are in the process of
getting better. It suggests a difference that might
unintentionally reflect how society views people,
showing how choosing certain words in talking about
recovery can really shape how people see themselves
and how others see them too. Therefore, this could lead to the stigmatization of self.
The artwork sends a message about healing, making big changes, and the chance to start
over, focusing on being hopeful and supportive for those working to move past addiction. By
pairing "new" with "clean," it encourages leaving the past behind and looking forward to a fresh
start.
Choosing a handwritten style for the text gives it a personal feel, underlining themes of
change and starting anew. Although the phrase "clean new life" aims to challenge negative views
or stereotypes, it also supports the idea of people in recovery as changed and refreshed.
Through its thoughtfully chosen words and visuals, Figure 17 illustrates the complex
journey of recovery, emphasizing empowerment, renewal, and hope. It portrays how effective
communication, grounded in clarity and directness, can influence individuals' perspectives on
recovery and societal views on addiction.
161
Figure 18
In the analysis of Figure 18, the flyer
introduces elements that highlight cultural heritage,
empowerment, and the journey toward healing within
the recovery process. It integrates symbols and
messages that directly appeal to and respect the
cultural backgrounds and personal experiences of
individuals undergoing recovery.
The inclusion of the medicine wheel symbol aligns with the theme of cultural relevance,
resonating with Ojibwe beliefs and practices. This symbol, representing the interconnectedness
of life, the cycles of nature, and pathways to health and healing, anchors the flyer in a context
that values the integration of cultural traditions and wisdom in the recovery journey. It signifies a
holistic approach to recovery messaging, acknowledging the importance of balancing physical,
mental, emotional, and spiritual health.
The phrase "Recovery Is Possible" is a declaration of empowerment and hope. This
message is empowering, reinforcing the belief in positive change and the potential for healing. It
aligns with the identified preferences for recovery messaging that creates optimism and
confidence in the possibility of recovery, important for motivating individuals to engage with and
persevere through the recovery process. With this phrase the flyer challenges the stigma
surrounding addiction. It promotes a supportive, non-judgmental approach to recovery,
highlighting the success and feasibility of overcoming addiction.
The visual presentation of the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center's acronym
"NMAWC" in bold and large letters immediately draws attention, underlining the supportive
162
environment offered by the center. The use of black and white contrast throughout the design
adds visual impact and may also symbolize the clarity and focus of the recovery message being
conveyed. This design choice aligns with visual and design preferences that prioritize clear,
impactful, and meaningful communication.
Additionally, the use of a feather alongside the medicine wheel introduces another layer
of cultural significance. Feathers are often associated with attributes such as trust, honor,
strength, wisdom, power, and freedom—all of which are important in the context of recovery.
The medicine wheel's presence directly correlates with the theme of healing and personal
transformation.
Together, these elements in Figure 18 show a narrative that is both culturally grounded
and universally hopeful. It provides a message of healing, empowerment, and the possibility of
transformation. This flyer highlights the participants' perspective on the center in supporting
individuals through their recovery with respect for their cultural backgrounds and personal paths
to healing.
Figure 19
This flyer, figure 19, presents a compelling
visual narrative that seamlessly blends cultural
symbols with a message of healing and community
engagement in the context of recovery. This flyer's
design and content reflect the cultural backgrounds
and healing journeys of individuals engaging with
the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center.
163
The main feature of this flyer is a circle that includes the name "Northern Minnesota
Addiction Wellness Center" drawing inspiration from Ojibwe cultural symbols such as the flint
stone fire and drum. This circular motif mirrors beliefs in life's cyclical nature and the pursuit of
balance and harmony. The phrase "Centered on Recovery," located at the circle's edge, highlights
the participants' perspective of the wellness center's dedication to promoting healing within a
cultural framework. The flyer also mentions "Flint Stone Fire," referencing traditional
fire-making practices and their role in ceremonies and gatherings aimed at community healing.
"Centered on Recovery" highlights the center's focus on healing as its core mission,
expressing a commitment to guiding individuals through their recovery with hope and
determination. The fire symbol, signifying change and renewal, complements this by suggesting
a journey of purification and growth. Moreover, the circular design underlines the importance of
community and collective effort in the recovery process, promoting a sense of shared support and
resilience. The design's simplicity, characterized by its clear and efficient use of space, aligns
with preferences for visual communications that are direct and uncomplicated. The circular focus
supports Ojibwe values of symbols representing wholeness and life's cycles.
Figure 19 shows how combining cultural symbols with clear messages can help in talking
about recovery. The flyer uses designs inspired by Ojibwe culture to connect with its audience,
showing the importance of including cultural traditions in messages about recovery. This makes
the message meaningful, helping people feel supported and understood on their journey to
recovery.
164
Figure 20
Figure 20 presents a lively and engaging visualization
of recovery, mixing hope, cultural depth, and encouraging
messaging to motivate individuals toward wellness. Through
its use of exclamations, references to cultural heritage, and
positive imagery, this artwork paints recovery as a journey
filled with joy, potential, and strong cultural connections.
The artwork's lively shouts, "Holay!!!," act as an
enthusiastic affirmation of life’s brighter possibilities. Paired
with questions aimed at the future "Want happiness? Want a
better life? Want serenity? Want to live again?," it crafts a narrative of optimism and opportunity.
This method prompts individuals to consider a future filled with contentment and peace. It also
aligns with themes of encouragement and empowerment, suggesting that the path to recovery is
full with positive outcomes.
At the center of the flyer is a special phrase, "Mino Bimaadiziwin," which means living a
good life. This idea is really important in Ojibwe culture and talks about looking at health and
happiness in a big-picture way. The flyer uses this idea to show how getting better from
addiction is tied to who you are and where you come from, mixing personal healing with cultural
traditions.
It lists values like "Honesty, Integrity, Humility" next to words like "Med Management,
Spirituality, Recovery," which shows what the community thinks is important to the recovery
process. These points highlight key parts of getting better, like growing as a person, finding
165
spiritual peace, and looking after your health in a balanced way. The flyer uses these messages to
encourage and support people on their path to feeling better.
There's a big, smiling sun in the center that looks warm and hopeful. Its bright and simple
style, plus the handwritten notes, make the flyer feel friendly and real, making the message
resonate for people with similar values. This kind of personal touch helps make the message
stand out as sincere and direct.
Also, by asking questions such as "Want a better life?" the flyer encourages people to
think about the possibilities of a brighter future. It shifts the focus from the struggles to the
positive sides of getting better, offering hope and the promise of a happier life ahead. This
change is key for helping people see getting better as a chance for a better, more joyful life.
In conclusion, Figure 20 is an animated celebration of the journey to recovery, illustrating
through its vibrant tone, cultural references, and hopeful imagery, an invitation to individuals to
envisage a future marked by joy, health, and cultural connection. This artwork serves as a
powerful message of optimism, showing that recovery is attainable.
Collaborative Creation Circles Conclusion
The analysis of the Collaborative Creation Circles reveals that incorporating cultural
sensitivity and community engagement is crucial in creating effective communication tools for
addiction recovery within Ojibwe populations. Through the detailed examination of brochures
and flyers developed for the Northern Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center, reflected across
figures 1a to 20, the importance of blending cultural symbols, community input, and co-design
methodologies emerges as a central theme in facilitating a healing journey that honors cultural
identity and meets individual needs.
166
Incorporating Ojibwe cultural symbols such as the medicine wheel, feathers, and Ojibwe
phrases such as "Gaanawaanindiwug" ("Take Care of Each Other") in the recovery materials
demonstrates respect for and the recognition of the cultural heritage and spiritual practices of the
community. These symbols are essential elements in supporting the themes of healing,
community support, and cultural identity. Their presence in recovery materials could reinforce
the importance of cultural identity as a source of resilience and strength in the recovery process.
Insights from community members and stakeholders through interviews and collaborative
circles stress the importance of collaborative efforts in creating materials that resonate on both
personal and community levels. The preference for messaging that promotes positivity,
empowerment, and hope highlights a collective desire for narratives that inspire and motivate,
moving away from fear-based approaches historically associated with substance use disorder
The analysis of visual and design preferences reveals an appreciation for simplicity,
clarity, and nature-inspired imagery, reflecting the values and aesthetic preferences of the Ojibwe
community. By using visuals drawn from nature and a simple design approach, the materials
transcend their informational purpose, becoming a means of cultural expression and connection.
The emphasis on providing accurate information about addiction recovery services and
the expressed need for increased education and awareness show a key objective: empowering
individuals with the knowledge and resources necessary for recovery. Highlighting culturally
tailored programming and comprehensive service overviews emphasizes the necessity of
accessible and inclusive recovery services.
A recurring theme across the Collaborative Creation Circles is the challenge of
addressing the stigma associated with addiction. By carefully selecting language and imagery,
the brochure aims to counteract stigma, creating a narrative of compassion, understanding, and
167
mutual support. This approach serves immediate needs of those seeking recovery and aims to
contribute to a broader cultural shift toward more empathetic and supportive attitudes toward
addiction.
The insights from the Collaborative Creation Circles show the integration of cultural
sensitivity, community input, and co-design practices is important in developing communication
messages for addiction recovery. The materials developed by participants for the Northern
Minnesota Addiction Wellness Center highlight the teamwork and cultural connection important
in helping individuals recover.
Concluding Insights
In concluding this detailed exploration, the insights from both individual interviews and
Collaborative Creation Circles with Ojibwe community members of Northern Minnesota have
illuminated a path forward for developing communication strategies that genuinely resonate with
Ojibwe peoples navigating the recovery journey. This reveals the potential of culturally specific
messaging to enhance engagement, comprehension, and empowerment throughout the recovery
journey.
The collaborative approach, integrating community insights and creative expressions, has
shown the critical importance of embedding Ojibwe cultural symbols, language, and narratives
into recovery messaging. This honors the cultural identity of Ojibwe peoples and strengthens the
messages' relevance and impact. The preference for positive, empowering content over
fear-based narratives emerged as a clear directive, guiding the creation of materials that inspire
hope and convey a deep respect for the community's resilience and capabilities.
168
Furthermore, the use of varied communication strategies, including personal stories and
culturally significant symbols like the medicine wheel, emphasizes the multifaceted nature of
effective communication. These strategies transmit information and create connections,
providing a sense of belonging, and supporting the community's journey toward healing.
Looking ahead, the findings from this research offer a blueprint for future initiatives
aimed at addressing substance use disorder within Ojibwe communities. The research method of
co-design used in this dissertation offers a valuable approach for other communities seeking to
uncover communication insights tailored to their unique cultural values and traditions, thereby
supporting long-term healing and recovery processes. By prioritizing cultural relevance,
community involvement, and empowering messaging, there's an opportunity to craft more
effective, compassionate, and engaging recovery programs. This effort aligns with the needs and
values of the Ojibwe community and sets a precedent for how we understand and support
recovery across diverse cultural landscapes.
While the insights and methodologies detailed in this exploration offer promising
avenues for culturally tailored communication strategies within Ojibwe communities, it's crucial
to recognize that these approaches may not universally translate across different cultural
contexts. The incorporation of Ojibwe cultural symbols, language, and narratives into recovery
messaging—resonates with Ojibwe peoples—shows the importance of cultural specificity in
health communication strategies. This specificity also signals a potential challenge when
applying similar methods in communities with distinct cultural identities and values. For
example, symbols and narratives that hold meaning and provide comfort to Ojibwe communities
may not have the same relevance or could even have unintended negative implications in other
cultural settings. This emphasizes the need for a nuanced understanding of each community's
169
unique cultural framework before implementing communication strategies derived from one
specific cultural context. Therefore, while the co-design approach and the emphasis on positive,
empowering messaging offer valuable lessons, they must be adapted with sensitivity to the
cultural dynamics of other communities to ensure they support healing and recovery without
inadvertently causing alienation or misunderstanding. This delicate balance between cultural
specificity and universal applicability highlights the complexity of designing health
communication strategies that are both effective and respectful across diverse cultural
landscapes.
In essence, this is just the beginning of a journey toward a deeper understanding of how
to effectively communicate within the context of addiction recovery in a way that honors and
incorporates cultural identity and community strength. It advocates for a shift toward more
inclusive, empathetic, and culturally attuned approaches in the field of health communication,
highlighting the indispensable role of community collaboration in creating meaningful and
effective recovery support tools.
170
DISCUSSION
Summary of Primary Findings
In this discussion section, I reflect on the core discoveries of the study, which investigates
the Ojibwe community's preferences in communication strategies in recovery messaging. The
research questions that guided this study asked: What preferences do Ojibwe community
members in Northern Minnesota have for messaging within addiction recovery program
materials? In what ways can their preferences inform the creation of effective communication
tools that encourage engagement with available recovery resources? This research uncovered
insights, notably emphasizing the importance of cultural relevance, community engagement, and
favored communication strategies as key to improving recovery messages among Ojibwe
peoples.
Key findings reveal a strong preference for recovery messaging that resonates with the
Ojibwe community's cultural values and traditions. This involves incorporating the Ojibwe
language, symbols, and stories into recovery program materials. Doing so respects the
community's cultural identity. Additionally, discussing the teachings and wisdom of Elders with
cultural practices greatly improves the success of these programs. As such culturally tailored
messaging creates a greater sense of connection and relevance, encouraging more meaningful
connection with recovery resources and their programming.
Preferred communication messaging emerged as another central theme, with a clear
preference for approaches that empower and inspire hope, rather than those that instill fear. The
findings suggest a shift toward positive, strengths-based messaging that emphasizes recovery as
a journey of healing and growth, grounded in the community's cultural and spiritual beliefs. This
171
aligns with the broader desire for recovery resources that are informative and resonate on an
emotional and cultural level.
The communication preferences identified for reaching and engaging the Ojibwe
community in recovery programs highlight a diverse range of modes. A preference is in-person
recruitment, which is effectively supported by the distribution of flyers. These flyers are not only
handed out during direct recruitment efforts but are also strategically placed in locations where
they are likely to reach potential participants, such as jails, hospitals, and community colleges.
This method ensures that information about recovery programs is accessible in spaces frequented
by community members who may benefit most from these services.
Radio chats and educational talks are also favored communication strategies, leveraging
local media and community gatherings to spread awareness and knowledge about addiction and
recovery. These platforms offer a dynamic way to engage the community, providing
opportunities for interaction and immediate feedback. Furthermore, word of mouth is a powerful
tool within the community, harnessing the trust and existing networks of community members to
share information organically.
Once individuals are engaged with recovery facilities, online tools become more relevant,
with website searches serving as a primary method for accessing detailed program information
and resources. This dual approach of using both traditional and digital media ensures
comprehensive coverage that respects the community’s preferences and maximizes the reach and
impact of recovery messaging.
Peer support also proved to be invaluable in recovery programs where shared experiences
resonate strongly. This support system utilizes the unique perspective of individuals who have
navigated their own paths through addiction and recovery, offering guidance rooted in empathy
172
and shared understanding. Such peer relationships foster trust and accountability, enhancing
engagement in recovery efforts. Moreover, peer support strengthens community bonds, instills
hope, and builds resilience by demonstrating that recovery is both achievable and sustainable
within the community. The involvement of peers in the recovery process makes it more relatable
and accessible, leveraging personal triumphs and struggles to empower others.
Moreover, the findings highlight the critical role of community engagement in the
development of communication strategies. By involving community members, Elders, and
healthcare professionals in a collaborative process, the research ensures that the communication
tools created are culturally appropriate and address the specific needs and preferences of the
Ojibwe community. This collaborative approach, particularly through methods like Collaborative
Creation Circles, ensures that recovery messages are authentic and empowering, reflecting the
community's collective experiences and insights.
These findings offer contributions to the field of health communication, highlighting the
critical importance of cultural sensitivity and community participation in crafting effective
communication strategies for recovery messaging. They show the need for communication tools
that are seen, heard, felt, and lived by the community members they aim to serve. This research
lays the groundwork for future efforts to improve the health and recovery results of Ojibwe
communities. It supports a respectful and inclusive strategy that values the distinct cultural
identities and strengths of community members.
Findings in Relation to Existing Literature
The field of recovery messaging in health communication has increasingly recognized the
importance of culturally responsive and empowering strategies, particularly within diverse
173
communities. This section explores how the findings from this dissertation align with and expand
upon the existing literature on effective communication strategies in recovery programs, with a
focus on the Ojibwe community. It highlights the crucial role of using empowering and hopeful
communication, the necessity for diverse and accessible communication strategies, and the
critical influence of cultural sensitivity in enhancing the effectiveness of recovery programs
(Lefebvre et al., 2020; Skinstad, 2021). Empowering and hopeful communication strategies are
highlighted as essential for enhancing motivation and engagement in recovery programs. The
findings from this study confirm the literature’s advocacy for positive, strengths-based
approaches rather than fear-based messaging, which has been shown to foster more proactive and
responsive engagement among participants (Lefebvre et al., 2020; Skinstad, 2021). Additionally,
the dissertation emphasizes the importance of a varied toolkit for communication, incorporating
in-person recruitment, strategic placement of flyers, and the use of radio chats and educational
talks. This approach aligns with the literature on the effectiveness of utilizing multiple
communication channels to ensure broad reach and deep impact within the community (Boyd et
al., 2021; Venner et al., 2018).
The findings show the importance of using empowering and hopeful communication
strategies, a theme that is supported by the literature review's discussion on the effectiveness of
positive, strengths-based approaches. This preference for inspiring rather than fear-based
messaging aligns with broader research findings that suggest such strategies enhance motivation
and engagement among participants (Lefebvre et al., 2020; Skinstad, 2021).
Furthermore, the emphasis on diverse communication strategies, including in-person
recruitment and the strategic placement of flyers, reflects insights from the literature on the
necessity of accessible and community-integrated communication methods. The use of radio
174
chats, educational talks, and word of mouth as primary tools for spreading awareness and
engaging the community is particularly noteworthy. This multi-modal approach aligns with the
literature's assertion that varied communication channels can broaden the reach and impact of
recovery programs, ensuring that messages resonate across different segments of the community
(Boyd et al., 2021; Venner et al., 2018).
The findings on the role of cultural sensitivity in recovery programs for the Ojibwe
community align with existing literature that highlights the importance of integrating cultural
practices, symbols, and languages into recovery efforts. This literature highlights that cultural
incorporation enhances the acceptance and effectiveness of these programs but also
fundamentally supports the identity and social cohesion of Indigenous communities. For
example, Venner et al. (2018) have demonstrated that recovery programs tailored to the cultural
contexts of Indigenous groups markedly improve participation and outcomes. This aligns with
findings from this study that show preference for the integration of the Ojibwe language and
cultural symbols into recovery messaging can enhance program reception by Ojibwe peoples.
Further support comes from Boyd et al. (2021), who explore the effectiveness of recovery
programs that include Indigenous languages and traditional practices. Their research concludes
that these elements substantially increase the programs' relevance and acceptability among
Indigenous participants—a conclusion that mirrors the observations regarding the Ojibwe
community. Additionally, the research by Lefebvre et al. (2020) into health communication
strategies show the importance of involving community members in the creation of health
messages, a practice that leads to more effective and culturally congruent health communication
strategies. This approach is reflected in the dissertation’s methodology, which involves the
Ojibwe community in the development of culturally resonant recovery messaging.
175
Moreover, the findings from this dissertation contribute to the discourse on cultural
competence in health communication, as highlighted by Skinstad (2021) and Lefebvre et al.
(2020). These studies highlight the importance of culturally sensitive approaches in reducing
stigma and enhancing the delivery of health services. They advocate for the involvement of
community members in developing health messages and interventions, which leads to more
effective and culturally congruent health communication strategies.
The dissertation's examination of the stigma associated with addiction within the Ojibwe
community offers important insights, aligning with broader research that stresses the importance
of culturally sensitive approaches to stigma reduction. By focusing on empowering language and
incorporating community-driven narratives, this study provides valuable strategies for addressing
and mitigating the negative perceptions surrounding addiction.
Existing research, such as that by Lefebvre et al. (2020), supports the idea that stigma
reduction is crucial for the success of health interventions, particularly in communities where
addiction may be heavily stigmatized. The findings of this dissertation suggest that using
language that emphasizes strength, recovery, and community connection can help to reframe the
perception of addiction from a negative to a more constructive perspective. This approach is in
line with studies that highlight the power of positive and empowering narratives in changing
public attitudes and reducing stigma (Skinstad, 2021).
Participants expressed that the use of Ojibwe language and the inclusion of local stories
and symbols in recovery messaging create a sense of pride and ownership, which is essential for
combating stigma. For example, an Elder stated, "When we hear our language and see our
symbols, it reminds us of our strength and history, not just our struggles.” This aligns with Boyd
176
et al. (2021), who discuss how Indigenous languages and cultural practices enhance the
relevance and acceptance of health interventions among Indigenous communities.
Additionally, the integration of community narratives in recovery messaging contributes
to a better understanding of effective strategies for stigma reduction. By including stories of
resilience and recovery from community members themselves, recovery programs can provide
relatable and realistic examples of overcoming addiction. This method aligns with the research
advocating for the use of personal stories as a means to humanize the issue of addiction and
reduce associated stigma (Boyd et al., 2021).
Resonating with existing studies on the effectiveness of peer support, family
involvement, and community-based recovery initiatives - this research emphasizes how
community connections and support mechanisms can greatly enhance recovery outcomes,
aligning with broader literature that points to the benefits of integrated social support in
treatment programs.
Research such as that by Lefebvre et al. (2020) and Boyd et al. (2021) indicates that
recovery is more successful when supported by a network of peers, family, and community
members. This adds to the discourse by detailing how Ojibwe community-based recovery
programs utilize local cultural practices and community gatherings to facilitate peer support, thus
embedding recovery within culturally significant and familiar contexts.
This work demonstrates how peer-led initiatives incorporate the lived experiences of
individuals who have successfully navigated their own recovery journeys. Peers serve as mentors
and models of resilience, providing both emotional support and practical guidance crucial for
long-term recovery. This mirrors findings from Lefebvre et al. (2020), who emphasize the role of
peer support in enhancing the effectiveness of recovery programs by offering a sense of
177
community, accountability, and mutual understanding among participants. Additionally, the
dissertation's focus on peer recovery aligns with Boyd et al. (2021), who note that culturally
tailored peer interactions can improve engagement and outcomes in health interventions by
embedding recovery programs within the cultural and social fabric of the community. This dual
approach of cultural sensitivity combined with peer support effectively enriches the recovery
process, reinforcing both individual and communal pathways to healing within the Ojibwe
community.
Moreover, the importance of community-based recovery initiatives is distinctly outlined
in this study. It reveals how these initiatives provide a supportive network that also helps
integrate individuals into a positive social environment, reinforcing recovery goals. This
approach corresponds with findings from Skinstad (2021), who observed that recovery programs
integrated within community structures tend to be more successful due to their accessibility and
relevance.
This dissertation corroborates existing research on effective recovery messaging but also
contributes new insights into the application of these strategies within the Ojibwe community.
The integration of empowering language, a multimodal communication strategy, and cultural
sensitivity are all shown to play roles in the success of recovery initiatives. These findings
reinforce the necessity of developing recovery programs that are culturally congruent and are
also strongly linked with the community’s social and cultural fabrics, ensuring that they are both
effective and sustainable. This enriches the discourse on cultural competence in health
communication, particularly within contexts for the Ojibwe community, highlighting the
potential for community-driven, culturally informed approaches to enhance the public health
landscape.
178
Interpretation of Findings
The findings from the dissertation illustrate the influence of traditional Ojibwe practices
and beliefs on recovery pathways. These cultural practices, such as the use of traditional
medicine, participation in spiritual rituals, and the emphasis on community and kinship ties, are
essential components of the recovery process. They are not only therapeutic but also integral to
the identity and resilience among the Ojibwe. The integration of these practices into recovery
programs has shown positive outcomes, aligning with community values and enhancing the
relevance and effectiveness of support provided.
The research provides examples of successful integration, such as recovery programs that
incorporate Ojibwe language and cultural symbols, making the recovery environment more
familiar and supportive for participants. Such culturally adapted interventions receive greater
acceptance and participation, leading to improved recovery rates and sustained engagement with
treatment programs. These examples highlight the critical role of cultural competence among
healthcare providers. The findings emphasize that healthcare providers who understand and
incorporate Ojibwe cultural contexts into their practice can build trust with community members,
which is crucial for effective communication and increasing adherence to recovery programs.
Moreover, the approaches adopted by culturally competent healthcare providers directly
influence the effectiveness of recovery messaging and the overall success of recovery programs.
When providers respect Ojibwe traditions and social structures, they deliver messages that
resonate with the community members' lived experiences. This alignment can enhance the
relevance and impact of the messaging, leading to higher levels of program adherence and
success in recovery outcomes. The evidence suggests that when recovery programs are culturally
179
congruent, they not only address the immediate needs of the individuals but also promote a
supportive environment that sustains long-term well-being and resilience within the community.
The findings illustrate the role that community engagement and social support hold in the
recovery processes within Ojibwe communities, aligning closely with Indigenous values about
collective involvement and mutual assistance. These preferences are essential, reflecting
principles in Indigenous standpoint theory and grounded theory that guided the research
methodology and analysis. Indigenous standpoint theory is particularly beneficial for
understanding how Indigenous values and community frameworks influence recovery outcomes,
emphasizing the need for recovery efforts that are culturally attuned and supported by the
community.
Grounded theory, employed to systematically derive conclusions from the data, facilitates
the inclusion of community-centric insights into the design of recovery programs. This ensures
that the programs accurately reflect and respond to the genuine needs and cultural practices of
the Ojibwe community. The data indicates a preference for recovery programs that integrate
communal activities and the support of an extensive social network, essential for enhancing the
effectiveness of recovery outcomes.
Strong community connections and active participation in social networks, as highlighted
by community members, lead to more successful recovery experiences. Programs that
incorporate these elements show higher engagement rates and improved outcomes. Examples
from the research include recovery initiatives that incorporate traditional ceremonies and group
therapy sessions conducted by respected community Elders. These programs provide emotional
and spiritual support while reinforcing cultural identity and communal responsibility, all crucial
for effective recovery.
180
To encourage community involvement in recovery programs, it is recommended to create
more opportunities for community participation and leadership within these initiatives. Allowing
community members to assume roles such as mentors or group facilitators can empower
individuals and strengthen community bonds. Moreover, recovery programs designed and led by
community members ensure alignment with cultural practices and expectations of Ojibwe
communities. Involving the community in the planning stages of recovery programs also
enhances the relevance and acceptance of these initiatives, making them more effective at
meeting the community's needs.
Findings demonstrate the effectiveness of culturally grounded communication strategies
in reducing stigma associated with recovery from addiction within the Ojibwe community. By
integrating cultural elements that resonate with community values and historical context, these
communication strategies address and diminish the stigma surrounding addiction, thereby
enhancing the openness and engagement of community members in discussing and seeking
recovery options.
Specific strategies that have shown alignment with community preferences for addressing
stigma involve the use of traditional narratives and language that reflect the community’s cultural
heritage and collective identity. These strategies include storytelling sessions led by Elders that
incorporate traditional Ojibwe teachings and recovery stories, which educate and reinforce
community bonds and shared understanding. Another effective approach has been the integration
of cultural symbols and practices into public health campaigns, which helps normalize recovery
and portrays it as a strength-based process supported by the community.
The implications of these findings for public health messaging and policy-making are
important. By demonstrating the effectiveness of culturally informed communication strategies,
181
the research provides a model for how public health messages can be designed to resonate more
with specific communities, particularly Indigenous populations. This approach not only improves
the effectiveness of these messages in achieving their health promotion goals but also supports
the broader objective of cultural preservation and respect.
Furthermore, these culturally grounded approaches have the potential to transform
perceptions of addiction and recovery not just within Ojibwe communities but also in broader
cultural communities. By showcasing successful strategies that respect and incorporate
Indigenous knowledge and practices, public health policy can shift toward more inclusive and
culturally sensitive frameworks. This shift has the potential to influence public perceptions and
reduce stigma on a wider scale, encouraging a more empathetic and holistic view of addiction
and recovery.
The importance of integrating cultural sensitivity, community engagement, and effective
stigma reduction efforts into addiction and recovery messaging for the Ojibwe and broader
Indigenous populations cannot be overstated. This dissertation highlights the role that culturally
tailored messaging plays in enhancing the effectiveness of recovery programs. By ensuring that
recovery messages are aligned with cultural values and community norms, these initiatives not
only respect and preserve Indigenous heritage but also improve engagement and outcomes.
Cultural sensitivity is crucial in the crafting of health messages, ensuring that they are
perceived as relevant and respectful. This relevance is key to enhancing receptivity and
participation among community members, fostering an environment where individuals feel
understood and supported. Community engagement strengthens these messaging efforts, drawing
on the collective power and support inherent in Indigenous communities. This approach supports
individual resilience and reinforces community cohesion, important for recovery efforts.
182
Stigma reduction through culturally informed messaging further amplifies the
effectiveness of these programs. By addressing stigma in a way that resonates culturally, these
messages break down barriers to seeking help, which is often a hurdle. Culturally resonant
messaging not only educates but also changes perceptions, promoting a more compassionate and
understanding view of addiction as a manageable condition rather than a personal failing.
Reflecting on the potential of these findings to influence future research, policy, and
practice, there is a profound opportunity to expand the application of culturally resonant
messaging within recovery programs. Future research should continue to explore the impact of
such messaging on recovery rates and long-term outcomes, providing data to support policy
changes and the broader adoption of culturally informed practices. Policy makers are encouraged
to recognize the efficacy of culturally tailored messaging and to support initiatives that integrate
these practices.
In practice, the implementation of recovery programs that incorporate these findings can
lead to more effective engagement for recovery outcomes. There is a clear need for continued
investment in recovery programs that respect and utilize the cultural values of Indigenous
communities. Such programs serve the immediate needs of individuals and contribute to the
health and vitality of entire communities, marking a step forward in public health and wellness.
Implications for Theory and Practice
The findings of this study expand existing theoretical frameworks in health
communication by integrating the specific cultural context of the Ojibwe community and their
unique recovery messaging needs. Using Grounded Theory and Indigenous Standpoint Theory,
this research respects and reflects Indigenous epistemologies and ontologies, challenging and
183
extending current understandings of recovery communication by incorporating cultural resilience
and community-specific strategies.
Through grounded analysis of interview data and collaborative circles, the research
reveals the critical role of culturally informed recovery strategies, emphasizing the need for
health communication models to adapt and include the cultural values and traditional practices of
Indigenous communities. This alignment improves the efficacy of recovery programs, offering a
stronger platform for engagement and sustained recovery among the Ojibwe. Insights from this
study suggest that recovery is not just an individual journey but a community process that is
enhanced by culturally resonant support systems.
Moreover, this dissertation revises the depth of peer support systems within Indigenous
communities, showing how these networks function as support mechanisms and as essential
components of the healing process. By doing so, it advocates for a broader interpretation of
recovery models that consider social and cultural dimensions as essential elements of health
communication strategies. This approach calls for a shift toward recovery programs that are
culturally tailored and actively involve community members in their development and
implementation, ensuring that they are relevant and respectful of Ojibwe sovereignty and
self-determination.
The implications of this study for both theory and practice offer a pathway for integrating
Indigenous knowledge and practices into health communication theories. It encourages scholars
and practitioners to consider more inclusive models that genuinely reflect the diversity of
communities they aim to serve, particularly in contexts of health crises like the opioid epidemic
affecting the Ojibwe and other Indigenous peoples. By doing so, it contributes to the broader
184
discourse on health equity, suggesting that truly effective recovery strategies and messaging
should be rooted in an understanding and respect for cultural identities and values.
This study’s exploration of cultural resilience through the lens of Indigenous Standpoint
Theory illustrates how cultural practices, beliefs, and community solidarity are essential
resilience factors in recovery processes within the Ojibwe community. Cultural practices such as
storytelling, ceremonies, and the revitalization of language, strengthen individual and collective
identities, supporting recovery efforts. These elements reinforce the community's connection to
their heritage, providing spiritual strength and a structure for addressing substance misuse (Foley,
2007).
Beliefs rooted in Ojibwe traditions contribute to resilience by portraying recovery not just
as a physical healing process, but as a restoration of balance and wellness across spiritual,
emotional, and community dimensions. This holistic view of health, inherent in many Indigenous
paradigms, contrasts with conventional health frameworks that often focus on the physical
aspects of recovery. The Indigenous health paradigm considers wellness as a balance among
various life aspects, including connections with the land, community, and ancestors, all regarded
as sources of strength (Moreton-Robinson, 2013).
Community solidarity is particularly emphasized as a resilience factor. Findings from the
study show that recovery is supported through communal activities and collective participation in
cultural and ceremonial practices. This solidarity is about mutual support and reinforces a shared
dedication to the values and wellness of the community. Such participation helps individuals in
recovery feel recognized and valued within their social context, enhancing their sense of
belonging and purpose (Nakata, 2007).
185
These findings also complicate the understanding of resilience in the context of
Indigenous health and wellness. While affirming the importance of integrating cultural practices
and community engagement into recovery programs, they also highlight the challenges
communities face in maintaining traditional practices amidst modern pressures and historical
traumas. The resilience of the community is challenged by external factors such as economic
hardships, social discrimination, and the impacts of colonization, which can diminish cultural
identity and community cohesion (Smith, 2012).
Furthermore, the study examines how resilience is conceptualized and operationalized
within the community. It questions whether resilience should be viewed just as the ability to
recover from adversity, suggesting instead that it involves proactive engagement with cultural
renewal and the reclamation of Indigenous identity as essential to wellness. This perspective
invites broader reflection on how health interventions can react and proactively meet the needs of
Indigenous communities, creating environments where cultural practices are preserved and
promoted (Foley, 2007; Moreton-Robinson, 2013).
This study aligns with Indigenous Standpoint Theory by illustrating the role of
Indigenous knowledge and practices in the discourse on addiction and recovery messaging.
Indigenous Standpoint Theory advocates for research grounded in the lived experiences and
cultural frameworks of Indigenous peoples, providing essential perspectives that challenge
dominant narrative structures (Foley, 2007). This theory guides the study's focus on how
recovery messages are created and received within the Ojibwe community, emphasizing the
importance of language, cultural symbols, and collective narratives in promoting health and
wellness.
186
Grounded Theory has been important in revealing culturally specific insights into
communication. This methodology facilitates the emergence of themes from qualitative data,
such as interviews with community members and health practitioners, focusing on how messages
about recovery are crafted and perceived within a cultural context (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis,
2019). Using this approach, the study identifies the central role of traditional communication
methods, like storytelling and ceremonial dialogue, in supporting recovery by strengthening
community bonds and affirming cultural identity.
The findings suggest that effective recovery messaging must resonate with cultural values
and practices to be impactful. Messages incorporating traditional languages, metaphors related to
healing, and narratives of community resilience engage more deeply with community members,
enhancing their involvement with recovery programs. This strategy respects the cultural
dimensions of communication and improves the relevance and receptivity of health messages
within the community.
Integrating Indigenous Standpoint Theory with Grounded Theory to examine recovery
messaging offers a comprehensive view of how Indigenous knowledge systems can influence
health communication. This research highlights the need for developing recovery messaging
strategies that are informative and culturally consonant, ensuring they respect and reflect the
values and experiences of Indigenous communities.
The research highlights the critical need to develop recovery materials that align
culturally, emphasizing the integration of traditional symbols, narratives, and languages specific
to the Ojibwe community. Including these elements enhances the effectiveness of recovery
messages, making them resonate more deeply and meaningfully with community members.
187
Traditional symbols and narratives connect the content to the community’s values and history,
potentially serving as powerful motivational tools within the recovery process.
Incorporating traditional languages into recovery materials strengthens this approach by
ensuring that messages are not only understood intellectually but also felt emotionally. Language
carries layers of cultural meaning and values that deeply resonate, bridging clinical advice and
cultural practices, and making health messages more relatable and accessible.
This research also stresses the importance of co-design processes that include community
members in the development of these materials. Co-design ensures that the materials are
culturally appropriate and meet the specific needs and preferences of the community. This
collaborative approach is crucial for the efficacy of recovery programs, as it empowers
community members by giving them an active role in creating materials designed to support
them. Participatory practices increase the likelihood that recovery materials will be accepted and
utilized, leading to improved health outcomes.
By involving community members in the development process, the materials not only
gain cultural legitimacy but also become more tailored to address the unique challenges faced by
the community. This collaborative method enhances the trust and credibility of the recovery
programs and fosters a stronger commitment to the recovery process among community
members. Additionally, this direct and meaningful involvement strengthens communal bonds and
reinforces shared responsibility for health and wellness, which are central to the Ojibwe way of
life.
The findings from this study stress the importance of creating interventions that are
culturally sensitive and rooted in the lived experiences of Indigenous peoples in recovery. These
interventions should move beyond typical recovery frameworks by integrating culturally-specific
188
elements that reflect the unique values, practices, and historical contexts of Indigenous
communities (Foley, 2007).
Engaging the community in the design and implementation of these interventions is
crucial. This involves collaboration with local leaders, Elders, and community members who
have direct experiences with addiction and recovery. By incorporating traditional healing
practices—such as the use of ceremonial rituals, herbal medicines, and community
gatherings—these interventions align with the spiritual and cultural practices of the community,
thus enhancing their relevance and effectiveness (Moreton-Robinson, 2013).
Such culturally tailored interventions are likely to be more successful because they
resonate with the community's own healing traditions and are perceived as legitimate and
respectful methods of addressing health issues. This cultural congruence helps to secure
community buy-in, which is essential for the success and sustainability of recovery programs
(Nakata, 2007).
Developing effective communication strategies for addiction recovery in Indigenous
communities requires a deep understanding of the community's communication norms, values,
and channels. Insights gathered from interviews with various stakeholders, including healthcare
providers, community Elders, and people in recovery, are invaluable in shaping these strategies.
They provide a diverse range of perspectives that highlight different facets of the addiction and
recovery experience within the community (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019).
One effective approach is to create communication strategies that are informative,
empowering, and motivational. This involves framing messages in a way that highlights stories
of recovery and resilience rather than focusing solely on the perils of addiction. Such positive
framing can inspire hope and motivate engagement with recovery programs. It's also important
189
to ensure that these messages are disseminated through channels that are widely accepted and
trusted by the community, such as local radio stations, community gatherings and spaces, and
through the endorsement of respected community members (Smith, 2012).
Moreover, incorporating the community’s language in communication materials ensures
that the messages are clearly indicated for the community, understood, and that they resonate
with the intended audience. Language is a powerful tool for connection and can greatly enhance
the emotional impact of recovery messages, making them more compelling and persuasive. The
integration of culturally specific symbols and metaphors can also enrich the messages, making
them more relatable and impactful without relying on language. This is a way to reach
individuals who may not be familiar with (all or some) of their communities' language.
By drawing on comprehensive stakeholder insights and respecting the unique cultural
context of the community, the development of communication strategies in addiction recovery
can be improved. This tailored approach enhances the clarity and reach of recovery messages
and strengthens the overall community engagement and support for individuals in their recovery
journey.
This study enhances our understanding of recovery communication by integrating
culturally informed approaches within Ojibwe communities. Utilizing Grounded Theory and
Indigenous Standpoint Theory, the research respects and reflects Indigenous knowledge systems,
challenging and expanding existing health communication models. The findings emphasize the
necessity of incorporating cultural values and traditional practices into recovery strategies,
demonstrating that recovery extends beyond the individual to encompass community-wide
engagement and support.
190
The research demonstrates that recovery messaging is not solely an individual-focused
endeavor but a community-centric process that thrives on culturally resonant support systems.
Traditional practices such as storytelling, ceremonies, and language revitalization play essential
roles in reinforcing community bonds and fostering a supportive environment for recovery.
These cultural elements not only convey messages in ways that are meaningful and respectful to
the community but also strengthen the communal fabric, essential for collective healing and
resilience.
The implications for theory and practice are clear: there is a need for recovery messaging
to be crafted with cultural sensitivity and active community involvement. This approach ensures
that messages are heard and felt, resonating with the community's values and experiences, and
supporting their journey toward recovery.
This study calls on researchers, practitioners, and policymakers to prioritize cultural
relevance and community engagement in developing and implementing recovery messaging
strategies. By embracing and integrating Indigenous knowledge and practices, recovery
messaging can be transformed to serve as a tool for information dissemination and as a powerful
catalyst for healing and empowerment within Indigenous communities. As we move forward,
continued exploration, validation, and promotion of culturally informed messaging approaches
will be essential in advancing health equity and enhancing the efficacy of recovery programs in
Indigenous settings.
Limitations and Future Research
The research conducted in Northern Minnesota focused on Ojibwe community members'
preferences for recovery messaging, employing a qualitative approach that integrated Indigenous
191
Standpoint Theory and Grounded Theory. The study faces limitations due to its sample size and
composition. The semi-structured interviews involved a select group of 24 participants, including
four clinical staff, two community Elders, and 18 Ojibwe individuals personally affected by
substance use disorder. While this provided rich, in-depth data, the relatively small and specific
sample limits the generalizability of the findings. There's a bias due to the singular representation
of certain sub-groups within the broader Native American and Ojibwe populations, such as age,
socioeconomic, and geographic diversity, which may not have been fully captured.
These limitations raise concerns about the extent to which the findings can be applied to
other Indigenous communities. The sample’s composition also may not accurately reflect the full
spectrum of experiences and views within Ojibwe communities as well as in broader Indigenous
contexts, potentially affecting the validity and applicability of the study’s conclusions outside the
specific community studied.
The geographic scope of the study is a potential limitation. The research was localized to
the Ojibwe community in Northern Minnesota, where specific cultural, social, and environmental
factors influence recovery messaging preferences and the efficacy of community engagement
strategies. This geographic limitation suggests that the findings may not directly transfer to other
communities with different cultural backgrounds or regional characteristics.
These geographic constraints limit the findings' relevance and applicability to other
Indigenous populations, requiring adjustments or additional research to tailor recovery
messaging strategies to different communities. Future research should expand to include a
variety of communities across specific regions to enhance the diversity of cultural perspectives
and experiences captured, thereby improving the robustness and applicability of the research
findings to broader Indigenous communities.
192
The study's reliance on qualitative data, while providing rich and detailed insights into
the perspectives of the Ojibwe community, introduces methodological limitations that affect the
interpretation and broader application of its findings. Qualitative research, as used in this study
through semi-structured interviews and collaborative creation circles, excels in exploring
in-depth personal and cultural dynamics but does not offer the broader information that
quantitative methods provide (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019). This reliance on qualitative
methods restricts the ability to extrapolate findings to all Ojibwe individuals, as the collected
data represent a deep but narrow view focused on individual experiences and perceptions.
Additionally, potential biases in data collection processes must be considered. The
subjective nature of qualitative inquiry can introduce variations in how data are collected,
interpreted, and presented. Factors such as the interviewer's perspective, the specific phrasing of
questions, and the participants' perceptions of the research could influence the responses,
possibly leading to biased data or interpretations (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019).
Despite these limitations, the study's focus on the Ojibwe community is both its strength
and its specialization. While this focus provides detailed insights into a specific cultural context,
it also means that the findings are particularly tailored to that setting and may not directly
transfer to other contexts without consideration of their unique cultural, social, and
environmental circumstances (Foley, 2007).
To address these methodological constraints in future research, it would be beneficial to
employ mixed-methods approaches that combine qualitative depth with quantitative breadth.
This would allow researchers to map the extent of observed phenomena more comprehensively
and validate qualitative findings with empirical data. Expanding the scope of research to include
diverse segments within the Ojibwe community including communities in Canada and other
193
Indigenous groups in larger regions such as the Great Lakes could also help to enhance the
generalizability and applicability of the findings within specific Indigenous communities (Foley,
2007).
Future longitudinal research is essential for a deeper understanding of the recovery
journey over time among Indigenous individuals. I recommend that future studies track
participants over extended periods to observe the sustainability of recovery outcomes and the
long-term impacts of culturally sensitive interventions and their messaging modes and methods.
These studies should aim to measure various outcomes such as relapse rates, psychological
well-being, community integration, and the revitalization of cultural practices. By documenting
changes over time, researchers can identify which aspects of culturally tailored programs are
most effective and how they contribute to sustained recovery. Additionally, such research could
explore intergenerational effects, examining how recovery impacts families and future
generations within these communities (Smith, 2012). This approach will provide valuable
insights into the long-term benefits and potential areas for improvement in recovery strategies
tailored to Indigenous populations.
Comparative studies would also be helpful for understanding how addiction and recovery
messaging dynamics operate across different cultural and ethnic groups. I advocate for research
that compares the impacts of addiction and recovery processes between Indigenous communities
and other racial or ethnic groups. This analysis should focus on identifying unique challenges
and strengths within Indigenous communities that might influence recovery outcomes differently
from those in non-Indigenous contexts (Chun Tie, Birks, & Francis, 2019). Then inquire how
these recovery spaces communicate to their audiences and why.
194
Furthermore, it is beneficial to conduct comparative analyses within various Indigenous
communities to evaluate the effectiveness of different culturally tailored intervention programs.
Such studies would involve multiple communities that vary in geographical, cultural, and social
attributes to determine how these variables affect the success of recovery interventions. By
comparing these programs, researchers can identify best practices and elements that are
universally effective, as well as those that should be customized to fit specific community needs
(Foley, 2007).
A Need for Future Research
This dissertation highlights the critical need for recovery messaging that is culturally
sensitive and closely engaged with community practices, especially within Ojibwe and other
Indigenous groups in the United States. The research clearly shows a gap between the existing
approaches in recovery messaging and the specific needs and preferences expressed by Ojibwe
community members. This gap points to a general neglect in mainstream recovery programs to
include culturally specific elements that resonate with Indigenous values and healing practices.
The findings reveal that the Ojibwe community prefers recovery messages that reflect
their cultural narratives and are intertwined with communal and spiritual aspects of healing. This
alignment not only makes the messages more relevant but also improves engagement and
effectiveness of recovery programming. Mainstream recovery messaging often lacks this cultural
connection, leading to disengagement among Indigenous populations who do not see their
cultural identity and communal values reflected.
Therefore, there is an urgent need for a change in how recovery programs are designed
and communicated. This change should involve a model that genuinely incorporates Indigenous
195
knowledge, traditions, and communication preferences. Such an approach would not only fill the
current gap but also empower Indigenous communities by affirming their cultural identities and
supporting their unique pathways to recovery. This study calls for public health stakeholders,
community leaders, and policymakers to rethink and realign recovery efforts with the cultural
realities and preferences of Indigenous communities. It is time for committed action to ensure
that recovery messaging is as culturally resonant and effective as it is respectful and inclusive.
Building on the findings of this research, it is crucial for researchers to continue
exploring culturally specific recovery strategies. There is a substantial need for more qualitative
and quantitative studies that look into the nuances of effective communication and intervention
strategies within Indigenous populations in the United States. Such studies are essential to
expand our knowledge base, enabling the development of recovery programs that are truly
aligned with the cultural identities and healing traditions of Indigenous communities. This
continued inquiry will not only enhance the efficacy of interventions but also contribute to the
broader academic (and applied) discourse on culturally competent healthcare practices.
In addition to further exploration, this research strongly advocates for the adoption of
collaborative research models. These models should actively involve members of Indigenous
communities in the research process, thereby ensuring that the studies are informed by the lived
experiences and cultural knowledge of those communities. Participatory research approaches are
crucial for creating genuine engagement and trust between researchers and community members.
By integrating Indigenous perspectives at every stage of the research process, from design to
implementation and evaluation, these models generate results that are scientifically sound and
culturally relevant. This approach promotes a more ethical, respectful, and effective way to
address the unique needs and challenges faced by Indigenous community members in recovery.
196
Conclusion
This dissertation has illuminated effective communication strategies that resonate with
the Ojibwe community, particularly in the context of recovery messaging. It has revealed critical
insights into the community's preferences for messaging, which emphasize empowerment and
hope, offering an alternative to fear-based approaches. These insights stress the importance of
employing mediums of communication that are culturally consonant and physically accessible,
such as in-person discussions, radio chats, and strategically placed flyers.
Additionally, the research highlights how the integration of cultural symbols, languages,
and narratives into recovery messaging not only respect and preserve Ojibwe cultural identity but
also can enhance the engagement and effectiveness of communications. By integrating
traditional elements into modern recovery strategies, the dissertation highlights the role of
cultural respect and sensitivity in developing communication approaches that are heard and felt
by the community. This integration acts as a bridge, connecting the Ojibwe community’s heritage
with contemporary health interventions, thereby creating a more inclusive and supportive
recovery environment. The study has documented that recovery messages that integrate aspects
such as Ojibwe language, storytelling, and spiritual rituals resonate more with the community,
facilitating a more engaged and responsive audience.
This contributes to the understanding of the role that community engagement and social
support play in creating environments conducive to recovery. It demonstrates how incorporating
communal narratives and involving community members, including Elders and healthcare
professionals, in the development of recovery messaging can enhance the effectiveness of these
197
interventions. The research shows that recovery programs integrated with the community’s
cultural and social structure are more likely to succeed.
The findings stress the importance of basing recovery interventions on the principles of
community solidarity and active participation. Engaging the Ojibwe community in the
development and execution of recovery strategies ensures cultural relevance and promotes
empowerment. This involvement creates a sense of ownership and pride among community
members, which is crucial for sustaining recovery outcomes over time.
Furthermore, the dissertation highlights how community-based support systems, such as
peer networks and Elder-led discussions, provide essential social support necessary to sustain
recovery efforts. These systems reinforce community bonds which are vital for supporting
individuals on their recovery journeys. By leveraging community resources and capabilities,
these interventions can lead to more resilient and lasting recovery outcomes.
This dissertation reinforces the crucial need for an integrated approach that merges community
engagement, cultural sensitivity, and evidence-based practices in addressing recovery messaging
within Indigenous communities. The research emphasizes that such strategies are necessary to
create interventions that are effective and respect the unique cultural contexts of these
communities.
The findings point to the limitations of generic, one-size-fits-all solutions in recovery
messaging, especially when addressing diverse populations such as Indigenous communities.
The study highlights the importance of developing customized strategies that are finely tuned to
the specific cultural norms and values of these groups. By incorporating cultural elements—from
language and symbols to community values and traditional practices—into health messaging,
198
these strategies build a deeper connection with the audience, enhancing receptivity and the
overall impact.
Additionally, the research underlines how culturally sensitive approaches not only
improve the effectiveness of interventions but also promote community empowerment by
reinforcing cultural identity and pride. This integrated approach, which honors and leverages the
cultural strengths of Indigenous communities, is important for creating trust and cooperation
between healthcare providers and community members, thereby boosting the success of recovery
efforts.
The necessity to move away from broad-brush methods to embrace more refined and
culturally informed strategies is a key theme of this dissertation. Such approaches are not just
recommended but essential for advancing health communication and public health interventions
targeting Indigenous populations, ensuring that recovery messages are heard, resonant, and
meaningful to the communities they are meant to serve.
This analysis highlights several opportunities for advancing research on recovery
intervention and communication strategies within diverse Indigenous populations. It points to the
necessity for further studies that examine the complexities and effectiveness of culturally tailored
recovery messaging across various Indigenous groups. Future research should investigate how
cultural distinctions impact the success of intervention strategies, aiming to broaden our
understanding and identify effective approaches that resonate across different communities.
There is also a call for ongoing collaboration between researchers, community leaders,
healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Such cooperative efforts are crucial to building upon
the groundwork established by this dissertation. By uniting these diverse perspectives, the
development and implementation of recovery messaging can be enhanced, ensuring that
199
interventions are both evidence-based and rooted in the cultural realities of the communities they
aim to support.
Further, promoting interdisciplinary research teams could introduce new insights and
methods into the study of addiction recovery messaging within Indigenous populations. These
teams are well-positioned to apply advanced research techniques and technologies that can more
accurately assess the efficacy of culturally informed interventions.
In summary, the proposed future directions aim to widen the research scope, increase
community involvement, and refine recovery messaging strategies. This approach is intended to
contribute to more effective and culturally sensitive addiction recovery interventions for
Indigenous populations, aligning scientific inquiry with community-based knowledge and
practices.
Reflecting on this research journey, it has enhanced my understanding of the needs and
challenges Indigenous communities face in recovery - as a whole. This dissertation has not only
highlighted the complexities involved in creating effective recovery messaging but also
demonstrated the potential impact of culturally sensitive and community-engaged approaches.
The insights gained emphasize the need for communication strategies that align with the cultural
and social fabrics of Indigenous populations, which can lead to better engagement and more
sustainable recovery outcomes.
This work brings hope that with the right approaches, substantial progress can be made in
addressing this critical public health issue. It shows how blending traditional ways of knowing
with modern health practices can lead to more respectful and effective health interventions. The
potential for these culturally attuned strategies to enhance the well-being of many is significant,
offering a pathway that respects cultural identities while tackling health challenges.
200
I am grateful to all the individuals who generously shared their experiences and insights
with me throughout this project. Their willingness to open up about their personal journeys and
provide such deep, detailed perspectives has been invaluable. I appreciate the time, energy, and
genuine presence each person devoted, which has shaped the outcomes of this research.
Additionally, my gratitude extends to my mentors and colleagues, whose guidance and
expertise were crucial in shaping this study. Their knowledge and critical insights provided a
solid foundation from which this work could evolve. Their support proved indispensable, not
only in navigating the technical aspects of this project but also in offering moral and intellectual
encouragement throughout the process (because the Creator knew I needed each and every one
of you).
Finally, I acknowledge the collective effort of everyone involved in this research,
including community leaders and healthcare professionals. Their collaboration and dedication
have been essential in enhancing our understanding and in developing effective communication
strategies. I express my heartfelt gratitude to the Elders, whose involvement in this project was
an honor. Their active participation and meaningful discussions were critical in shaping every
facet of messaging, ensuring it truly reflected and conveyed the authentic voice and traditions of
Ojibwe peoples. Their guidance was important in linking traditional knowledge with modern
communication efforts, enriching this work with insights that only they could provide.
Chi-miigwetch bizindawiyeg (thank you very much to everyone who listened).
201
APPENDICES
Informed Consent
Researcher: Nii Mahliaire, Doctoral Candidate, University of Oregon
Study: Minobimaadizi: Culturally Responsive Health Communication in Ojibwe Communities
Introduction
We are invited to join a study exploring how to share messages about opioid use disorder (OUD)
recovery resources within Ojibwe communities in northern Minnesota. This study aims to find
the most impactful ways to reach and engage the Ojibwe community, while involving family in
the process. Please review this document thoroughly before deciding to participate.
Purpose of the Study
The goal of this study seeks effective communication modes/methods for sharing information
about opioid use disorder recovery resources within Indigenous communities in northern
Minnesota. Aiming to understand the elements that make communication strategies effective for
conveying health messages about opioid use disorder recovery and treatment choices.
Study Procedures
Should you agree to take part, you will have a one-on-one interview with the researcher, Nii
Mahliaire. This interview will last anywhere from 45 to 60 minutes, will be audio-recorded for
accuracy and can take place in person, over a call, or via a video conferencing platform like
Zoom. We'll explore your views and experiences on the best ways to share information about
opioid use disorder recovery resources within your community through a series of open-ended
questions.
Risks and Discomforts
Discussing personal experiences with opioid use disorder or its community impact might stir
minor emotional discomfort. Feel free to skip any question that unsettles you. Also, you may exit
the study anytime without any repercussions.
Benefits
While there may not be direct benefits to you, your input could contribute to enhancing how
information on opioid use disorder recovery resources is shared within Indigenous communities
moving forward.
Confidentiality
We prioritize your confidentiality. Any identifying details will be detached from the interview
transcripts. Only Nii Mahliaire will have access to the secure storage of audio recordings and
transcripts. Although study findings may be shared publicly or at professional gatherings, your
identity will remain undisclosed.
Voluntary Participation
Your engagement in this study is entirely voluntary. Feel free to opt-out or withdraw at any stage
without any penalty or loss. Should you withdraw, all your provided data till that point will be
erased.
202
Contact Information
If you have any questions or concerns about the study, you may contact Nii Mahliaire at
aricam@uoregon.edu.
Why oral consent?
Considering the Ojibwe community's comfort and traditions, I am using an oral consent method
for this study. This friendly approach lets us discuss the study details verbally, making it easier
for you to understand and decide on participation, while respecting cultural norms.
Consent
If you agree to participate in this study, please confirm your understanding of the provided
information by reading the following statement at the start of the audio recording:
"I have read the consent form and I agree to participate in this study."
203
Semi-Structured Interview Questions
Interview Guide - 30 mins to 1 hour interviews
1. Have you read the consent form, and do you agree to participate?
2. What is the brochure telling you? (Give participants time to look it over and answer)
3. How do you usually see information like this?
4. Who tells you about this kind of information? (Resources, education, etc.)
5. How does the brochure make you feel?
a. What do you like about the brochure?
b. What do you dislike/what could be better?
6. After reading this brochure how likely are you to tell people about it?
7. How could this brochure “speak to you” or better represent you?
8. Does it represent your cultural values in any way? How or why not?
a. Do you find the use of cultural symbols, imagery, and language respectful? Are
there specific elements you would add or change?
9. How did you hear about this place?
204
Addiction Treatment Center: Creation Circles
We're diving into a hands-on creative task. We want you to whip up a flyer or brochure for our
treatment center, one that catches your eye and makes you stop. We're looking for something that
feels authentic, talks your language, and shows respect for diverse cultural backgrounds.
Objectives
● Craft a flyer or brochure that grabs attention and feels real.
● Celebrate diverse cultures, including, but not limited to, Ojibwe culture.
● Use language that's down-to-earth and resonates with you.
● Aim to create something that other people would recognize and connect with too in a
public setting.
Instructions
● What's the Buzz?: Consider what makes this place tick for you. Highlight the stuff that
you think is cool and beneficial.
● Talk the Talk: Use words that resonate with you, the lingo you and your friends would
use. Or any other slang that feels real. Always remember to be respectful with your word
choices.
● Culture Vibes: This is your chance to honor the diverse cultures that make up our
community.
● If you're drawn to Ojibwe culture or any other, feel free to incorporate elements like
language, symbols, art, and patterns into your design.
● Get Crafty: Use the paper and art materials provided to bring your flyer or brochure to
life. You don't need any tech, just your hands, your creativity, and your passion!
● Time Check: You've got 1 hour to roll with this. Don't stress over the clock though. This
is all about the ideas, not a race to perfection.
● Show and Tell: Get ready to show off your creation and share why you made the choices
you did. How does your design reach out to you and the community?
What We're Looking For
● A flyer that shouts out what our center is all about.
● A genuine celebration of diverse cultures and heritage.
● Down-to-earth language and terminology that hits home.
● A design that's eye-catching and gets the message across.
205
Codebook
Messaging Preferences
● Code: Messaging_Preferences
○ Definition: Preferences for types of messages (e.g., tone, style, content) in
recovery program materials.
○ Rationale: Identifies the specific messaging characteristics that resonate with
community members.
○ Examples: Positive vs. negative framing, success stories, holistic vs. clinical
approaches.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Direct mentions of preferred message types, descriptions of
effective messaging seen in other contexts, suggestions for ideal messaging.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General discussions on communication that do not relate to
recovery program messaging.
Communication Channels
● Code: Communication_Channels
○ Definition: Preferred methods for receiving recovery program information (e.g.,
digital, print, community meetings).
○ Rationale: Aims to identify the most effective platforms for disseminating
recovery messages.
○ Examples: Social media, brochures, word-of-mouth, community gatherings.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Preferences for specific communication methods, successful
outreach examples, critiques of current methods.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General discussions on communication technologies not
related to recovery information dissemination.
Visual and Design Preferences
● Code: Visual_Design_Preferences
○ Definition: Preferences for the visual and design aspects of recovery program
materials.
○ Rationale: Understands the impact of visual aesthetics and design on the
effectiveness of messaging.
○ Examples: Color schemes, imagery use (e.g., nature, community symbols), layout
simplicity.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Direct mentions of visual or design elements that enhance
message reception, suggestions for design improvements.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General discussions on art or design not related to recovery
program materials.
Cultural Relevance
● Code: Cultural_Relevance
○ Definition: The importance of cultural elements in recovery messaging, including
traditional practices, languages, and symbols.
○ Rationale: Highlights the critical role of cultural sensitivity and appropriateness in
messaging to enhance engagement.
206
○ Examples: Use of Ojibwe language, references to traditional ceremonies,
incorporation of cultural symbols like the medicine wheel.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Mentions of cultural practices, discussions on the significance
of cultural identity in recovery, examples of culturally relevant messages.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General mentions of culture not connected to recovery
messaging.
Community Narratives
● Code: Community_Narratives
○ Definition: Stories and narratives shared by community members about addiction
and recovery.
○ Rationale: Provides insight into the shared experiences and stories that could
inform effective messaging.
○ Examples: Personal recovery stories, community challenges with addiction,
success stories.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Narratives that highlight experiences with substance use
disorder and recovery, both personal and observed.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Stories not related to addiction or recovery.
Empowerment and Hope
● Code: Empowerment_Hope
○ Definition: Elements of messaging that inspire hope, empowerment, and
motivation in the recovery journey.
○ Rationale: Pinpoints the tone and content that can motivate individuals to engage
with recovery resources.
○ Examples: Success stories, empowerment language, focus on recovery
possibilities.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Messages that are seen as uplifting, motivational narratives,
language that conveys hope and empowerment.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Messages that induce fear, shame, or hopelessness.
Stigma and Language
● Code: Stigma_Language
○ Definition: Addresses the impact of social stigma and the power of language on
recovery, highlighting non-stigmatizing terminology.
○ Rationale: Highlights how societal perceptions and language choices influence
individual recovery journeys, emphasizing the need for compassionate, supportive
narratives and language.
○ Examples: Discussions on the effects of terms like "addict," advocacy for terms
such as "person with a substance use disorder."
○ Inclusion Criteria: Mentions of stigmatizing language, discussions advocating for
empowering terminology, reflections on the impact of societal perceptions.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General discussions on communication or language that do not
directly relate to recovery or the experience of stigma.
Misinformation and Accurate Information
207
● Code: Misinformation_AccurateInfo
○ Definition: Encompasses discussions around the impact of misinformation in
addiction recovery education and the emphasis on the necessity for accurate, clear
information in recovery program messaging.
○ Rationale: Identifies how misinformation affects community engagement and
trust in recovery resources and underscores the community's call for reliable,
evidence-based messaging.
○ Examples: Criticisms of drug education inaccuracies, discussions on the
importance of precise language in describing addiction, suggestions for enhancing
message accuracy.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Discussions highlighting worries about false information in
messages about recovery. Calls for sharing information that is factual and
scientifically verified.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Wide-ranging criticisms of educational methods that don't
directly tie to addiction recovery. Ways of spreading information that don't focus
on ensuring truthfulness or combating false information in recovery discussions.
Education and Awareness
● Code: Access_Awareness
○ Definition: The extent to which potential clients are informed about the treatment
center, services, and information about use.
○ Rationale: Assesses the effectiveness of outreach efforts and identifies
opportunities for improving awareness among the target population.
○ Examples: First contact stories, discussions on community knowledge of the
center.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Mentions of how individuals learn about the center and the
methods used for outreach.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Detailed discussions of treatment modalities not related to
outreach or awareness efforts.
Cultural Foundations in Recovery
● Code: Cultural_Sensitivity_Integration
○ Definition: The integration and respect for Indigenous cultural practices, values,
and symbols within the recovery process.
○ Rationale: To highlight the importance of culturally relevant care in supporting
the healing journey of Indigenous clients.
○ Examples: Integration of smudging ceremonies, beadwork sessions, and the use of
Indigenous languages within treatment programs.
○ Inclusion Criteria: References to specific cultural practices, discussions on the
importance of cultural relevance in treatment.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General mentions of therapy that do not specifically
incorporate or acknowledge Indigenous cultural practices.
● Code: Cultural_Restoration_Identity
○ Definition: Efforts aimed at reviving and reinforcing Indigenous identity through
traditional practices, ceremonies, and language learning.
208
○ Rationale: Emphasizes the pivotal role of cultural heritage in fostering a sense of
belonging and identity, essential for recovery.
○ Examples: Participation in pipe ceremonies, language classes, and traditional
crafting sessions like drum making.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Activities and initiatives focused on preserving and practicing
Indigenous traditions and languages.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Non-Indigenous cultural activities or therapeutic activities not
connected to cultural restoration.
Community and Social Dimensions of Recovery
● Code: Community_Social_Recovery
○ Definition: Focuses on the support structure provided by the community,
including peer support, mentorship by Elders and former clients, and the building
of recovery-oriented communities.
○ Rationale: Emphasizes the critical role of communal relationships and social
networks in supporting recovery, highlighting the value of shared experiences and
communal resilience.
○ Examples: Peer-led support groups, Elder-guided cultural teachings, community
recovery events.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Narratives of community support, discussions of social support
networks, descriptions of community-building efforts.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Individual recovery strategies or professional support
mechanisms without a community or cultural component.
Challenges and Barriers to Recovery
● Code: Recovery_Challenges_Barriers
○ Definition: Identifies external and internal obstacles to the recovery process,
including systemic challenges, personal struggles, and the diversity of recovery
experiences.
○ Rationale: Offers insights into the complexities of the recovery journey,
emphasizing the need for addressing these barriers to facilitate more effective
recovery outcomes.
○ Examples: Accounts of encountering systemic barriers, personal narratives of
overcoming addiction-related challenges, discussions on the importance of
recognizing diverse recovery paths.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Specific mentions of challenges faced during recovery,
discussions highlighting the diversity of recovery experiences.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Broad or theoretical discussions on addiction that do not
directly address specific obstacles or challenges in recovery.
Healing and Personal Transformation
● Code: Healing_Personal_Transformation
○ Definition: Captures the healing journey through nature, spirituality, personal
transformation processes, and the importance of forgiveness in recovery.
209
○ Rationale: Reflects the therapeutic benefits of engaging with the natural world
and spiritual practices, and the transformative power of forgiveness and personal
growth in overcoming substance use disorder.
○ Examples: Participation in outdoor spiritual ceremonies, narratives of personal
breakthroughs in recovery, accounts of forgiving oneself or others.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Descriptions of outdoor healing practices, personal stories of
transformation, discussions around the theme of forgiveness.
○ Exclusion Criteria: General recovery activities or therapies that do not involve a
clear connection to nature, spirituality, or the process of personal transformation
and forgiveness.
Future Directions and Expansion
● Code: Future Direction_Expansion
○ Definition: Plans and initiatives aimed at broadening the center's services and
capacity, including new programs and facilities.
○ Rationale: Highlights the center's commitment to addressing unmet needs and
enhancing support for clients through various recovery stages.
○ Examples: Strategic planning for establishing a detox center or transitional
housing.
○ Inclusion Criteria: Detailed discussions on specific future projects and
expansions.
○ Exclusion Criteria: Vague aspirations or goals without concrete plans for
implementation.
210
Co-design Materials
Figure 1a
211
Figure 1b
212
Figure 2a
213
Figure 2b
214
Figure 3
215
Figure 4
216
Figure 5a
217
Figure 5b
218
Figure 6
219
Figure 7a
220
Figure 7b
221
Figure 8a
222
Figure 8b
223
Figure 9
224
Figure 10a
225
Figure 10b
226
Figure 11
227
Figure 12
228
Figure 13
229
Figure 14
230
Figure 15
231
Figure 16
232
Figure 17a
233
Figure 17b
234
Figure 18
235
Figure 19
236
Figure 20
237
REFERENCES
Allen, J., et al. (2018). Multi-level cultural intervention for the prevention of suicide and alcohol
use risk with Alaska Native youth: a nonrandomized comparison of treatment intensity.
Prevention Science, 19(2). 174-185.
American PA. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM–5). American
Psychiatric Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.books.9780890425596
American Psychological Association. (2017). Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of
Conduct. https://www.apa.org/ethics/code
Anthony, K. E., Venette, S. J., Pyle, A. S., Boatwright, B. C., & Reif, C. E. (2018). The role of
social media in enhancing risk communication and promoting community resilience in
the midst of a disaster. K. Bandana & D. Cochran (Eds.), The Role of Risk
Communication in Community Resilience Building. Routledge.
Antonucci, T. C. (1985). Social support: Theoretical advances, recent findings, and pressing
issues. I. G. Sarason & B.R. Sarason (Eds.), Social support: Theory, research, and
application. Nijhoff, 21–37.
Arnett, J. J. (2000). Optimistic bias in adolescent and adult smokers and nonsmokers. Addictive
behaviors, 25(4), 625-632.
Apers, S., Vandebosch, H., Perko, T., & Železnik, N. (2023). Co-Designing Communication: A
Design Thinking Approach Applied to Radon Health Communication. International
Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 20(6), 4965.
https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20064965
Bagley, B. (2019). Narcan can save your loved one: Designing messages for the opioid crisis
using the extended parallel process model. University of Southern Mississippi
Dissertations. 1728. https://aquila.usm.edu/dissertations/1728
Bagley, B. & Beckham, J. (2020). Building messages for the opioid crisis using the extended
parallel process model. Qualitative Research Reports in
Communication, 22(1). 47-55. doi: 10.1080/17459435.2020.1836017
Bahorik, A. L., Satre, D. D., Kline-Simon, A. H., Weisner, C. M., & Campbell, C. I. (2017).
Alcohol, cannabis, and opioid use disorders, and disease burden in an integrated health
care system. Journal of Addiction Medicine, 11(1), 3–9.
doi:10.1097/ADM.0000000000000260
Baker, T. E., & Chang, G. (2016). The use of auricular acupuncture in opioid use disorder: a
systematic literature review. The American Journal on Addictions, 25(8), 592-602.
Bernard, H. R. (2011). Research methods in anthropology: Qualitative and quantitative
approaches (5th ed.). AltaMira Press.
Best, D., & Laudet, A. (2010). The potential of recovery capital. London, UK: RSA.
Boyd, T., Stipek, J., et al. (2021). Quantifying opioid use disorder Cascade of Care outcomes in
an American Indian tribal nation in Minnesota. Drug and alcohol dependence, 222.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2021.108661
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in
Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2021). Rx Awareness.
https://www.cdc.gov/rxawareness/index.html
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics. (2022).
Wide-ranging online data for epidemiologic research (WONDER). http://wonder.cdc.gov
238
Chalana, H., Sachdeva, J. K., Kundal, T., Malhari, A. S., & Choudhary, R. (2015). A
double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized study comparing quetiapine with placebo,
along with oral naltrexone, in the treatment of opioid dependent patients. Journal of
Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences, 4(53), 9158-9167.
Chun Tie, Y., Birks, M., & Francis, K. (2019). Grounded theory research: A design framework
for novice researchers. SAGE Open Medicine, 7, 2050312118822927.
https://doi.org/10.1177/2050312118822927
Cohen, S., Underwood, L. G., & Gottlieb, B. H. (2000). Social support measurement and
intervention: A guide for health and social scientists. Oxford University Press.
Clore, G. L., Schwarz, N., & Conway, M. (1994). Affective causes and consequences of social
information processing. R. S. Wyer & T. K. Srull (Eds.), Handbook of social cognition.
(1), 323–417.
Collins, A.B., Bluthenthal R.N. Boyd, J., & McNeil, R. (2018). Harnessing the language of
overdose prevention to advance evidence-based responses to the opioid crisis.
International Journal of Drug Policy. doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugpo.2018.02.013
Creswell, J. W. (1998). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among five traditions.
Sage Publications.
Creswell, J. W. (2013). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods
approaches (4th ed.). Sage Publications.
Ellingson, L. L., & Borofka, K. G. E. (2014). Grounded theory. In T. L. Thompson (Ed.),
Encyclopedia of health communication (pp. 661-662). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Emerson, R. M., Fretz, R. I., & Shaw, L. L. (2011). Writing ethnographic fieldnotes (2nd ed.).
University of Chicago Press.
Evans, W. D., Blitstein, J., Vallone, D., Post, S., & Nielsen, W. (2010). Systematic review of
health branding: growth of a promising practice. Translational Behavioral Medicine, 1(1),
72-82.
Fetterman, D. M. (2010). Ethnography: Step-by-step (3rd ed.). Sage Publications.
Ferrer, R. A., & Klein, W. M. (2015). Risk perceptions and health behavior. Current Opinion in
Psychology, 5(October), 85–89. https://doi.org/10. 1016/j.copsyc.2015.03.012
Foley, D. (2007). Indigenous Standpoint Theory: An Acceptable Academic Research Process for
Indigenous Academics. The International Journal of the Humanities: Annual Review,
3(8), 25-36.
Garrett, M. T., & Carroll, J. J. (2000). Mending the broken circle: treatment of substance
dependence among Native Americans. Journal of Counseling & Development, 78(4),
379–388. doi:10.1002/j.1556-6676.2000.tb01921.x
Grindell, C., Coates, E., Croot, L., et al. (2022). The use of co-production, co-design and
co-creation to mobilise knowledge in the management of health conditions: a systematic
review. BMC Health Services Research, 22, 877.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-022-08079-y
Goodyear-Smith, F., Jackson, C., & Greenhalgh, T. (2015). Co-design and implementation
research: challenges and solutions for ethics committees. BMC Medical Ethics, 16, 78.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12910-015-0072-2
House, J. S. (1981). Work, stress, and social support. Addison-Wesley.
Hser, Y., Evans, E., Grella, C., Ling, W., & Anglin, D. (2015). Long term course of opioid
addiction. Harvard Review of Psychiatry, 23(2). 76-89. Doi:
10.1097/HRP.0000000000000052
239
Humphreys, K., Shover, C. L., Andrews, C. M., Bohnert, A. S., Brandeau, M. L., Caulkins, J. P.,
& Timko, C. (2022). Responding to the opioid crisis in North America and beyond:
recommendations of the Stanford–Lancet Commission. The Lancet, 399(10324),
555-604. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(21)02252-2
Jones, K. O., Lopes, S., Chen, L., Zhang, L., Zinzow, H., Jindal, M., & Shi, L. (2019).
Perceptions about mindfulness-based interventions among individuals recovering from
opioid and alcohol use disorders: findings from focus groups. Complementary Therapies
in Medicine, 46, 131-135
Judd, H., Meier, C. L., Yaugher, A. C., Campbell, E., & Atismé-Bevins, K. (2021). Opioid use
disorder stigma reduction through story telling narrative and sharing: a qualitative review
and lessons learned. International Journal of Mental Health and Addiction, 1-16.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11469-021-00639-3
Karras, E., Warfield, S. C., Stokes, C. M., & Bossarte, R. M. (2018). Lessons from suicide
prevention campaigns: Considerations for opioid messaging. American Journal of
Preventive Medicine, 55(1), 125–128. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2018.02.015
Kennedy-Hendricks, A., Barry, C. L., Gollust, S. E., Ensminger, M. E., Chisolm, M. S., &
McGinty, E. E. (2017). Social stigma toward persons with prescription opioid use
disorder: associations with public support for punitive and public health–oriented
policies. Psychiatric services, 68(5), 462-469.
Kennedy-Hendricks, A., Busch, S. H., McGinty, E. E., Bachhuber, M. A., Niederdeppe, J.,
Gollust, S. E., & Barry, C. L. (2016). Primary care physicians’ perspectives on the
prescription opioid epidemic. Drug and alcohol dependence, 165, 61-70.
Kennedy-Hendricks, A., McGinty, E. E., & Barry, C. L. (2016). Effects of competing narratives
on public perceptions of opioid pain reliever addiction during pregnancy. Journal of
Health Politics, Policy and Law, 41(5), 873-916.
Kilgo, D. K., & Midberry, J. (2020). Social media news production, emotional Facebook
reactions, and the politicization of drug addiction. Health Communication, 1–9.
doi:10.1080/10410236.2020.1846
Lefebvre, R. C., Chandler, R. K., et al. (2020). Health communication campaigns to drive
demand for evidence-based practices and reduce stigma in the HEALing communities
study. Drug and alcohol dependence, 217..
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.drugalcdep.2020.108338
Leshner, A. I., & Dzau, V. J. (2019). Medication-based treatment to address opioid use disorder.
JAMA. doi:10.1001/jama.2019.5523
Lewis, I., Watson, B., & White, K. M. (2013). Extending the explanatory utility of the EPPM
beyond fear-based persuasion. Health Communication, 28(1), 84-98.
Li, J. (2022). Grounded theory-based model of the influence of digital communication on
handicraft intangible cultural heritage. Heritage Science, 10(1), 126.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s40494-022-00760-z
Lindlof, T. R., & Taylor, B. C. (2011). Qualitative communication research methods (3rd ed.).
Sage Publications.
Lindquist, S., Westerlund, B., Sundblad, Y., Tobiasson, H., Beaudouin-Lafon, M., & Mackay, W.
(2007). Co-designing Communication Technology with and for Families – Methods,
Experience, Results and Impact. In N. Streitz, A. Kameas, & I. Mavrommati (Eds.), The
Disappearing Computer (Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 4500). Springer,
Berlin, Heidelberg. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-540-72727-9_5
240
Mashford-Pringle, A., & Pavagadhi, K. (2020). Using OCAP and IQ as frameworks to address a
history of trauma in Indigenous health research. Journal of Ethics | American Medical
Association.
https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/using-ocap-and-iq-frameworks-address-histor
y-trauma-indigenous-health-research/2020-10
Macpherson, L., Snyder, S. A., Venette, S. J., Sellnow, T. L., Callaway, E., Slovic, P. (2014).
Context and core messages for chromium, medicines and personal care products, NDMA,
and VOCs (Project #4457). Water Research Foundation.
http://www.waterrf.org/Pages/Projects.aspx?PID=4457
Martin, V. B., Scott, C., Brennen, B., & Durham, M. G. (2018). What is grounded theory good
for? College of Communication Faculty Research and Publications, 502.
https://epublications.marquette.edu/comm_fac/502
McCamish-Svensson, C., Samuelsson, G., Hagberg, B., Svensson, T., & Dehlin, O. (1999).
Informal and formal support from a multidisciplinary perspective: A Swedish follow-up
between 80 and 82 years of age. Health and Social Care in the Community. 7, 163–176.
McCracken, G. (1988). The long interview (Vol. 13). Sage Publications.
McCrady, B. S., Ladd, B. O., & Hallgren, K. A. (2012). Theoretical bases of family approaches
to substance abuse treatment. In S. T. Walters & F. Rotgers (Eds.), Treating substance
abuse: Theory and technique (pp. 224–255). The Guilford Press.
McGinty, E. E., & Barry, C. L. (2020). Stigma reduction to combat the addiction crisis —
developing an evidence base. New England Journal of Medicine, 382(14), 1291–1292.
doi:10.1056/nejmp2000227
McGinty, E. E., Goldman, H. H., Pescosolido, B., & Barry, C. L. (2015). Portraying mental
illness and drug addiction as treatable health conditions: effects of a randomized
experiment on stigma and discrimination. Social science & medicine, 126, 73-85.
McGinty, E. E., Stone, E. M., Kennedy-Hendricks, A., Sanders, K., Beacham, A., & Barry, C. L.
(2019). U.S. news media coverage of solutions to the opioid crisis, 2013–2017.
Preventive Medicine, 126, 105771. doi:10.1016/j.ypmed.2019.105771
McLellan, A. T., Carise, D., & Kleber, H. D. (2003). Can the national addiction treatment
infrastructure support the public's demand for quality care? Journal of Substance Abuse
Treatment, 25(2), 117-121.
Meyer, B., Utter, G. L., & Hillman, C. (2021). A personalized, interactive, cognitive behavioral
therapy–based digital therapeutic (MODIA) for adjunctive treatment of opioid use
disorder: Development study. JMIR Mental Health, 8(10). doi: 10.2196/31173.
Momper, S. L., et al. (2017). American Indian Elders share personal stories of alcohol use with
younger tribal members. Journal of Ethnicity in Substance Abuse 16(3), 293-313.
Moreton-Robinson, A. (2013). Towards an Australian indigenous women’s standpoint theory a
methodological tool. Australian Feminist Studies, 28(78), 331-347.
National Institutes of Health. (2020). Guidelines for Obtaining Informed Consent.
https://www.nih.gov/health-information/nih-clinical-research-trials-you/informed-consent
New Spirit New Life. (2016). About Us. Oshki Manidoo - New Spirit. New Life.
http://oshkimanidoo.com/?page_id=1.
Nakata, M. N. (2007). Disciplining the savages, savaging the disciplines. Aboriginal Studies
Press.
Noar, S. M. (2006). A 10-year retrospective of research in health mass media campaigns: where
do we go from here? Journal of Health Communication, 11(1), 21-42.
241
Opioid Response Network. (2022). https://opioidresponsenetwork.org/
OpiSafe. (2023). https://opisafe.com/our-story/who-we-are
Pescosolido, B. A., Martin, J. K., Long, J. S., Medina, T. R., Phelan, J. C., & Link, B. G. (2010).
“A disease like any other”? A decade of change in public reactions to schizophrenia,
depression, and alcohol dependence. American Journal of Psychiatry, 167(11),
1321-1330.
Peters, E., & Slovic, P. (2007). Affective asynchrony and the measurement of the affective
attitude component. Cognition & Emotion, 21(2), 300–329.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02699930600911440
Peters, E. M., Burraston, B., & Mertz, C. K. (2004). An emotion-based model of risk perception
and stigma susceptibility: Cognitive appraisals of emotion, affective reactivity,
worldviews, and risk perceptions in the generation of technological stigma. Risk
Analysis: An International Journal, 24(5), 1349–1367.
https://doi-org.proxy-um.researchport. umd.edu/10.1111/j.0272-4332.2004.00531.x
Preston, N. D., Jacoby, D., & Coady, Y. (2018). A PAL in Need Is a PAL Indeed: An Opioid Use
Case for a Peer Alerting Lifeline (PAL) to Mitigate Risk Exposure. Advances in
Intelligent Systems and Computing, 743–757. doi:10.1007/978-3-030-02683-7_53
Qin, Y., Chen, J., Namkoong, K., Ledford, V., & Lim, J. R. (2020). Increasing perceived risk of
opioid misuse: the effects of concrete language and image. Health Communication, 1–13.
doi:10.1080/10410236.2020.1846323
Rieckmann, T., et al. (2016). A national study of American Indian and Alaska Native substance
abuse treatment: Provider and program characteristics. Journal of Substance Abuse
Treatment, 68. 46-56.
Rimal, R. N., & Morrison, D. (2006). A uniqueness to personal threat (UPT) hypothesis: How
similarity affects perceptions of susceptibility and severity in risk assessment. Health
Communication, 20(3), 209-219.
Roubideaux, Y. (2011) American Indian/Alaska Native behavioral health briefing book. U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services.
www.ihs.gov/dbh/includes/themes/newihstheme/display_objects/documents/AIANBHBri
efingBook.pdf.
SAMHSA. (2022). Key substance use and mental health indicators in the United States: Results
from the 2021 National Survey on Drug Use and Health (HHS Publication No.
PEP22-07-01-005, NSDUH Series H-57). Center for Behavioral Health Statistics and
Quality, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration.
https://www.samhsa.gov/data/report/2021-nsduh-annual-national-report
SAMHSA. (2021). Health substance surveillance and program support. Substance Abuse and
Mental Health Services Administration.
https://www.samhsa.gov/sites/default/files/samhsa-fy-2022-bib.pdf
Sarason, I. G., & Sarason, B. R. (2009). Social support: Mapping the construct. Journal of Social
and Personal Relationships. 26, 113–120.
Schreurs, B., Van Emmerik, H., Notelaers, G., & De Witte, H. (2010). Job insecurity and
employee health: The buffering potential of job control and job self-efficacy. Work &
Stress, 24(1), 56-72
Schuchat, A., Houry, D., & Guy, G. P. (2017). New data on opioid use and prescribing in the
United States. Journal of the American Medical Association, 318(5), 425–426.
doi:10.1001/ jama.2017.8913
242
Schuckit, M. A. (2016). Treatment of opioid-use disorders. New England Journal of Medicine,
375(4), 357-368. doi:10.1056/NEJMra1604339
Skinstad, A. H. (2021). Prevention, Treatment, and Recovery Innovations in Native American
Communities. Native Center for Behavioral Health, College of Public Health, University
of Iowa.
Smith, L. (2012). Decolonizing methodologies: Research and indigenous peoples. Zed Books.
Smith, S. (2021). The socio-ecological model makes large-scale social change possible. Social
Impact Architects. https://socialimpactarchitects.com/social-ripple-effect/
Snyder, L. B., Hamilton, M. A., Mitchell, E. W., Kiwanuka-Tondo, J., Fleming-Milici, F., &
Proctor, D. (2004). A meta-analysis of the effect of mediated health communication
campaigns on behavior change in the United States. Journal of Health Communication,
9(S1), 71-96.
Soto, C., West, A., Unger, J., et al. (2019). Addressing the Opioid Crisis in American Indian &
Alaska Native Communities in California: A Statewide Needs Assessment.
Strauss, A., & Corbin, J. (1998). Basics of qualitative research techniques (2nd ed.). Sage
Publications.
Tofighi, B., Grossman, E., Bereket, S., & D. Lee, J. (2015). Text message content preferences to
improve buprenorphine maintenance treatment in primary care. Journal of Addictive
Diseases, 35(2), 92–100. doi:10.1080/10550887.2015.1127716
Truth Initiative, Office of National Drug Control Policy, & Ad Council. (2018). The Truth About
Opioids. https://www.thetruth.com/opioids
Turner, M. M., Skubisz, C., & Rimal, R. N. (2011). Theory and practice in risk communication:
A review of the literature and visions for the future. Thompson, T. L., Parrott, R., &
Nussbaum, J. F. The Routledge handbook of health communication. Routledge. (2nd ed),
174-192.
Venette, S. J. (2008). Best practices for communicating risk and crisis messages to the media:
Overcoming the constraints of message filtering. Paper presented at the Los Alamos
National Labs Risk Symposium – Effective risk communication: Tools, theory and
application, Santa Fe, NM.
Venner, K. L., Donovan, D. M., Campbell, A. N. C., Wendt, D. C., Rieckmann, T., Radin, S. M.,
Rosa, C. L. (2018). Future directions for medication assisted treatment for opioid use
disorder with American Indian/Alaska Natives. Addictive Behaviors, 86, 111–117.
doi:10.1016/j.addbeh.2018.05.0
Wakeman, S.E. (2019). Harm reduction approaches for opioid use disorder. in: kelly, j.,
wakeman, s. (eds) treating opioid addiction. Current Clinical Psychiatry. Humana, Cham.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-16257-3_8
Wilcox, B. L., & Vernberg, E. M. (1985). Conceptual and theoretical dilemmas facing social
support. I. G. Sarason & B.R. Sarason (Eds.), Social support: Theory, research and
applications Martinus Nijhoff, 3–20.
White, W. L., & Kelly, J. F. (2011). Recovery management: What if we really believed that
addiction was a chronic disorder? In: Kelly, J. F., & White, W. L. (eds.). Addiction
recovery management: Theory, research, and practice. New York, NY: Humana Press, pp.
67-84.
Witte, K. (1992). Putting the fear back into fear appeals: The extended parallel process model.
Communications Monographs, 59(4), 329–349. doi:10.1080/03637759209376276
243
Witte, K., & Allen, M. (2000). A meta-analysis of fear appeals: Implications for effective public
health campaigns. Health Education & Behavior, 27(5), 591–615. doi:10.1177/
109019810002700506
Yin, R. K. (2009). Case study research: Design and methods (4th ed.). Sage Publications.
244