'. RECOMMENDED S.ELLWOOD-MORELAND NE GHBOR 000 PLA Where are we in the Process?· Oct Nov Dec Jan • bed e f f I ·h 1998 j What do the leUers mean? a Start plan process (1993) g . Planning Commission Recommended Plan available ( October 6,1997 b Sept~mber Discussion Draft h Heari/flq bdoreCityCouncH November 5, 1997 c October DiscuSsion Draft i !\doption of Plan , SMILE- Adopled Plan j Plan becomes ~ffectlve d 11/6/96 -- Plan e 3/5/91---- Zoning 'f Hearing before Planning Commission -- June 24, 1997 and September 9, 1997 .. , City of Portland .Bureau of Planning Portland, Oregon October 1, 1997 SELLW99D M9RELl\ND NEIGMB9RM99D , Portland City Council Vera Katz, Mayor Jim Francesconi, Commissioner Charlie Hales, Commissioner Gretchen Kafoury, Commissioner Eric Sten, Commissioner Portland Planning Commission Richard Michaelson, President Steve Abel, Vice-President Sarah Hitch Bruce Fong Amanda Fritz Rick Holt Marcy MeIneUy Paul Schuback Ruth Scott Acknowledgments SMILE Board of Directors Lee Leighton, President; Kris Heiberg, VP; Eileen Fitzsimons, Secretary; Matt Hainley, Treasurer; Kevin Downing; Maureen Quinn; Margaret Branson; Gary Bley; Mark Perepelitza; Teresa Pucik; Kathleen Stokes; Alice Knudsen. Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan Steering Committee Kathleen Stokes, Co-Chair Lee Leighton, SMILE President, Co-Chair Tim Barnes Gary Bley Margaret Branson Howard Dietrich Eileen Fitzsimons John Fyre Leonard Gard Tracy and Deb Hanthorn Alice Knudsen Merrie (Schneider) Loboy Joanne McIntyre Victoria Martin Mark Perepelitza Michael Pucik Teresa Pucik Leslie Roman Martha Taylor Stephanie Tolliver John Underhill Gary Waite Nancy Walsh Gary Wilson Mary Beth Wilson Joe Nordling Thanks to the following: Sellwood School (for meeting space) Portland Bureau of Planning Charlie Hales, Commissioner-in-Charge David C. Knowles, Planning Director Deborah Stein, Principal Planner Michael S. Harrison, AICP, Chief Planner, Community and Neighborhood Planning Portland Office of Transportation Charlie Hales, Commissioner-in-Charge Felicia Trader, Director Victor F. Rhodes, City Engineer Don Gardner, Manager, Streets Systems Management Project Staff Mark Bello, Ph.D., AICP, City Planner Donah Baribeau, Clerical Specialist Leo D. Williams, AlA, Senior Planner (retired) Drawings and photos courtesy of Eileen Fitzsimons, Mark Perepelitza and Kathleen Stokes Neighborhood Plan Technical Advisory Committee David Sw~,et, Bureau of Buildings Steve Kenworthy, Bureau of Environmental Services James Crawford, Bureau of Fire and Emergency Services Rachel Jacky, Bureau of Fire and Emergency Services Patty Rueter, Bureau of Fire and Emergency Services Bob Weaver, Bureau of Fire and Emergency Services Diana Holuka, Bureau of General Services Judy Sanders, Bureau of Housing and Community Development John Sewell, Bureau of Parks and Recreation Jim Sjulin, Bureau of Parks and Recreation David Yamashita, Bureau of Parks and Recreation Mary Rose Navarro, Bureau of Parks and Recreation, Urban Forestry Division Roberta Jortner, Bureau of Water Barbara Duncan, Metro Mary Weber, Metro Jo Ann Bowman, Multnomah County Commissioner Dan Saltzman, Multnomah County Board of Commissioners Lt. Terry Jones, Multnomah County River Patrol Ben Meyer, National Marine Fisheries Service Don Gardner, Office of Transportation Kevin Hottman, Office of Transportation Monique Wahba, Office of Transportation Laurel Wentworth, Office of Transportation Brant Williams, Office of Transportation Fred Eberlee, Oregon Department of Transportation Sonya Kazen, Oregon Department of Transportation Jerry Hedrick, Oregon Division of State Lands Jim McFerrin, Pacific Power and Light Tim Hayford, Peninsula Drainage District #2 Capt. Dennis Merrill, Police Bureau Carol-Linda Cassin, Portland Development Commission Kerry Hampton, Portland Public Schools Dave Obern, State Marine Board Wayne Shuyler, State Marine Board Phil Colombo, Tri-Met Judy Linton, U.s. Corps of Engineers I. II. Table of Contents Introduction The Purpose of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan Plan Organization Background Settlement, Transportation and Architecture The History of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood SMILE Neighborhood Association The Planning Process for Developing the Neighborhood Plan Relationship to Other Plans, Regulations and Studies Portland Comprehensive Plan Willamette Greenway Plan Johnson Creek Basin Protection Plan Using the Comprehensive Plan and the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan in Land Use Reviews Page 1 2 3 6 13 13 18 21 III. Vision for the Neighborhood Vision Statement IV. Policies, Objectives & Action Charts 23 Neighborhood Character & Identity 29 Neighborhood Form/Urban Design 31 Community Identity 33 Neighborhood Subareas - - (Challenges & Desired Character) 35 River Edge Tacoma Pedestrian-Oriented Commercial Areas McLoughlin Edge Crystal Springs North End Residential Areas Environment & Greenspaces 79 Transportation 83 Community Services 85 Public Safety & Crime Prevention 89 V. Appendices A. Selected Population Information for Sellwood-Moreland B. Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan -- McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project List of Maps 1. Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood 2. Comprehensive Plan designations prior to adoption of new designations by City Council 3. Comprehensive Plan designations adopted by City Council, , 1997 Ordinance # _ • INTRODUCTION The Purpose of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan Residents began the neighborhood plan effort because of growing concerns about quality of life issues and the neighborhood's future. Topics such as regional population growth, planning efforts for south-north light rail in the McLoughlin corridor, possible replacement of the Sellwood Bridge, declining housing affordability, and impacts related to traffic all contributed to a desire to act. Sellwood-Moreland residents made a commitment to direct change in positive ways by developing a neighborhood plan. In addition to articulating the neighborhood's preferences for accommodating growth and redevelopment, this plan represents the neighborhood's position on issues that will affect its future. The plan's policies and objectives are based on the values that evolved from our community planning process. These values are: • To maintain the small-town character of the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood, by retaining its historic commercial buildings and houses. • To increase the vitality of commercial areas, encourage the provision of neighborhood services, and preserve the neighborhood's pedestrian scale and character. • To preserve the natural areas and greenspaces around and within the neighborhood, and to encourage residents to enjoy and enhance these abundant resources. • To ensure that the neighborhood is a safe place for all ages, with attractive public streets and parks that encourage community interaction. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 1 Plan Organization The Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan consists of several parts. They are the introduction; background; vision statement; neighborhood goals; policies, objectives and action charts; neighborhood advocacy agenda [not endorsed by the City]; and appendix. The vision statement, policies and objectives will be adopted by ordinance. The action charts will be adopted by resolution. Resolutions are advisory to decision- makers and do not have the force of law. Other portions of the plan will be used by the Sellwood-Moreland Improvement League (SMILE, the recognized neighborhood association) as part of its implementation efforts. The Introduction explains the purpose and organization of the neighborhood plan. The Background section describes the neighborhood, the neighborhood association and relationships to other plans or regulations. This material is for the reader's information. None of it will be adopted or made part of Portland's Comprehensive Plan. The Vision Statement contains the aspirations of the current residents of Sellwood- Moreland for the future. The vision provides a standard against which to measure the plan's success. Following the vision discussion is the goal. This goal ties the Sellwood- Moreland Plan to Portland's adopted Comprehensive Plan, making the plan and its five policies a part of the Comprehensive Plan. The vision and the goal are adopted as part of the Portland Comprehensive Plan by ordinance. Policies and Objectives provide guidance to decision-makers. They will be adopted as part of the Portland Comprehensive Plan by ordinance. This section addresses the following themes: neighborhood and subarea character and identity; the environment and greenspaces; transportation; community services; and public safety and crime prevention. Action Charts specify projects and programs that carry out Sellwood-Moreland policies and objectives. They are assigned a time frame and possible champion, or implementor, to carry them out. Action charts will be adopted by resolution, which means they do not have the force of law. The Appendix contains technical information such as abbreviations, historic inventories, census data, a glossary and a bibliography. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 2 • BACKGROUND Settlement, Transportation and Architecture Geography and transportation were the two factors most responsible for the development of Sellwood and, later, Westmoreland. The earliest settlement of Sellwood was adjacent to Willamette River transportation, and at Johnson Creek, which powered two early sawmills. As street railway transportation became available in the 1890s, homes and businesses were built in proximity to these routes. In the mid- 1920s, increased ownership of automobiles and the construction of the Ross Island and Sellwood Bridges boosted the development of Westmoreland. Golf Junction, Sf 13th Avenue between Linn and Ochoco Streets, circa 1920. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 3 Located three miles south of downtown Portland, the neighborhood is situated on the east bank of the Willamette River near the southern tip of Ross Island. According to its 1882 plat map, its original boundaries were the river (west), Ochoco (south), 19th Avenue (east), and Miller Street (north), However, when the City established the boundaries of the neighborhood in the 1970s, they were expanded to include Westmoreland, a primarily 1920s area which lies to the northeast of Sellwood. Official boundaries of this combined neighborhood are the Willamette River, Ochoco Street, and McLoughlin Boulevard to the north and east. Also included is 45-acre Garthwick, a 1920s era neighborhood, situated just south of Ochoco Street between SE 17th and 13th Avenues. Intersection of 13th and Tacoma (looking north on 13th), circa 1946. The neighborhood is currently pursuing an extension of neighborhood boundaries to include all of the east bank of the Willamette River and Ross Island. It should be noted that the small community of Willsburg was located just east of Sellwood, in the vicinity of present-day Tacoma Street and McLoughlin Boulevard. It was platted in 1869 and was 16 blocks in size. In 1848 George Wills arrived over the Oregon Trail and claimed 80 acres at Johnson Creek, on which he operated a saw mill. Willsburg was eventually a stop on the Oregon & California Railroad (later Southern Pacific), with its own post office, school and several homes, It was also the location of the Gabriel Shindler Furniture Company (1872-1896), and later the Oregon Worsted Company, Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 4 The neighborhood includes four public parks (Westmoreland, Sellwood, Sellwood Riverfront,. Johnson Creek), an elementary school (Llewellyn), a middle school (Sellwood), Oaks Amusement Park, the Oregon Yacht Club, Portland Rowing Club moorages, the Oaks Bottom wildlife area, a community center, Boys & Girls Club, a branch library, many churches, fratemallodges, a movie theater, and three business districts. The 1920s era Westmoreland business district stretches for several blocks along Milwaukie Avenue, with its center at Bybee Boulevard. It provides a mix of service- oriented businesses for local residents (grocery, hardware and variety stores, dry cleaners, sh.oe repair, two banks, medical and dental offices) and visitors (restaurants, antique shops). The business district in Sellwood, developed between the 1880s and early 1900s, extends along 13th Avenue with its center at Umatilla Street. Many of the older storefronts remain on 13th with the exception of a grocery store, laundromat, and several restaurants. Antique shops account for most of the businesses in the district. The neighborhood's third business district is situated on 17th Avenue near Tacoma Street. It includes restaurants and video stores, auto body and repair shops, insurance and law offices, a car wash, and a wooden fence and building painting business, among others. At the eastern margin of the district, between Spokane and Ochoco and McLoughlin and 23rd, there is a small area of light industry. Otherwise, the neighborhood remains primarily residential in character. Ferry John Caples crossing the Willamelte River, approaching landing in the vicinity of present day Staff Jennings. Lumber mill on the east bank is visible in the background, circa 1900. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 PageS The History of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood The earliest white settlers of record in the area arrived over the Oregon Trail in late 1847. In February 1848, Henderson Luelling (Llewellyn), his wife and nine children settled on five acres of slashed timber along the Willamette River. The land, which they had purchased from a man named Wilson, is now part of the south end of Waverley Country Club property. In March the Luellings were joined by their friend and fellow emigrant William Meek. The two men agreed to establish a commercial nursery with the stock brought over the Oregon Trail by Luelling. They also dammed Johnson Creek (at approximately Hwy. 224) and built a sawmill. The Luelling-Meek nursery business was a success and the partners soon began selling fruit trees. East side lumber mill, looking north from Sellwood Bridge, circa 1925. In May 1866, the Rev. John Sellwood purchased 321 acres from the Luelling heirs. Rev. Sellwood, in turn, sold this land to the Sellwood Real Estate Company in 1882. It was only after May 28, 1882, when the company filed incorporation papers, that the area carne to be known as "Sellwood." Although an Oregonian article of April 1887 stated that the Sellwood tract was "in a condition of nature" and was "virgin soil," settlement and building was already underway in the area. Before 1859, Arthur Miller "had charge of a 2 and a half acre apple orchard on the bluff overlooking The Oaks." By early 1877 the farm of P.J. Martin on the bluff above Ross Island was producing apples. There was also a settlement at Willsburg, where employment was available at Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 6 the Shindler Furniture Company. In any case, the Sellwood Real Estate Company began clearing the trees and selling house lots very quickly; by 1885 the population of Sellwood was put at 500. Early Sellwood (1848-1892) developed east from the banks of the Willamette River and near the Milwaukie Road. Transportation to and from the community was via the river by ferry, steamboat and launch. Passage was readily available to the Macadam Road and downtown Portland from landings at the foot of Umatilla and Spokane Streets. The riverbank was the site of many houseboats as well. Although there was good transportation in and out of Sellwood, it was a largely self-contained community for many years. Store on the sOl/tlleast comer of SE 13th Avenue and Tacoma Street, circa 1915. By April 1887, Sellwood had three stores, one church, a school and almost 100 homes. In 1890 it had two hotels, three shoemakers, two grocers, a blacksmith, bookbinder, bookkeeper, two saloons, a druggist, dressmaker and its own brewery. Many business owners lived above or behind their shops. Sellwood had no attorneys, architects, doctors, dentists, clothing stores or banks. Presumably residents took a boat, or later, a streetcar, to Milwaukie or Portland to obtain these goods and services. In the late 1880s and early 1890s new businesses were developed in Sellwood which provided employment to community residents. The Sorenson & Young Saw and Planing mill began operating at the foot of Spokane Street in 1885. It continued until 1900 when it became the East Side Lumber Mill, which lasted until the mid-1930s. South of the mill was a box factory and the Oregon Door Company, which manufactured doors, sash and moldings. At the foot of Marion Street was the Bissinger Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 7 & Company wool warehouse. Other jobs were available at Willsburg in the furniture factory. The Milwaukie Road (Milwaukie Avenue) laid out by Benjamin Stark and William Pettygrove in the mid-I840s, was used primarily as a wagon road until the early 1890s. By 1870 the Oregon & California Railroad (later Southern Pacific) was running steam trains on its tracks at the easternmost edge of Sellwood, with a stop at Willsburg. This provided transportation from Portland to Salem and beyond. • • Sellwood furniture store on the southeast corner of SE 13th Avenue and Tacoma Street, modernized by the Shaw Family (new owners), circa 1948. Although Sellwood had been well served by water transportation for almost 40 years, steam and electric street railways were being rapidly developed. One of the primary reasons for the sudden surge of population in Sellwood (from 800 in 1890 to 1,800 in 1893) was the arrival in 1892 of electric railway service. The first downtown bridge across the Willamette River opened in 1887. In May 1891, the City of Sellwood was granted a franchise to bring the East Side Railway Company line to the neighborhood. In spring of 1892, the company promised to extend its line to Sellwood if it were granted a "subsidy" by the city. The subsidy was raised and by June 5, 1892, the line was providing service as far as City View Park in time for the horse-racing season. By late 1892 the cars reached Milwaukie, and by January 1893, there was electric railway service all the way into Oregon City. A City Atlas, circa 1892, shows the Oregon Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 8 City Electric Motor Line going south on Milwaukie to Bybee, west on Bybee to 13th and south on 13th to Milwaukie and Oregon City. Faced with competition from the electric railways, steamboat service began to decline. However, until the opening of the Sellwood Bridge in 1925, a cable ferry continued to transport pedestrians and cars from the foot of Spokane Street to the west side of the Willamette River. The City of Sellwood was incorporated in early 1887 and its residents elected a five-man city council shortly thereafter. The all-volunteer, citizen government passed a variety of ordinances which dealt primarily with law and order issues such as intemperance, discharge of firearms, regulation of gambling and wandering animals. However, most of the council's attention was focused on establishing a volunteer fire department, locating a reliable source of drinking water and improving the public streets. Looking north on 5£ 13th Avenue, between Hamey and Umatilla 5treets, circa 1910. The latter task was elementary but time consuming. It required removing stumps and other obstacles from the streets, determining uniform widths for streets and sidewalks, grading the roads (east from the river) and building plank crosswalks and sidewalks. Between 1882 and 1895 the city grew rapidly. The demands for improvements were too great to be handled piecemeal by a volunteer governing body and in 1893, Sellwood was annexed to the City of Portland. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 9 Although the 1905 Lewis and Clark Fair was located at the other end of the city, preparations for that event did affect Sellwood. The Oregon Water Power & Railway Company (OWPR) established interurban electric railway service along the Willamette River through Oaks Bottom east to Lents in 1904. To encourage increased ridership OWPR constructed the Oaks Amusement Park in Sellwood, which opened in 1905. Another recreational attraction, although open to members only, was the Waverley Golf Club. Development of the course, just south of the Sellwood city limits at Ochoco Street, began jm 1899. The remains of the Luellings' fruit orchards were replaced with putting greens, and at least one, if not several, homes were moved from the golf course and relocated in Sellwood. The houses were some of the few that had been part of the Cambridge La.nd Company's attempted development of 1890. A stop on the streetcar line at SE 13th and Ochoco was known as Golf Links, or Golf Junction. Looking south on SE 13th Avenue at Tacoma Street, circa 1946. In 1905 a power substation for the electric railway lines was constructed at SE 13th near Linn. This intl~rsection marked the end of the electric car line which served Oregon City, Sellwood, Milwaukie, Mt. Scott, Waverley-Richmond and the Woodstock branches. On the east side of 13th are the large street-car barns constructed in 1910. In the same year a two-story brick clubhouse for the workers was built across the street from the car barns. To the south of these structures are several small rooming houses which served as housing for employees of the street-car line. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 10 The years immediately following the Lewis and Clark Fair, 1905 to 1913, were years of rapid expansion and growth in Portland, including Sellwood. Several important cultural and recreational institutions arrived in 1910: Sellwood Park was acquired by the City of Portland and its first public swimming pool opened; Portland's first branch of the YMCA and the first branch of the Portland Library Association opened. In the same year, the Sellwood Commercial Club built its headquarters, and in 1911 St. Agatha's Catholic School and chapel were constructed. The residential development of the area which began in Sellwood in the late 1880s now expanded to the Westmoreland area. In late 1909, the Westmoreland plat was carved out of William Ladd's 500-acre Crystal Springs farm. Westmoreland lay between Milwaukie Avenue and the Southern Pacific Railroad tracks, and Reedway and Miller Streets. The eastern edge of the farm, with the beginnings of the Reed Institute (Reed College) was developed as Eastmoreland, beginning in 1910. Because the two "Morelands" were not then separated by McLoughlin Boulevard, the golf course in between was used as a promotional device for both subdivisions. Sales of the 700 lots in Westmoreland began in early 1909 and ended in 1924. Toward the end of the IS-year sale period, the construction of the Sellwood and Ross Island Bridges was announced. Automobile owners realized they could reach Westmoreland quickly over these fixed-span bridges and the final 165 lots sold in less than two months. Also developed in the early 1900s along the river edge were the Oregon Yacht Club moorage, adjacent to and down river from the Oaks Amusement Park, and the Portland Rowing Club, upriver from the present-day Sellwood Bridge. The moorages were originally developed for their members to pursue yachting, rowing, and competitions. But the purpose of the clubs eventually changed to promote houseboat living (i.e. floating homes) with summer residences evolving quickly to become year- round residences at each moorage. The opening of the Sellwood Bridge in late 1925 and the Ross Island Bridge a year later marked the end of major development in the neighborhood until 1933-37 when McLoughlin Boulevard (Highway 99E) was constructed. This project encouraged increased traffic on 99E through Milwaukie and Oregon City, and also had the effect of completely dividing Westmoreland and Eastmoreland except via the Bybee Boulevard overpass (':onstructed in 1919). Before 1933, Reedway Street, at the northern end of Westmoreland, had served as an access street to the Reed College area. This connection was severed with the completion of McLoughlin Boulevard. The divisive effect of McLoughlin was increased again in the 1980s when it was widened to accommodate additional lanes. The 1925 Sellwood Bridge had been designed to feed traffic into the neighborhood. But after the 1950s, the bridge served as a conduit for traffic to the growing southeast Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 11 suburbs. Increased traffic on this bridge and Tacoma Street further divided the southern portion of Sellwood from the northern portion. In the late 1950s street-car service in the city ended. With the exception of a supermarket at 13th and Tacoma, most of the businesses that served Sellwood now shifted to Westmoreland, one mile to the north. Residents were now dependent upon automobiles for shopping and traveling to jobs. The Depression brought quiet times to the neighborhood. The East Side Lumber Mill closed in the mid-1930s. The mill in Willsburg, which had begun as a mohair factory in 1902, was rebuilt as the Oregon Worsted Company in 1918. It later expanded and became the Mill Ends Store (now Goodwill). After World War II, both a Safeway store and a Kienow's were built on Milwaukie Avenue. Following World War II, development increased in the neighborhood. Many new single-family homes were built, primarily in Westmoreland. Sellwood saw the construction of many one- and two-story, flat-roofed apartment buildings in the 1960s and 1970s. In 1961 the neighborhood's only National Register building, the Oaks Pioneer Church, arrived from Milwaukie. In the 1980s, many of Sellwood's colorful houseboats were forced to leave as new condominiums were constructed on the riverbank, south of the Sellwood Bridge. Remaining houseboats (floating homes) are at the neighborhood's original moorage, Oregon Yacht Club, with its gated enclave just north of Oaks Amusement Park; and at the Portland Rowing Club just south of the Sellwood Bridge, which includes houseboats, covered boats, and rowing facilities. The riverbank, formerly an area of industry and transportation, is now used for river view housing and public recreation. Situated south of the Sellwood Bridge are several apartment/condominium complexes, and the Portland Rowing Club moorage. North of the bridge are a restaurant, a boat launching area, an office building, a public park and dock, a stretch of public beach, the Oaks Amusement Park and the Oregon Yacht Club moorage. The Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood continues to have an interesting mix of houseboats, tiny worker's cottages, boarding houses, two-story multiplexes, late Victorian vernacular farmhouses, four-squares, English Arts & Crafts houses, bungalows, and houses from the 1920s to 1940s in a variety of styles, as well as contemporary ranch-style houses, apartment buildings, and rowhouses. It also contains two high-rise buildings: Westmoreland's Union Manor near Bybee and McLoughlin Boulevard, and the Sellwood Center at SE 17th and Tenino. Until quite recently, many homes have been single-owner occupied since their original construction. Due to its proximity to downtown Portland and improved bus service in the 1970s, the neighborhood has seen increased popularity as a residential area. Many homeowners are adding on to or remodeling their older houses. Residential infill development is also occurring. Some of the newer structures tend to be "suburban" in character and exhibit little architectural compatibility with their older neighbors. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 12 SMILE Neighborhood Association Early Days In the early 1960s, Dent Thomas, a Sellwood businessman, became concerned about the lack of citizen involvement in the community. Mr. Thomas felt that the neighborhood spirit was lacking. Letters were sent to the Sellwood Community Club, Westmoreland Community Club, the Masonic Lodge and others. At the resulting meeting, Howard Traver suggested naming the new organization the Sellwood-Moreland Improvement League (SMILE). 1980 Comprehensive Plan In 1980 the City of Portland looked at zoning citywide as part of a new Comprehensive Plan. Three alternatives were proposed by city planners. A fourth alternative was proposed by citizens. The zoning has remained generally unchanged from that era. The Planning Process for Developing the Neighborhood Plan The SMILE Neighborhood Association began the planning process early in 1993, with a call for volunteers to serve on the steering committee. After several meetings to discuss the way to proceed with creating a plan, the group decided to create a short questionnaire that would let neighbors describe what they valued about the neighborhood, that needed improvement, and what issues should be addressed in the planning process. A three-part questionnaire was used, over a six to eight month period, in a series of opportunities for visioning. A total of roughly 200 residents and property or business owners responded. There was little variation in response. The first part of the questionnaire asked, "What places or things best represent your image of the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood?" The most frequent responses were: • small town character • pedestrian orientation • old houses and commercial buildings (historic) • parks/green spaces/natural areas/the river • friendly character/safe & walkable • vitality / diversity of business districts The second part asked, "What do you like the least about Sellwood-Moreland?" The most frequent responses were: • traffic (speeding/cut through/congestion) • crime/ graffiti • rundown houses/infill houses Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 13 The third question was, "What are the most important things to include in a neighborhood plan for Sellwood-Moreland?" The most frequent responses were: • how to preserve small town character / good things about Sellwood- Moreland • traffic problems and pedestrian safety • Sellwood Bridge • high-capacity transit (light rail is anticipated in the McLoughlin corridor) • how to deal with population growth • how to protect green spaces In the fall of 1993, the neighborhood decided to organize a workshop and enlisted help from the City of Portland Planning Bureau. Bureau planners helped the neighborhood to organize it~; first workshop. Colleen Acres worked with the steering committee in an unofficial capacity. Six policy areas were identified from the visioning results and the workshop was structured around these areas: • history • land use/zoning/design • environment and greenspaces • traffic and transportation • community services • pub:lic safety and crime prevention At the same time, an individual recruiting effort was launched. The steering committee membership was boosted to about 20, including several members of the business community, and subcommittees were formed around the policy areas. Over 50 people attended the February 1994 workshop and expanded on issues in the policy areas. Following the workshop, the subcommittees investigated the issues in each policy area and then submitted drafts to the steering committee for comment and review. These drafts were compiled and edited to create the discussion draft that was reviewed in follow-up workshops in January and February of 1995. In July of 1995, the Bureau of Planning assigned a staff planner to work half-time with the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood to help with completion of the plan. The Bureau's staff has helped with technical advice in preparing the discussion draft, organizing workshops and providing an evaluation to the Planning Commission. The comments received during the workshop were used to edit the discussion draft. At the same time, the Neighborhood Plan Steering Committee worked to prepare a Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 14 neighborhood rezoning proposal to accompany the plan in the hope of seeing aspects of the plan implemented quickly. January/February 1996 Workshop Beginning July 20, 1996, the committee held a series of eight open house workshops: July 20 July 24 August 4 August 17 August 24 August 28 September 7 September 11 Westmoreland Union Manor Sellwood Community Center Sellwood Park ("Sundae in the Park") Sellwood Baptist Church Tenth Church of Christ, Scientist Moreland Presbyterian Church Sellwood Center SMILE Station Also, a presentation was made to the Sellwood-Moreland Business Association (SMBA) at their regular membership meeting on September 26, 1996. Postcards were mailed to all postal addresses in the neighborhood on the following dates: September 1996 February 1997 June 1997 October 2,1996 Town Hall Meeting Announcement Zoning Proposal Vote Announcement Planning Commission Hearing Announcement Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 15 Janllary/Febrllary 1996 Workshop The proposed draft plan and rezoning proposal were presented at the SMILE general membership meeting on October 2, 1996. The proposed plan and rezoning were discussed in an open, "town hall" meeting format. The draft plan was approved at the next SMILE general meeting on November 6, 1996. Following further workshops at the SMILE Station on February 15 and February 22, 1997, the rezoning map was approved at the SMILE general meeting on March 5, 1997. On June 24, 1997, the Planning Commission heard public testimony on the neighborhood's proposed plan. On September 9, 1997, the Planning Commission reviewed an Amendments Report and held a work session on the proposed plan. At that meeting the Planning Commission approved the Proposed Sellwood-Moreland Plan with few changes and forwarded it to the City Council. The Planning Commission unanimously recommended that the City Council adopt the plan as part of Portland's Comprehensive Plan and implement the plan through the rezoning of the neighborhood. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 16 January/Febrllary 1996 Workshop This document is the Planning Commission's Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan. The City Council will hold a public hearing on the Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan on Wednesday, November 5 at 2:00 p.m. The hearing will be held in the Portland Building Auditorium, 1120 SW Fifth Avenue. Copies of the Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan will be available on October 6, 1997, at the Bureau of Planning, 1120 SW Fifth Avenue, 10th floor. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 17 Relationship to Other Plans, Regulations, and Studies Portland Comprehensive Plan The Portland Comprehensive Plan provides the citywide policy framework for the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan. The Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan provisions focus on neighborhood-specific concerns, issues and opportunities. Policy 3.6 of the Portland Comprehensive Plan calls for the City to: Maintain and enforce neighborhood plans that are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and that have been adopted by City Council. The Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan goal, vision statement, policies, and objectives will be adopted as part of the City of Portland's Comprehensive Plan under Policy 3. (Neighborhood Plan). As part of the Comprehensive Plan, it is assured that the policies and objectives of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan will be considered when Comprehensive Plan designations and conditional use proposals are reviewed by the City. The Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan is made part of the Portland Comprehensive Plan by the addition of this linking statement and addition of the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan to the list of adopted neighborhood plans in Policy 3.6 (Neighborhood Plan): Goal Retain and enhance Sellwood-Moreland's neighborhood character as an urban village, with a rich mixture of land uses, a variety of housing types with a range of affordable housing, recreational opportunities, and transportation alternatives. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 18 Willamette River Greenway and Willamette River Greenway Plan The Willamette River serves as an important fish production and harvest area. The river and adjacent riparian habitat provide food, shelter, and cover for a wide variety of wildlife. They also are a significant recreational resource providing the citizens of Oregon with a range of recreational opportunities, including swimming, boating, sailing, fishing, and scenic enjoyment. The river and riverbank are also extremely valuable economic resources. The Willamette River plays a critical role in the state's economy, in terms of supporting agriculture, major shipping activities, aggregate mining, and other river-dependent and river-related industries. The Oregon Legislature developed Statewide Planning Goal 15, "Willamette River Greenway," which requires local governments to develop plans for the lands adjacent to the river which address a number of elements. To implement this statewide goal locally, the City of Portland adopted a Willamette Greenway Plan in 1979 and updated this in 198'7. The Willamette Greenway Plan is intended to guide the protection, conservation, maintenance, and enhancement of scenic, natural, historical, economic, and recreational qualities of lands along the Willamette River. The Wil/amette Greenway Plan includes a concept map which indicates several use emphases along Sellwood-Moreland's banks, corresponding approximately to the uses found along the river today: • • • Natural area emphasis along Oaks Bottom Recreational use emphasis at the locations of existing moorages Mixed use development emphasis in several locations south of Oaks Bottom The plan indicates a greenway trail along the edge of the bank through Sellwood- Moreland along with several access paths and river viewpoints. The plan also includes a set of de5ign guidelines for development occurring within Willamette Greenway boundaries. Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge Coordinated Resource Management Plan The Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge is located within Sellwood-Moreland's portion of the Willamette River Greenway. The refuge is a 160-acre City of Portland park, and is predominantly a floodplain wetland system consisting of several vegetation communities. The City of Portland acquired most of the park in the late 1950s. In 1968, Portland placed a number of restrictions on the development of the site and purchased the remainder of Oaks Bottom. In 1988 the City of Portland adopted the Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge Coordinated Resource Management Plan. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 19 Johnson Creek Basin Protection Plan and Johnson Creek Plan District The Johnson Creek Basin is an expansive watershed including significant fish and wildlife habitats, ecologically and scientifically significant natural areas, open spaces, water bodies, and wetlands. The watershed includes most of Sellwood-Moreland east of 13th Avenue and stretches east to Gresham, north beyond Burnside, and south into Clackamas County. Johnson Creek is the primary waterway of the basin, flowing westward nearly 20 miles, through the cities of Gresham; Portland, and Milwaukie. In Sellwood-Moreland, Johnson Creek flows southwest along McLoughlin Boulevard. Crystal Springs emerges from the spring-fed Reed Lake on the Reed College Campus and follows a southwesterly path through Crystal Springs Rhododendron Garden and Westmoreland Park. Crystal Springs meets Johnson Creek at the southeast corner of Sellwood- Moreland just south of Tacoma. The inhabitants of much of Portland's eastside are dependent on the basin's waterways for drainage of stormwater run-off; and plants, animals, and humans are dependent on the quality of the water and the surrounding riparian areas for their health. The lands adjacent to Johnson Creek and Crystal Springs are prone to seasonal flooding, a condition exacerbated by an increase in impervious surface, coupled with the removal of native vegetation. Sellwood-Moreland east of 21st Avenue is within the 100-year floodplain as defined by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). Much of Sellwood-Moreland inside the floodplain is currently held publicly as open space (Westmoreland Park); however, between Nehalem and Sherrett, the land within the Johnson Creek Basin Plan District is in current residential, employment and commercial use. In order to protect the important resources of the basin, the City of Portland adopted the Johnson Creek Basin Protection Plan in 1991. The Johnson Creek Basin Plan District was created to regulate the development of individual sites within the basin. The Johnson Creek Basin Plan District includes most of Sellwood-Moreland east of SE 21st. All general development standards of the plan district apply to this portion of Sellwood-Moreland. These standards prohibit structures within the Johnson Creek floodway and regulate the amount of run-off to the creek. The Johnson Creek Basin Plan District development standards also allow for transfer of development rights within the plan district and for density bonuses in certain locations. Because no part of Sellwood-Moreland is contained within either the Johnson Creek floodplain subdistrict or the south subdistrict, portions of Sellwood-Moreland sites within the Johnson Creek Basin Plan District that are outside of "c" and "p" overlay zones would be eligible to receive transferred development rights as well as density bonuses. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 20 Using the Comprehensive Plan and the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan in Lmd Use Reviews The Comprehensive Plan and neighborhood plans serve several purposes. Each plan is a statement of desired character. In addition, the plans may be used in certain land use reviews. Some land use reviews-such as conditional uses for institutions in residential zones-require that the proposal be consistent with neighborhood plans. Some land use reviews also require that the proposal be consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Where a land use review requires a proposal to be consistent with a plan, we look at certain aspects. Each plan contains a set of elements that should be considered and balanced, some requirements that must be met, and some that are guidelines but not required. Each goal and policy of the Comprehensive Plan and of this plan are designated as mandatory, balancing, or aspirational. All of the goals and policies of the Sellwood-A1oreland Neighborhood Plan are balancing goals and policies. Mandatory policies are required elements. They must be followed and met, and exceptions are not allowed. Mandatory policies are usually specific statements that include a dear directive. There are only a few mandatory policies in the Portland Comprehensive Plan. Balancing policies must be considered, but, rather than being rigid requirements, they are carefully weighed and balanced with other balancing policies. Decisions are made based on the cumulative weight of policy language and direction. A specific action may be approved even if it is not consistent with every applicable policy; the action may be approved if it is supported, on balance, by the greatest body of balancing policies. Most policies in the Comprehensive Plan, and all of those in neighborhood plans, are balancing policies. They must be considered, but do not have to be individually met. Aspirational policies express a public desire, but are guidelines only. They do not have to be considered, but may be used to help understand an area or issue, to develop more detailed policy, or to guide a neighborhood in creating an action plan. They are not binding on the City, property owners, or neighbors. Because all of the goals and policies of Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan are balancing policies, they must all be considered against each other and weighed with the balancing policies of the Comprehensive Plan. They must all be considered, but do not have to be individually met. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 21 •VISION FOR THE NEIGHBORHOOD Vision Statement The following is a statement of what the Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan intends the neighborhood to be like in the future, based on the concepts and policies set forth in this plan. Sellwood-Moreland is a significant part of the City of Portland, with one of the oldest and strongest neighborhood associations (SMILE) and a prominent position as a southern gateway into the city. Still, residents also see themselves as a distinct community whole unto itself. The sense of community is demonstrated by the care that people have taken to preserve the neighborhood's unique green spaces, its vintage business centers, and quality housing stock. While there is easy access to downtown Portland, OMSI, Lloyd Center and the suburban east side, many prefer to telecommute from their homes. The pedestrian and bicycle- friendly streets make it inviting to tend to shopping and errands in the neighborhood. Recreational opportunities are available for everyone, from grandparents to toddlers. A quick escape to nature is only moments away or often just outside the window. The river edge is an active corridor for a mix of residential, commercial and recreational uses, all co-existing with an improved habitat for fish, waterfowl and other wildlife. Tacoma Street, formerly a gritty and dismal barrier that divided the neighborhood, now is like a seam that draws it together. The higher density (two- to three-story) housing, interspersed with small-scale retail commercial development has re-energized the area .. The street trees, planting strips, on-street parking and wider sidewalks create a safe and vital pedestrian atmosphere. The restaurant, pub and retail outlets at the bridgehead link Tacoma Street to riverfront activity. The new two-lane bridge with its bicycle and pedestrian walks and viewing turnouts is a favorite place for weekend strolls or morning bicycle commuters. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 23 The neighborhood has retained three pedestrian-oriented commercial centers, each with a unique identity. Milwaukie Avenue has retained an interesting mix of businesses, many of them serving the needs of local residents, so that it functions as a small town main street. Seventeenth Avenue properties have been renovated and more businesses have located there. The street edge has been redefined at a pedestrian scale of development. Shops that serve various remodeling and decorating needs are mixed with stores that serve the needs of local residents in the south end of the neighborhood and the north end of the City of Milwaukie. Thirteenth Avenue's Antique Row is still going strong and its reputation continues to grow. The street's appearance has been improved by compatible infill and by the addition of street furniture, decorative paving, and the placement of baskets of annual flowers. McLoughlin's role as a transportation corridor has been expanded with the addition of local high-capacity transit and high-speed rail between San Francisco and Seattle. The development along the edge is now a mix of general commercial retail with some high- density residential development. Long-time neighborhood commercial outlets, such as Bob's Rental, still serve the neighborhood's needs. The edge gives strong definition to the neighborhood, but links over the roadway allowing pedestrians and bicyclists to cross to the high-capacity transit stations, Crystal Springs Lake and the Springwater Corridor. Crystal Springs district is a highly sought-after residential area. Crystal Springs Creek is an amenity that is treasured by the whole neighborhood. The 21st Avenue bikeway is a favorite walk or ride for both children and adults. The restored health of the Crystal Springs and Johnson Creek streambeds and the links to the Springwater Corridor and Willamette Greenway have invited more wildlife into the corridor. Even in the high density residential portion of Willsburg, the creek is shared with ducks, frogs and other wildlife. The North End has redeveloped with new amenities that make it an inviting urban scale mini-neighborhood. The pocket park, community garden and the north edge of Oaks Bottom, with access to the Willamette Greenway trail, provide natural getaways at the doorstep of the four- to five-story residential buildings. Landscaping and courtyards make these units attractive to residents, many who ride high-capacity transit, available nearby. Shops along Milwaukie Avenue and McLoughlin, as well as the complex at the old Vocational Village site, offer convenient services for residents in the area. Westmoreland, City View, Sellwood and Garthwick remain much the same with the historic housing stock constantly improved through restoration and renovation. The occasional infill housing is compatible with the older housing that surrounds it, blending in comfortably with the neighborhood. Many residents have added accessory rental units in their basements or above their garages, to augment their retirement income or provide a place for aging parents. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighbor/wad Plan October 1, 1997 Page 24 As before, the SMILE Station serves as a community hub for all types of civic activities. The local newspaper, The Bee, has relocated its offices in the neighborhood and serves as a popular communication vehicle. The community policing station, neighborhood watch program, and neighborhood foot and bicycle patrols have all worked together to curb property crimes and to keep the streets safe. Neighbors are proud of their active community and conscious of its identity. They work hard to support neighborhood efforts and. to maintain their community's image. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 25 •POLICIES, OBJECTIVES & ACTIONS Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 27 :NEIGHBORHOOD CHARACTER & IDENTITY The separate eras represented by the different parts of the neighborhood reflect the development patterns that occurred from the 1880s to the 1940s. Sellwood and the Willsburg area, in the southeast corner of the neighborhood, and parts of the North End, are the oldest areas. These areas were developed before the turn of the century. Garthwick and Westmoreland were developed much later, primarily in the 1920s. Overall, 61 percent of the housing in the neighborhood was built prior to World War II. The scale and variety of architecture is considered a positive characteristic of the neighborhood that residents wish to preserve. Policy I: Historic Preservation Protect historic resources. Preserve the historic character of neighborhood areas recognized in this plan. Objectives: 1. Increas'2 public awareness of neighborhood history 2. Recognize and conserve historic resources and structures 3. Respect the character of Sellwood-Moreland by sensitively integrating new development with the historic elements of the community Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 29 Action Chart: Historical Character Time # Actions PROJECTS/ PROGRAMS Adopt On- ith Plan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs HC 1 HC 2 HC3 HC4 HC5 HC6 HC 7 HC& Identify the structures and sites that are of the greatest historic significance to the neighborhood. Consider creating historic conservat.ion districts in the North End. Sellwood. and Garthwlck. Adopt deSign guidelines to protect the spwal character of each of the three districts. Commemorate sites of historic interest wlLh signs. Develop historic walking tours of the North End. Sellwood, and Garthwick. Organize SMILE's historic photo collection. Display photos from the SMILE collection in public places. Commemorau: the town of Willsburg by creating a Wdlsburg Station on the south/north high-capaCity tranSit comdor, south of racoma on McLoughlin Blvd. ProVide historiC infonmation on Willsburg. SMILE Planning SMILE Planning Planning SMILE 5MBA SMILE SMILE SMILE 5MBA SMILE NOTE: Action Charts were approved by Portland City Council by resolution, They are a starting place. All actions have an Identified Implementor. They were adopted With the understanding that some will need to be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible proposals. Identification of an implementor for an actwn is.an expression of interest and support with the understanding that circumstances will affect the implernent.ation le.ader's ability to take action. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 30 NEIGHBORHOOD FORM/ URBAN DESIGN The neighborhood is formed, as an entity, from various physical elements. These elements help to create the image that people carry of the area as a distinct place. The elements include edges, gateways, paths, nodes, and landmarks or focal points. The Willamette River forms one edge to the neighborhood; McLoughlin Boulevard forms another. An example of a gateway is the Sellwood Bridge. Paths may be natural such as those in Oaks Bottom, or a path may be a well-traveled sidewalk, perhaps along SE Milwaukie in Westmoreland. The intersection of SE Milwaukie and SE Bybee in Westmoreland is an example of a node; that is, the activity center of the Milwaukie Avenue business district. Buildings or objects such as the clock in Westmoreland are landmarks. All of these aspects contribute to a "sense of place." Good use of urban design principles makes all the pieces of the urban scene fit together in a way that is comfortable, but interesting. People want to come back again and again. Policy II: Sense of Place Reinforce a distinctive sense of place by emphasizing neighborhood boundaries, connections, business districts, public open spaces, and focal points. Objectives: 1. Make neighborhood edges an integral part of the community 2. Identify and strengthen neighborhood gateways 3. Promote development at key nodes that reinforces the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood as a pedestrian-oriented, self-sufficient "village" 4. Establish focal points within each business district 5. Enhance the neighborhood's established character as a mixed-use village, emphasizing residential areas surrounding a number of business districts, orientation to public transit and a healthy pedestrian environment Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October I, 1997 Page 31 Action Chart: Neighborhood Form/Urban Design Time # Actions FROJECfS/ FROGRAMS Adopt; On- it;h Plan going Next; 6 w Implemenwrs 5 Yrs 20 Yrs NF 1 Consider linking high-capacit;y uan"it; W t;he neighborhood and SpringwaurCor-idor at; Willsburg/Sellwood swp by means d a pedesUian/bike crossing over McLoughlin Blvd. NF 2 Ident;lfy rouus for pedest;"an and bicycle pathways NF 3 Attract new nelghborhood-oriente.~ service businesses and housing at; ident;ifled nodes (13t;h and Tacoma, lhh and Tacoma. Milwaukie and Bybee, new Mcloughlin uansit; st;at;ion loc.,t;ions). NF4 Require new consuuct;ion In t;he RH and Rl zones W be subject to design reView, NF5 On an interim basis. require neo.v cor,struction in the R2 and R2.5 zones to be subject to deSign review. Reconsid~~r appolicabili-cy of c.:tesign review overlay zoning after the City adopts new d!~slgn-onented base zone regulations. ODOT Met;ro Parks PDOT Met;ro SMILE 5MBA BOP BOP NOTE: Act;ion Charts were approved by Porland C,t;y Council by resolut;ion. They are a st;arting place. All act;ions have an ident;ified Implemenwr. They were adopud with the understanding that; some will need W be adJusud and others replaced with more feaSible proposals. Identlfrcatlon of an Implementor for an action is an expression of interest and support with the understanding that cjrcurnstances will affect the implementation leader's ability to take action. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plall October 1, 1997 Page 32 COMMUNITY IDENTITY Fostering a sense of community identity ensures that residents will take pride in their neighborhood and recognize that they are a part of a greater whole. Sellwood- Moreland's vision statement describes the neighborhood's identity. Sellwood-Moreland's neighborhood character is best described as an urban village, with a rich mixture of land uses; a variety of housing types with a range of affordable housing; recreational opportunities; and transportation alternatives. Policy 1II: Community Livability Strengthen the sense of community and neighborhood identity. Objectives: 1. Acknowledge and celebrate the heritage of the neighborhood 2. Communicate news of neighborhood activities and get more people involved in the SMILE Neighborhood Association 3. Build on the potential of parks, open spaces and streets as shared public spaces to strengthen the coherence and unity of the neighborhood Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 33 Action Chart: Community Identity Time # Actions PROJECTS/ PROGRAMS Adopt On- ith Plan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs Cll CI 2 CI3 Adopt a symbol and use it at gateways. on street signs. commercial areas, historic homes. etc. Continue to sponsor community activities. Develop an urban design plan to provide neighborhood continuity on the major streets including elements such as street Signs. light standards. paving patterns. canopy street trees. hanging flower baskets and other plantings. SMILE SMILE SMILE NOTE: Action Charts were approved by Portland City Council by resolution. They are a starting place. All actions have an identified Implementor. They were adopted with the understanding that some will need to be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible proposals. Identification of an implementor for an action is an expression of interest and support with the understanding that circumstances will affect the implementation leader's ability to take action. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 34 NEIGHBORHOOD SUBAREAS The Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood is comprised of unique areas, each of which is described in the pages that follow. Challenges and opportunities are highlighted for the reader. The plan's proposed policies and action items respond to these challenges and opportunities. Policy IV: Subareas Recognize and reinforce distinct neighborhood subareas, considering their unique strengths, character, challenges, and opportunities. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 35 RIVER EDGE The parks and natural resource areas that are so abundant in the neighborhood help to shape the community and to define its character. The Willamette River and greenway zone form the western boundary of the neighborhood. Layered in along the river are Sellwood Riverfront Park, Sellwood Park, the park-like areas of Oaks Amusement Park, moorages on the river, and Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge. Adjacent to the north end of the neighborhood in the Willamette River lie Ross Island, Hardtack Island, and East Island. The Willame!te River - looking southwest from Sellwood Riverfront Park. Sellwood-Moreland has a unique relationship with the Willamette River edge. Only in St. Johns and in downtown Portland is there equivalent opportunity for access to the water at the same grade level. In Sellwood-Moreland, a large portion of the river shore is dedicated to public open space. Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge is home to beaver, otters, great blue herons and bald eagles. Residential uses, including houseboats (floating homes), extend up to these open spaces north of Tacoma Street and the Sellwood Bridge, and occur again at the Oregon Yacht Club moorage north of Oaks Amusement Park. On the south, condominiums and private moorages occupy the edge all the way to Waverley Golf Course. South of the bridge, public access is physically limited. The Willamette Greenway designation protects the right to public access and is intended to lead to eventual Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 37 development of a pedestrian trail along the river, connecting Sellwood to Milwaukie and to downtown Portland. The Samtrack passenger train service currently connects from a terminus near the Sellwood Bridge to OMSI on weekends during the summer months. Existing partial Willamelte Greenway Trail, looking north from the former Anchorage Restaurant. The challenges facing the neighborhood in the river edge district are: • Creating physical and visual links between the residential and commercial portions of the neighborhood and the riverfront • Finding ways to implement the Greenway Trail • Protecting natural areas from pressures for development • Creating greater appreciation for the natural processes of the river and riparian areas • Recognizing residential moorages (with floating homes, i.e. houseboats) as unique pocket communities that contribute to the historical and unique character of the neighborhood Desired Character The river edge should have a variety of public spaces which accommodate active and passive recreational opportunities and commercial enterprises that respect the unique attribute offered by the river. The wildlife habitat values should be preserved and Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 38 enhanced, with the Oaks Bottom, Hardtack, Ross Island and related islands treated as one ecosystem with strict environmental regulations to protect its fragile condition. Housing and business along the river edge should be compatible with the natural character of the area, in use, in form and in style. They should avoid negative impacts to the environment, reinforce community access to the river edge, and contribute to development of the greenway trail. They should preserve views of the river from vantage points such as Sellwood Riverfront Park, Sellwood Park, Sellwood Boulevard, the Sellwood Bridge, Oaks Bottom, the north entrance to the neighborhood on SE Milwaukie Avenue, and Oaks Park. Condominiums and floating homes south of the Sellwood Bridge. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 39 Policy V: The River's Edge Make the river edges integral to the community. Objectives: 1. Strengthen and create connections between the neighborhood and the river 2. Protect Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge from any development which threatens to diminish its capacity to support a variety of native species 3. Preserve views from the Sellwood Bridge to the river, the hills to the west, and downtown Portland in any Sellwood Bridge renovation or replacement 4. Strengthen the role of the Sellwood Bridge as a neighborhood gateway 5. Use the public areas near the river's edge to help unify and create an identity for the neighborhood 6. Pursue and support commercial activity at the bridgehead that is compatible with river edge resources, and will link commercial and residential areas on Tacoma with the residential and recreational areas below at the water's edge Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 40 Action Chart: River's Edge Time # Actions Adopt On- ith Plan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs PROJECTS/PROGRAM S Increase access to the river edge ... RE 1 ... by I:: re.:1tlng a stronger physical connection Parks between upper Sellwood Park and Riverfront Park. RE 2 ... by creating a link between the Springwater Parks Corridor and the Willamette River Greenway, PDOT possibly using the proposed bikeways along Spokane and Umatilla Streets. RE3 .,. by connecting the Springwater Corridor to.a Parks pedestrian and bicycle trail running parallel to the Portland Traction Company railway. RE4 ... by Installing uniform signs to denote pathways. Parks RE 5 ... by Implementing the Willamette River Greenway SMILE Plan. 5MBA RE6 ... by oooperating with bUSiness and property SMILE owner-s to develop a waterfront loop trail from the 5MBA foot of Linn to Spokane, to 13th. to Ochoco Streets. RE 7 ... by placing interpretive signs and benches at view SMILE point.s along the waterfront trail. 5MBA RE8 Attr,:;lct more pedestnan-orlented uses at "the river SMILE edge south of Spokane Street. RE 9 Crealoe linkages between the Willamette River and Parks other natural resource areas such as the histonc Metro Portland Traction Co. Corridor with natural plan1;ings. RE10 Encourage development of compatible commercial SMILE activity in the residential area south of the bridge. RE 11 Draw river edge residents into the larger SMILE neighborhood. Pursue reSidential development that 5MBA links existing residential areas on the river edge to the "djacent neighborhood. RE12 Deve'Op a master plan for conserving significant- Parks views Within Parks' jurisdiction. Planning RE13 PrOVide viewing areas and benches along the river's SMILE edge. 5MBA RE 14 Increase awareness and stewardship of natural SMILE areas by sponsoring field trips to Oaks Bottom. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October I, 1997 Page 41 Time # Actions PROJECTS/PROGRAMS Increase awareness and stewardship of natural areas... Adopt On- ith Plan ~oin~ Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yes RE 15 ... by seekin~ sponsors and organizers to create a youth corps to help maintain trails RE 16 ... by organizing efforts to remove litter and discourage dumping. RE 17 ... by encouraging neighborhood foot patrols to include parks and natural areas during months of heavy usage. RE 18 ... by using signs in public spaces to explain plants and ot.her features of native habitats. RE 19 Update the Oaks Bottom Wildlife Refuge Management Plan which includes management poliCies for Oaks Bottom and other adjacent riverfront habitat areas. Include a wildlife interpretive center. RE 20 AcqUire woodland between Riverfront Park and Oaks Pank for a publiC green space. RE 21 Promote the use of native plants and elements of wildlife habitat in future development and reh.abilitatlon projects. RE 22 Use trees and landscaping to Incorporate natural elements into pedestrian zones and bike paths. "SMILE SMILE SMILE SMILE Parks BES Metro Panks BES Panks NOTE: Action Charts were approved by Portland City Council by resolution. They are a st;artlng place. All actions have an identified Implementor. They were adopted with the understanding that some Will need to be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible proposals. Identification of an implementor for an action is an expression of interest and support With the understanding that CIrcumstances will affect the implementation leader's ability to take action. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 42 TACOMA STREET Tacoma Street plays an important role by connecting the neighborhood to the river and other parts of the city and region. The two ends of Tacoma Street are major entrances to the neighborhood that could be developed as gateways. Western gateway to the neighborhood--the bridgehead looking east on Tacoma Street. Unfortunately, Tacoma Street currently serves as a regional thoroughfare which carries traffic from Clackamas County through the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood, and across the river to points in Clackamas and Washington Counties or southwest Portland. Parking has been largely eliminated, creating four narrow traffic lanes, which narrow to two, creating a bottleneck at the Sellwood Bridge. Sidewalks are narrow and lack a parking strip or parked cars to serve as a buffer. The environment is hostile, and unsafe for pedestrians of all ages. Crossing the street is difficult due to the high traffic volumes and speeds. No signalized crosswalks exist west of 13th Avenue or east of 17th. Tacoma Street has been identified by residents as the number one problem in the neighborhood. Land use along Tacoma Street remains predominantly residential, with commercial uses only at the major intersections of McLoughlin, 17th, 13th, and the bridgehead. Many of the properties have deteriorated and problems continue to increase as the population in Clackamas County grows and traffic volumes rise. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 43 Tacoma Street has the potential to become a very pleasant public part of the neighborhood. Deteriorated properties could be redeveloped with a mix of two- to three-story buildings with some commercial uses at street level and residential uses above, creating a lively pedestrian atmosphere. The proximity of the river, parks, shopping, and bus service would make dwellings desirable to those who do not want a yard to maintain. Vision drawing showing bridgehead gateway with restaurant/pub development. (Watercolor by Mark Perepelitza.! However, until Tacoma Street and the Sellwood Bridge are relieved of the burden of regional traffic, the vision for the street and new bridge cannot be fully realized. Studies are currently under way by Metro, as well as city and county agencies, to find the best solution for a river crossing south of downtown Portland to serve regional traffic. The Sellwood Bridge and Tacoma Street location is inappropriate for the regional traffic due to capacity limitations and inefficient routing. The challenges facing the neighborhood on Tacoma Street are: • Improving the residential and commercial environment of the street • Bringing the street back into the neighborhood fabric • Reducing impacts from traffic • Reducing the role of the street as a barrier Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 44 Desired Character Tacoma Street should be returned to its intended role as a district collector, with reduced traffic loads, reduced speed limits and an increase in pedestrian access and on- street parking. Planting strips should be incorporated in areas interspersed with parking spaces and turning lanes. Mixed-use development and redevelopment should be encouraged, allowing shops to locate among the residential uses in old houses and on the first floor of residential buildings in the CM zoned areas. Commercial nodes should be dedicated to pedestrian-oriented storefront shopping. The area at the bridgehead should have commercial activity that offers public activity with a focus on the views up and down the river, such as restaurants, pubs or other community gathering spots. Architectural styles should complement the historic homes and commercial building that exist on the street. The eastern portion of the street should accommodate development that ties into the mass-transit corridor along McLoughlin. The Tacoma/McLoughlin node should balance the accommodation of higher densities with the environmental concerns for the Johnson Creek and Crystal Springs watersheds. Tacoma Street plnll study showing two through lalles of traffic, cellter tum lalles, and plantillg strips with street trees altematillg with oil-street parkillg. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 45 Policy VI: Tacoma Street Improve access to and from the neighborhood across the Willamette River for transit, bicycles, and pedestrians. Objectives: 1. Create gateways to the neighborhood at the Sellwood Bridge and at the McLoughlin overpass 2. Enhance the safety of the Sellwood Bridge for pedestrians and bicyclists 3. Reduce regional traffic on the Sellwood Bridge and Tacoma Street 4. Manage traffic on Tacoma Street consistent with the classifications for transit, bikeway, and pedestrian ways in the Transportation Element of the Comprehensive Plan 5. Improve the safety and character of pedestrian crossings across Tacoma Street 6. Encourage mixed-use (commercial/residential) development on Tacoma Street that enhances the character of the area Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 46 Tacoma Street looking west from the McLoughlin overpass. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 47 Action Chart: Tacoma Street Time # Actions PROJECTSIPROGRAMS Adopt On~ ith Plan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs TSl TS2 TS3 PrOVide safe bicycle lanes and separate pedestrian walkways on the bridge. Ensure th.at 'the design for any renovation or replacement of the Sellwood Bridge is appropriate and elegant in fomn and detailing. Support planning for translt~orienteddevelopment (T.OD.) across McLoughlin at a high~capacity transit stop just south of Tacoma. Multnomah County Multnomah County ODOT Tn~Met NOTE: Action Charts were approved by Portland City Council by resolution. They are a starting place. All actions have an Identified Implementor. They were adopted with the understanding that some will need to be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible propos.als. Identification of an implementor for an actIon IS an expression of interest and support with the understanding that Circumstances will affect the implementation leader's ability to take action. Recommended Sellwood~Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 48 PEDESTRIAN-ORIENTED COMMERCIAL AREAS Sellwood-Moreland has several separate and distinct commercial areas which are located along major north-south routes in neighborhood. Flanked by residential areas, these business districts are integral parts of the neighborhood, making important contributions to its identity, character, and livability. The commercial areas also offer the opportunity to bring more housing into the neighborhood as mixed-use development with housing above street-level retail. Many of the needs of the added residents can be met by the immediate access to bus transportation and commercial services. Milwaukie Avenue Commercial Area The Milwaukie Avenue district was developed in the 1920s, along with the Westmoreland residential area. The appeal of the area is the main street, or village square atmosphere, created by the solid row of shops along the streets radiating out from the Bybee intersection. The structures are one to two stories, largely of masonry or stucco, in 1920s and 1930s commercial styles. The core of the area is pedestrian-oriented, with lot coverage to the sidewalk edge and few breaks in the street wall. The area invites Milwaukie Avenue commercial area, looking south all Milwaukie at Glell1uood Street. Recommended Sellwood-Morelalld Neighbor/wad Plall October 1, 1997 Page 49 walking and browsing, or stopping at cafes and eateries. Many of the businesses serve needs of the neighborhood, so the district functions more as a small town main street than as a collection of boutique-style attractions. However, the area also harbors a cluster of offices and a number of restaurants that draw from well outside of the immediate area. Challenges facing the neighborhood along Milwaukie Avenue are: • Retaining the street orientation and shop front style of architecture that is characteristic of the area • Preserving businesses that serve the needs of the neighborhood • Maintaining a mix of businesses that offer variety and interest to keep up the level of pedestrian activity Seventeenth Avenue Commercial Area The 17th Avenue area serves the south end of the neighborhood with general goods and services. The district runs from Nehalem to Ochoco Street. This area is less unified, both in architectural characteristics and in uses, than the other commercial areas in the neighborhood. The pedestrian scale is strongest from Tenino Street through Sherrett Street, but development at the intersection of 17th and Tacoma is entirely auto- oriented. Older buildings are interspersed with modern buildings that are set back from the sidewalk, fronted by parking lots. These modern buildings have no special character. This area needs its own identity to spur revitalization and draw infill development. Currently a number of design services, such as lighting, furniture refinishing, and interior design are located in the district, possibly forming the nucleus for an area which complements 13th Avenue's Antique Row. There are also some businesses that serve the residents of the south end of the neighborhood. Residents would like to see more of this type of development. Traffic congestion is also a problem, especially for merchants who feel that it has a negative impact on their businesses. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 50 Seventeenth Avenue commercial area, looking north on SE 17th at Umatilla Street. Challenges facing the neighborhood in the 17th Avenue area are: • Reducing auto-dominated commercial development at the 17th and Tacoma Street intersection • Reducing the negative impacts that traffic congestion on 17th has on local businesses • Establishing an identity for the area in order to strengthen and revitalize the district • Encouraging businesses that provide services to the residents in the south end of the neighborhood • Maintaining the health of existing businesses Thirteenth Avenue Commercial Area Thirteenth Avenue is known as Sellwood's Antique Row. The 13th Avenue district runs from Malden to Harney Street, encompassing the nationally recognized Antique Row. Most of the shops have a regional draw, including the numerous antique shops, restaurants, and the Columbia Sportswear Outlet Store. There are also a laundromat, grocery store, and the neighborhood association's community facility, the SMILE Station. The buildings date from the early 1900s when the area served as the main street for the town of Sellwood. In recent years, higher rents have made success more difficult for some small locally oriented businesses. The Antique Row shops are heavily Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 51 patronized by weekend shoppers. These shops are enjoyed by local residents for the interesting displays and the upgraded business area that they have created. Vision drawing showing improved public street space at intersection of SE 13th Avenue and Tacoma Street, with consistent storefront commercial development. (Watercolor by Mark Perepelitza.! Thirteenth Avenue is a fairly densely developed district of one- to two-story buildings that mostly date from the turn of the century. This street was the main street of Sellwood from the time that the street car was introduced until about the time of its demise in the 1950s. It includes some classic main street-style masonry buildings and a large number of fragile wooden storefronts. The SMILE Station, a refurbished fire station, is a focal point just south of the key intersection at 13th and Tacoma. The street does not offer many opportunities for parking. Because it is a regional attraction, patrons drive to the district, but leave their cars and walk from shop to shop. The small storefronts retain a pedestrian scale and offer visual stimulation and variety. Challenges facing the neighborhood along 13th Avenue are: • Preserving the historic character of the commercial buildings on 13th • Filling in gaps in the street wall with compatible structures, especially at the intersection of 13th and Tacoma • Maintaining the health of the regional shopping district • Preserving businesses that serve the local neighborhood • Accommodating the parking needs of residents and visitors Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 52 Because the business districts are the most public places of the neighborhood, their character plays an important role in providing coherence and identity to the neighborhood. Good use of urban design principles gives the area a distinctive sense of being a place that is special. These principles make all the pieces of the urban scene fit together in a way that works. Desired Character The commercial areas should maintain or enhance the pedestrian-orientation of storefront shopping areas. The streetscape should have a sense of enclosure, formed by a strong building edge. Pedestrian amenities such as street furniture, planters and street trees should be emphasized. Building styles should be compatible with the historic structures that set the tone for each district. Residential and storefront commercial development along SE 13th Avenue, between Tenino and Umatilla Streets, in the commercial area. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 53 Policy VII: Balanced Growth Preserve the health and vitality of neighborhood commercial areas and maintain the balance among residential, commercial and industrial interests. Objectives: 1. Create an overall strategy and individual plans for each business district 2. Preserve the historic character and pedestrian-orientation of the neighborhood commercial areas 3. Establish focal points within each business district 4. Provide good vehicle and mass transit access to the commercial areas for customers and residents. Emphasize and promote pedestrian-oriented uses over auto-oriented uses ' 5. Reduce auto-dominance of the 17th Avenue intersection and redevelop it as the core of a revived business district that complements the 13th Avenue Antique Row and serves the local neighborhood Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 54 Action Chart: Balanced Growth Time # Actions PROJECTS/PROGRAM S Adopt On- ith Plan going Next; 6 1;0 Implement;ors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs BG 1 Develop a plan w provide a unified neighborhood identity in the business districts using elements such as sUeet; signs, light; st;andards, paving patu"ns, and hanging flower baskets, BG 2 Creat'" an urban design plan for Milwaukie Avenue w presf:rve and improve Its pedestrian character. BG 3 Creat'" an urban design plan for 13t;h Avenue, focus,ing on the Tacoma Street intersection and bring ng greater unity W 13t;h. BG 4 Creat;e an urban design plan W develop a suonger identity for the 17th Avenue commercial area. BG 5 EncoJrage development; which meets volunt;ary design gUidelines t;hat; promote and protect; t;he special character of t;he neighborhood's commercial areas. BG 6 Enhance commercial areas with street furnishings, lande,caping or decorative paving and street trees. BG 7 Make t;he SMILE St;at;ion neighborhood center inw an example of design features and amenities appropriatoe for t;he 13t;h Avenue business disuin. BG 8 Develop a neighborhood focal point; by creat;ing a public space or courtyard area wit;hln t;he SE 13th Avenue business district. BG 9 Capitalize on est;abllshed landmarks as organizing elemcnt;s (such as Johnson Jewelers clock, SMILE Station, Portland Memorial, Sellwood Community Cenwr and Oaks rark). BG 10 Work wit;h t;he Masonic 'Lodge W promoW t;he Masonic Temple on Milwaukie Avenue as a cultural cent;", for the neighborhood. BG 11 Suetlgt;hen urban design and economic funct;ion of core intersect;ions (13t;h and Tacoma. 17th and Tacoma, Milwaukie and Bybee). BG 12 Support t;he est;ablishment; of businesses that are compat;ible wit;h t;he pedesuian character of the neighborhood. BG 13 Ident;ify areas lacking in neighborhood services and promote t;he locat;ion of businesses W meet local needs. SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA SMILE SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA Parks SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA SMILE SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA SMILE 5MBA Recommended Sel/wood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 55 lime # Actions PROJECTSIPROGRAM S Adopto On- itoh Plan going Nexto 6 too 1m plementoors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs BG 14 Redevelop deuriorated propert;ies and fill in gaps witoh businesses tohato serve local needs and maintoain a diversitoy of business toypes. BG 15 Encourage tohe use of bus toransport;atoion w allevlau toraffic congestoion. BG 16 Provide an appropriate amounto of parking for cars witohouto destoroying tohe character of tohe districts. Parking shouid be behind buildings, and underground when feaSible. BG 17 PromoU shared parking facilitoles W keep overflow parking out of reSidential areas. SMILE 5MBA SMILE Tri-Met; 5MBA SMILE 5MBA NOTE: Actoion Cha'ts were approved by Pottland C,toy Council by resolutolon. They are a stoart;ing place. All actoions have an identoified Implemenwr. They were adopud with the understanding that some Will need W be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible proposals. Identification of an implementor for an action is an expression of interest and support; with tohe understoanding tohato circumstoances will affecto tohe implementation leader's abllitoy w toake actoion. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October I, 1997 Page 56 MCLOUGHLIN EDGE McLoughllin Boulevard, State Highway 99E, forms the eastern edge of the Sellwood- Moreland neighborhood. With the exception of the Westmoreland Park area, the street edge is undefined, the scale is erratic, and development patterns are unstructured with no cohesive character. The north end of this corridor has auto-oriented commercial uses. Just north of Bybee, the Westmoreland Union Manor retirement center backs on to the corridor. From Bybee to Nehalem, the road abuts Westmoreland Park where trees create a parkway environment. At Tacoma Street a new overpass, built by Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) at the scale of a freeway onramp, carries traffic over the roadway, eliminating the former signalized intersection. South of Tacoma, more commercial uses front the roadway. Many of these used to serve neighborhood needs, but now cater to the volume of McLoughlin traffic. Two sex entertainment business are located on the west side of the road. The Eastmoreland Golf Course, the Goodwill Store, and access to the Springwater Corridor are located on the east side of McLoughlin. McLoughlin Boulevard along Westmoreland Park, looking south. Johnson Creek crosses under the roadway at Tacoma and meanders to the edge of the street in several places. It is generally degraded and underutilized as an amenity in this area. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 57 The parkway character of McLoughlin along the edge of Westmoreland Park is relatively pleasant due to the canopy of large deciduous trees. This parkway character could be extended along the full length of the neighborhood to create a more humane environment. The North End and Tacoma Street overpass are potential high-capacity transit stops. These station areas offer the opportunity for mixed-use development oriented to both the neighborhood and high-capacity transit. A high-capacity transit stop is also possible at the Bybee overpass but redevelopment opportunities at that location are limited. These three locations are major entries into the neighborhood that could be developed as gateways, especially with any transportation upgrades. Challenges facing the neighborhood along the McLoughlin edge are: • Finding a way to humanize McLoughlin so that it can be an asset to the neighborhood • Finding ways to cross McLoughlin to access high-capacity transit, parks, the Springwater Corridor and other attractors on the east side of the roadway • Promoting redevelopment which is transit-oriented in response to the proposed high-capacity transit stations at the north and south ends of the neighborhood and, as much as possible without destroying natural resource areas and a stable neighborhood, at Bybee • Upgrading the environment of the Crystal Spring Creek and Johnson Creek where they are negatively impacted by McLoughlin and the adjacent development Desired Character McLoughlin is the major transportation corridor for auto and mass-transit, with heavy rail immediately adjacent to the east. It forms a boundary that is nearly as strong as the river on the west. The edges of the corridor should be screened by planting a continuous border of trees. . Access across McLoughlin should be made available at additional points by creating connections to the Springwater Corridor on the south and Crystal Springs Rhododendron Garden on the north. Desirable high-capacity transit stations are near the North End and Tacoma overpass. A Bybee station is a lesser priority. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 58 McLollghlin BOlllevard at the Bybee overpass, looking sOlllh. Policy VIlli Humanize McLoughlin Humanize McLoughlin and make it an asset to the neighborhood. Objectives: 1. Promote development at the North End and at the Tacoma Street overpass that supports high-capacity transit. Seek a high-capacity transit stop at Bybee but place priority on the other two stops 2. Provide some connections across McLoughlin for pedestrians and bicyclists 3. Create gateways to the neighborhood at the north end, Bybee overpass, and the Tacoma overpass. Take advantage of transportation improvements in creating these gateways 4. Improve the Crystal Springs Creek and Johnson Springs Creek environments Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 59 Action Chart: McLoughlin Edge Time # Actions PROJECTS/ PROGRAMS Adopt On- Ith Plan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs ME 1 Consider extending a parkway from the Westmoreland Park area south throughout the McLoughlin Edge corridor. ME 2 Restore the connection over McLoughlin to the Sprlngwat<:r Corridor as a pedestrian and bicycle pathway. ME 3 Consider major pedestrian connections over Mcloughlin to future high-capacity transit stations. ME 4 ConSider retrofitting existing overpasses at Milwaukie ~nd Bybee to better accommodate pedestrians and bicyclists. ME 5 Clean up the creek and restore its banks and st.reambed. Incorporate Johnson Creek as a focus of new development. ODOT Parks ODOT Metro ODOT Tri-Met ODOT PDOT Parks SMILE BES (JCWC) NOTE: Action Charts were approved by Portland City CounCil by resolution. They are a starting place. All actions have an identified Implementor. They were adopted with the understanding that some will need to be adjusted and others replaced with more feasible proposals. Identification of an implementor for an action is an expression of Interest and support with the understanding chat clrcumscances will affect the impiementation leader's abilicy to take action. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 60 CRYSTAL SPRINGS The Crystal Springs district parallels McLoughlin. It begins on the north at the Westmoreland Union Manor, where the creek crosses under McLoughlin and flows into the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood. It traverses Westmoreland Park, leaving the park on the south end at SE 22nd Avenue. South of the park, the creek extends between SE 21st Avenue and McLoughlin, from Lambert Street to Ochoco Street. Westmorelland Union Manor Westmoreland Union Manor is a high-rise retirement community that is situated north of Bybee Boulevard between McLoughlin and the Westmoreland residential area. Crystal Springs crosses under McLoughlin and exits the property on the south end of the manor site. Challenges facing the neighborhood at Westmoreland Union Manor are: • Creating ways to establish "bridges (i.e. social connections) between the manor population and other Sellwood-Moreland residents • Maintaining and improving services that are needed by the population at the manor The Westmoreland Union Manor Retirement Center on McLollghlin BOlllevard. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 61 Westmoreland Park Crystal Springs travels through Westmoreland Park and feeds both Westmoreland Pond and the casting pool. Large numbers of waterfowl use the streams and ponds as part of their year-round residence in the Crystal Springs and Oak Bottom area. The creek is channelized through the park, but the edges are caving in many places. Only the pond has plantings for wildlife habitat on the eastern edge. Challenges facing the neighborhood at Westmoreland Park are: • Restoring stream banks and riparian areas • Increasing storage capacity to accommodate winter flows in Crystal Springs Creek • Improving wildlife habitat characteristics Crystal Springs Residential Area The Crystal Springs residential area consists of the houses along the creek from the point where it exits at the south end of Westmoreland Park to its confluence with Johnson Creek. The stream leaves the park near Lambert Street. The SMILE fish hatchery is located just across from the park in this area. The stream passes through private property to 21st Avenue where it takes over the right-of-way between Spokane and Tacoma Streets. It passes under Tacoma in a culvert and runs next to the roadway on 21st from Tacoma to Tenino. It crosses under 21st and continues on through Crystal Springs Creek along SE 21st Avenlle sOllth of Tacoma Street. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 62 backyards and under streets and bridges to Sherrett Street, where it passes on the west side of a home and enters Johnson Creek Park. The stream runs through the park and joins Johnson Creek near the south end of the park. Challenges facing the neighborhood in the Crystal Springs residential area are: • Maintaining individual enjoyment of the stream amenity while promoting public consciousness regarding stream restoration and habitat enrichment • Preserving the SMILE fish hatchery Willsburg The Willsburg area is the western edge of the town of Willsburg, which dates from the 1800s in the McLoughlin Boulevard-Johnson Creek area, south of Tacoma Street. Johnson Creek passes through residential, commercial and industrial properties, often in a degraded condition with debris dumped in the steam bed. The creek crosses at road level at the foot of Sherrett Street, passes through to the east of a single residential unit, and enters Johnson Creek Park. Crystal Springs joins Johnson Creek at the south end of the park, and the stream continues through residential properties to the industrial area on Ochoco and then passes on to Milwaukie where it empties into the Willamette. The area consists of industrial and commercial properties, a scattering of older houses and a large project operated by the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Challenges facing the neighborhood in the Willsburg area are: • Recognizing the historic significance of Willsburg • Creating more opportunities for access to the creek and building awareness and appreciiation for Johnson Creek • Incorporating higher density housing near the future high-capacity transit station, while preserving stream habitat and protecting floodplain storage capacity • Increasing the residential and/or commercial development that utilizes the assets and pleasures of the creek environment Desired Character Crystal Springs and Johnson Creek set the tone of the subarea as a rich natural resource area in an urban setting. The Crystal Springs subarea should enhance and strengthen the unifying character of the stream corridor by employing natural materials in building construction, providing views of the stream and, where possible, public access points. All development should be designed to protect the habitat value of the watershed. Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 63 High-density concentrations in the area should focus on transit-oriented development, which is conducive to walking, bicycling and mass transit rather than automobile use. Floodplain and watershed concerns should be primary considerations in any development proposal and may limit density in some situations. Policy IX: Caring for Crystal Springs Foster community care and respect for the Crystal Springs environment. Objectives: 1. Protect the Crystal Springs greenspaces and preserve wildlife habitat 2. Increase public access to Crystal Springs and Johnson Creek Recommended Sellwood-Moreland Neighborhood Plan October 1, 1997 Page 64 Action Chart: Crystal Springs Time # Actions Adopt On- ith rlan going Next 6 to Implementors 5 Yrs 20 Yrs PRO~IECTS/ PROGRAMS CS1 rromote restoration of the habitat value of Johnson BES Creek onl 12.01 13.01 "" """'"' '.13.02 I~ 12.02 , ~, .v' ~ ~~ 9.01 B.Ol 10 --~ 9.02 " 0'<~ B.02 " "",. ~ ~ ~2 3.02~ ~ ~ East PorUand Community Plan Census Tracts East Portland Community Plan Boundary Census Tract Boundary ~ Area Outside 01 Plan Area Included In Analysis ~ Area Inside of Plan Area Excluded lrom Analysis 6 Appendix B SMILE Neighborhood Planl McLoughlin Neighborhoods Proj ecl May 28,1997 MEMORANDUM TO: FROM: Mark Bello, Planning Bureau Rich Newlands, Transportation Planning SUBJ1~CT: SMILE Neighborhood Plan/McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project Attached is the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project Implementation Strategy approved by the SMILE and Brooklyn Neighborhood Associations and adopted by City Council in July of 1995. The Strategy was developed to clarify the steps that need to be taken in order to implement the recommended transportation improvement projects contained within the origiDaLI McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project report (1983). These steps include timing (phasing), planning process, funding, and responsibilities. The original project proposed a package of transportation improvement projects to address the impacts of regional through traffic related to McLoughlin Boulevard and the Sellwood Bridge on the Sellwood-Moreland and Brooklyn neighborhoods. cc: Monique Wahba, Transportation Planning "25 - SECTION III RECOMMENDElJIMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY PROCESS , ' The conclusions of the technical and policy evaluation discussed in the previous section updated and verified the continued need for traffic management devises to address McLoughlin corridor traffic on neighborhood streets. The folloWing Recommended Implementation Strategy was developed to clarify the planning, timing (phasing), funding, approval processes, and program responsibilities to coordinate and move forward the conceptual solutions outlined in the Draft McLoughlin Neighborhoods Projects report to implementation. Phasing is a key component in the development of the Strategy. The 1983 report . allowed for phasing of projects due to various technical prerequisites, which since that time now have been completed. However, phasing of elements within the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project is still essential due to the current operating environment of constrained fiscal resources for transportation improvements which creates significant competition among projects City-wide. A Technical Advisory Committee was assembled to review and recommend a strategy which would ensure: the support and coordiliation from the City Bureaus. The Strategy was then presented to interested and involved neighborhood organizations and groups for their review and input. The main goals of the Strategy are to: • Maximize the efficiency of project implementation; • Assure coordination with other projects in the area; • Achieve support from PooT/ City to complete the projects; and • Provide public outreach - citizen involvement, distribution of information and consensus building. The structure of the Strategy is based upon the following four criteria: • Policy conformance and technical justification:, • Neighborhood priorities, within the Project • Availability of funds/cost: and • Complexity of work remaining The "policy conformance and technical justification" criterion refers to both the updating process discussed in the previous section and also further specific analysis related to individual projects, The first step in structuring a phasing plan requires that the specific problem each Project element was originally designed to address is still justified from a technical standpoint, and still complies with City -26 policy. The previous technical and policy evaluation p;rovided only verification of the general traffic conditions which were originally identified as responsible for the sp,ecific problems related to each Project element. If further technical analysis shows updated traffic conditions associated with individual problems are no longer significant or substantially similar to the conditions analyzed in 1983, then these projects will be removed from further project development. The second criterion used for the phasing plan of elements contained within the Project is "neighborhood priorities". Through the identification and ranking of local transportation priorities by the neighborhood associations, new problems or issues not specified in the 1983 report were also identified. For the purposes of developing the Strategy, these new problems and potential new projects will be assumed at this point as related to McLoughlin corridor traffic and have been preliminarily included within the scope of the Project's remaining work. However, prior to proceeding further on new projects, findings must be documented through technical and policy analyses that the recommended new projects comply with overall program goals of the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project. The new projects must be found to be related to corridor traffic infiltration on local streets or traffic diversion impacts related to other projects within the program. If these proposed new projects are found to not qualify within the McLoughlin Neighbor- hoods Project, alternative pla1'l':ning and funding programs will be identified by the City. The four new projects are: • 14th Avenue north of Bybee: cut-through traffic on local streets; • 13th Avenue north of Rex Street speeding and pedestrian safety; • Oaks Park Access Road: park access, congestion, and pedestrian/bicycle safety related to Tacoma Street traffic; and • Tacoma Corridor Plan: a multi-modal improvement plan for Tacoma with a focus on pedestrian accessibility and crossing issues. Additional new issues related to traffic conditions in the study area should be coordinated with all further work on the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project, but studied and funded separately from this program. The third criterion, "availability of funds", refers to whether there is currently speci.fied funding available to move individual projects forward, or whether a funding source needs to be determined. This criterion reflects the need of a phasing element as part of the Strategy to address the general funding limitations of the City on an annual basis and the unpredictable nature of being able to commit resources over future multiple years. The final criterion, "complexity of work remaining", pertains to the level of analysis required to evaluate the project design or to coordinate with other projects with difficult implementation issues. Some of the projects require extensive analysis, are • 27 J'0tentially inseparable from multiple other projects or are inseparable from other projects of significant scale in terms of cost or geographic extent. PHAsING Phase I Projects: • Milwaukie Pedestrian Project • 17th Avenue Project Constmction of a key element of the Milwaukie Pedestrian Program, curb extensions at the Milwaukie-Bybee intersection, is already underway. 1his Project has beE!n able to move forward on its own, mainly due to the fact that completion of the Tacoma Street Overpass was not a prerequisite. CIP funds have been used for design and construction. Relative to other Projects within the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project, the analysis and design work needed to complete the Milwaukie Pedestrian Program is minimal. The 171th Avenue Project is a major element of the Mcloughlin Neighborhoods Project and has historically been identified as a top priority of the SMILE Neighborhood Association. The Project in concept has received one of the highest rankings among the current !itt ,of Traffic Calming Program candidate projects, and is funded as a TCP project to begin project development in FY '94-95. Because of the proximity and relationship between the problems being addressed in the 17th Avenue Project and Westmoreland Park Project, data needed for the Westmoreland Park Project will be collected concurrently with data collection for the 17th Avenue Project. Phase lIT Projects: • Sellwood Blvd. Area Project • Brooklyn/Mcloughlin Project • Westmoreland Park Project • 14th Avenue north of Bybee (new project) • 13th Avenue north of Eex Street (new project) Due to the localized nature of each of the above projects, additional data collection for problem verification and, if warranted, project development is needed. While high priority projects for the neighborhoods, unlike the Phase I projecflisted above, none of-the Phase IT projects have a currently identified funding source. The Sellwood Blvd. Area Project consists of the local street elements of the Sellwood Bridge/Sellwood Blvd. Area Project identified in the 1983 report. Those elements of this former project that directly involve Tacoma Street are listed under Phase III but will likely be addressed through a separate and specific project development and funding process. 28 .Phase ill Projects: • .Linn/Marion Project • Eastmoreland Project • Tacoma Corridor Plan and Project (new project) • Oaks Park Access Road Project (new project) • Arterial and signalization elements of other projects The third phase contains those elements of the overall McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project which either entail considerably more technical analysis or policy analysis to verify, involve significant complexity for project development, are relatively expensive compared to other project elements or are significantly related to other large scale projects. Two projects, Linn/Marion and Eastmoreland, have a lower priority compared to other projects. The Linn/Marion Project is a Phase ill project . in order to accommodate new projects, 14th Avenue and 13th Avenue north of Rex Street, which are higher priority projects for the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood. The Eastmoreland Project has a lower priority within the program because of work already completed as part of the Eastmoreland NIMP Project, which addressed infiltration of non-local traffic on neighborhood streets. .. Except for the Linn/Marion and Eastmoreland Projects, it is likely that the rema'ining projects will require funding separate from the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project program. The Tacoma Corridor Plan is essentially a new project which contains the arterial elements of the Sellwood Bridge/Sellwood Blvd. Area Project identified in the 1983 report plus other improvements that may be identified for Tacoma Street. IMPLEMENTATION As stated above, the problems associated with each project, with the exception of the Milwaukie Pedestrian Project, will need to be firSt verified through additional speciific technical and policy analysis. -ptose projects which are verified will be mov,ed forward to project development. In the project development phase, the conceptual solutions proposed in the 1983 report will be considered along with new teclu:rlques. To efficiently implement the elements of the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project, it is important to establish the role and responsibility of participating City agencies and neighborhood organizations. Transportation Planning will retain overall responsibility for coordinating the implementation of all elements contained in the Strategy of the McLoughlin Neighborhoods Project, except the 17th Avenue Project, and will be the main contact between the neighborhoods and City. The 17th ,. •29 -Avenue Project will managed and implemented through the process established by " the Traffic Calming Program. Transportation Planning will be working closely with participating agencies, including the Bureau of Traffic Management and Bureau of Transportation Engineering. Representativebodi~ from the Sellwood-Moreland (SMILE) and Brooklyn (BAC) neighborhood associations will be responsible for helping to coordinate and solicit citizen involvement at the neighborhood level, from business associations and other neighborhood based subgroups. Before construction of any Project elements can occur, approval from City Council of recommended designs is required. Any new projects that are identified in the study area after this Strategy is adopted by the City Council will be added to the McLoughlin Neighborhood Project and its funding program only upon an amendment of this program and Strategy by action of the City Council. Findings must be developed to support any amendments of this program and Strategy. ORIGINAL PROJECTS Milwaukie Pedestrian Project: The Mllwaukie Pedestrian Project includes curb extensions at five other intersection locations in addition to the soon to be completed curb extensions at intersection of Milwaukie Avenue and Bybee'"Boulevard. These additional locations, two in the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood and three in the Brooklyn neighborhood, need to be verified given current land use and traffic conditions and neighborhood priorities. Remaining funds, with additional CIP dollars can also be used to finish the other curb extensions. 17th Avenue Project 'Project development and construction of the 17thAvenue Project will be managed and funded by the Traffic Calming Program. The originally recommended alternative will be reviewed along with new traffic management techniques for implementation. Detailed data collection, including volume counts, turn movements, and origin-destination surveys, to determine the relationship between through and local traffic, will be needed to evaluate design alternatives in relation to such issues as diversion, emergency vehicle response, transit service, and pedestrian and bicycle access. Adjacent local streets will also need to be monitored for diversion to other local streets. If diversion techniques are selected, they will be tested first before final construction begins. The Traffic Calming Program has a prescribed process for citizen involvement which includes public meetings, a working group for more active involvement in project development, balloting to gage support from adjacent property owners, and City Council review and approval of the proposed traffic calming plan. 30 Linn-Marion Project: Additional data collection will be needed to verify the current status of the problem. If warranted, project development will design and evaluate alternatives to address cut-through traffic south of Tacoma Street. Issues to be addressed include access impacts to commercial land uses on 17th and 13th Avenues, access to the mixed uses along the waterfront and in the vicinity of the Sellwood Bridge and po.ssible diversion of cut-through traffic to other local streets. New volume counts, tum counts and an origin"