Oregon Law Review : Vol. 87 No. 2, p.481-580 : Buying Witness Silence: Evidence-Suppressing Settlements and Lawyers’ Ethics

Show full item record

Title: Oregon Law Review : Vol. 87 No. 2, p.481-580 : Buying Witness Silence: Evidence-Suppressing Settlements and Lawyers’ Ethics
Author: Bauer, Jon
Abstract: The conventional wisdom among practitioners and legal ethics scholars has been that lawyers may ethically negotiate any settlement terms that serve their clients’ interests and are not criminal or fraudulent. (Some recent critics of settlement secrecy have argued that noncooperation settlements violate obstruction of justice statutes or other criminal laws, but the illegality argument is largely unconvincing.) This Article argues that the conventional view has looked at the problem through the wrong lens. In the ethos of the ethics codes, third party and societal interests generally take a backseat to client service, but certain types of conduct deemed especially harmful to the justice system have long been placed off-limits to lawyers because of their special role as “officers of the court.” This Article traces the history of one such duty, the principle that lawyers must not ask nonclients to refrain from voluntarily disclosing relevant information to other parties or their attorneys, and shows the important function that it plays in safeguarding the integrity of adversary adjudication. After providing a theoretical justification for liberally construing ethics rules that limit client advocacy for the sake of the adversary system’s effective functioning, this Article explores what the rules mean for settlement practices. The Conclusion addresses the critique that prohibiting lawyers from negotiating agreements that their clients could lawfully enter into on their own is either futile or paternalistic, and shows that it is neither.
Description: 94 p.
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/1794/9181
Date: 2008


Files in this item

Files Size Format View
Bauer.pdf 414.2Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)

Show full item record